Thread: 99 v 08
View Single Post
Old 11th April 2008, 09:03   #52 (permalink)
CnutOfAllCnuts
Bald Boring Cnut
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 19,952
From those players picked in the initial post. Scored based on the respective seasons:

Ferguson's class of 1999


Peter Schmeichel
Not at his best in 98/99 - 8/10

Gary Neville
Has matured with age - 7/10

Jaap Stam
Was superb after a shaky start - 9/10

Ronny Johnsen
Possible his best season at United - 8/10

Denis Irwin
Legend - 9/10

Ryan Giggs
One of his best seasons - 9/10

Nicky Butt
Very good squad player - 7/10

David Beckham
His best United season - 9/10

Jesper Blomqvist
A bit rubbish - 6/10

Andy Cole
Properly hit it off this season - 9/10

Dwight Yorke
People doubted him, he proved everyone wrong - 9/10

Teddy Sheringham
Played less than people imagine, but popped up with some crucial goals at the end - 7/10

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
Didn't play as much as he deserved, in a superb season - 8/10

Roy Keane
Monster - 10/10

Paul Scholes
Was superb, but another one who matured well with age - 8/10

Total: 123 / 150


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ferguson's class of 2008


Edwin van der Sar
Is steady and provides confidence to his back four - 7/10

Wes Brown
Out of position, but has done well - 7/10

Rio Ferdinand
World class - 10/10

Nemanja Vidic
Monster - 8/10

Patrice Evra
Our best fullback since Irwin - 9/10

Paul Scholes
Less dynamic, master of the pass - 7/10

Cristiano Ronaldo
Best player in the world - 10/10

Owen Hargreaves
Not played a lot, been average - 6/10

Ryan Giggs
Coming towards the end of his career - 6/10

Wayne Rooney
He plays, we win - 8/10

Carlos Tevez
Fitted in very well - 8/10

Nani
Has settled in very well - 7/10

Anderson
Very good season for the young lad - 8/10

Michael Carrick
Been our best midfielder - 8/10

Darren Fletcher
Not played a lot, but done well whenever called upon - 7/10

Total: 116 / 150
CnutOfAllCnuts is offline   Reply With Quote