Quote:
Originally Posted by sincher
My view is that questioning why a player didn't start is just more post-match analysis. Asking if anyone knows if he's injured might just about qualify for its own thread - it will be tough to judge.
|
I just think it's unnecessary to put all post-match stuff together, it'd do more harm than good in my view. I don't see the problem with having separate threads focusing on different aspects of the post-match analysis.
Let's say someone wants to talk about how useless it is using Rooney on the wing, another poster wants to talk about how Anderson could have made a difference, then someone wants to talk about how we should have attacked some more, then there's one calling Park invisible and finally we have someone talking about how solid our defence was.
Imagine having all those different discussions in the same thread - it would be chaos, and we'd have 5 posts discussing the same subject spread over various pages - it would be much better to keep the posts re. Rooney together in one thread and praise for our defence in another, as people would then be discussing the exact same thing and don't have to look through one giant thread in order to find segments of a discussion.
Again that's just my opinion, but I really can't see any advantages of having one huge thread.