Originally Posted by RedSky At Night

Here's a suggestion to counter the Evils Role claiming and its all based around the OP's.

I suggest we tell the Priests to keep quiet on all players roles (unless they're evil). Lets say as an example:

Dave the Village Whore is lynched Turn 1, Priest comes out Turn 3 and reveals that the Dave was a villager. Wilma then role claims and pretends to be the Village Whore, the Priest can then call bullshit. Job done, evil player snared. If however the Priest told us the Village Whore has already been killed, then naturally the Evil Player wouldn't role claim that specific role!

Therefore, I actually think the Priests in this game needs to be a little more cunning. Does that sound like a plan?