Originally Posted by Feedingseagulls

So look at my last 4 posts - only one mention - and that when quoting another poster.

If people wanting to praise Carrick are happy to tell us (without specific reference to another midfielder perhaps) whether Carrick was right to let Gerrard go or not, and why, then I'd be happy.

They just need to be aware what that implies when they comment (or have commented) on other errors. Fair?