Quote:
Originally Posted by Spoonez el Grande
Nor should it. The top 100 might not contain a musical film, for example, so it would defeat the purpose to have top 100 selected specifically from those categories.
Best way would be to have a straight up top hundred. If there is to be a fifteen member panel, perhaps there should be some sort of voting system. Obviously, not all will agree with the final list, but that's to be expected.
|
I think it was Empire magazine that tried something like this a few months ago by going by genre...ten best films from each....but that was to identify the ideal DVD collection...so perhaps not much help here...
Or how about seeing if there 15 panel members who submit thier top 100 personal choices, then someone calculate the top 100 out of that by seeing if any films regulalrly crop up to have a definative list to chose from...I'd volunteer to do the calculating (failing that I can get some slave labour from some of my film students to do it for me...tell 'em its part of an assignment and they get a gold star if they do it quickly!). I perhaps haven't explained this clearly....
