View Single Post
Old 14th May 2008, 14:16   #89 (permalink)
Sky1981
Fending Off the Urge
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: The reminiscence of long lost glory from the past
Posts: 2,850
Send a message via Skype™ to Sky1981
Quote:
Originally Posted by ERICSAGOD View Post
So answer me this hypothetical question . . .

No.2 goalkeeper doesn't play all season until the Champions League Final, during which, No.2 goalkeeper makes fantastic saves and keeps his team in the game. He then wins them the match by making two saves in the penalty shoot-out.

Does he deserve a medal?
No. Officially he does not.

If we lose stupidly to Wigan, and Chelsea nick the title, do we still win the leaque on the basis that we contribute and play better football?

Sorry, if he does makes that 2 saves, history will remember him as the man without medal who won the leaque.

That'll be all.

If by saying that a contribution is a contribution, every player who sets foot in the pitch is contributing, we can say that since we won with 2 points difference, than any sub we bring is indeed influential, since without them it can go either way.

Plus, every team got extra medal to hand to whoever they think deserves it.

PS: also in addition, if indeed PIG make that 2 saves, and he got the medal, wouldn't it be fair to the others who didn't make that glamorous 2 saves and 10 games to have got no medal ?

This will be and endless circle.
Sky1981 is offline   Reply With Quote