Youngsters - make or break time

smallred · 26th May 2008, 11:35

so, as we enter the summer transfer window, what you think will / should happen to these players who are on loan or have been sitting in the reserves all season?

wellbeck - should get 3 months at a team like Hull but chances are, he will stay in the squad and will get a few appearances here and there. overall chances of being a hit are excellent

eagles - i think his time has come to move on. i think we should sell him, maybe get 3 million for him

martin - sell to stoke perhaps, maybe get 1.5 million for him. overall, too light for united.

campbell - i think we should loan him out for another season with Hull, same as watford with foster and see how he gets on. overall chances of making - good. worth 5 million i would think, if we sold him.

dong - sell him. end of story. 2 million maximum, but we would be lucky to get 750,000. as to how he has not been loaned by now is very strange indeed.

what about the others?

thoughts please.

Cold_Boy · 26th May 2008, 12:47

Its not make or break for Welbeck.

However it surely is for Martin,Eagles,Gibson.Actually I think all of the m will be sold to championship clubs soon.

Campbell will have another year to prove himself good enough for United imo.Other wise he looks like he could have a good career at mid table clubs in premiership.

Dong,I just don't undertstand the situation.

FlawlessThaw · 26th May 2008, 12:49

Eagles will leave because his contract is up. He's been a terrific specialist reserve player though.

Martin, always thought he had a lot of talent maybe it is time for him to leave or do what Eagles did this season.

Campbell, I think he will return to us next season but if he isn't playing much then he will get loaned out come January.

Dong - Chinese

Gibson - not sure what will happen, maybe he will get loaned out.

ronnie dazzler · 26th May 2008, 15:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by smallred

so, as we enter the summer transfer window, what you think will / should happen to these players who are on loan or have been sitting in the reserves all season?

wellbeck - should get 3 months at a team like Hull but chances are, he will stay in the squad and will get a few appearances here and there. overall chances of being a hit are excellent

eagles - i think his time has come to move on. i think we should sell him, maybe get 3 million for him

martin - sell to stoke perhaps, maybe get 1.5 million for him. overall, too light for united.

campbell - i think we should loan him out for another season with Hull, same as watford with foster and see how he gets on. overall chances of making - good. worth 5 million i would think, if we sold him.

dong - sell him. end of story. 2 million maximum, but we would be lucky to get 750,000. as to how he has not been loaned by now is very strange indeed.

what about the others?

thoughts please.

wouldn't be surprised if all were sold, except for Wellbeck. Dong hasn't been on loan because he's a non EU national. I think his visa is for a specific club only an

PS18 · 27th May 2008, 00:49

too early to be loaning Welbeck out imo. would rather keep him with us until January at least, keep him training with the first team, playing for the reserves and maybe getting the odd spot on the bench for the first team.

Chris H · 27th May 2008, 02:50

I don't see a future for Simpson either. He's 21, he needs games. Not going to get them here. Too bad Keane already bought Bardsley at RB or he might've been interested again, had a good loan period there in 2006/07.

Might need another loan in order to go in the shop window, but I don't see him in a United shirt.

Cold_Boy · 27th May 2008, 05:24

Simpson is as good as gone.

He is not close to good enough.

Name Changed · 2nd June 2008, 01:50

Any chance of Macheda getting near the first team squad?

Mr. MUJAC · 2nd June 2008, 11:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Name Changed

Any chance of Macheda getting near the first team squad?

Nope!

26th May 2008, 11:35	#1 (permalink)
smallred Youth Team Player Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 288	Youngsters - make or break time so, as we enter the summer transfer window, what you think will / should happen to these players who are on loan or have been sitting in the reserves all season? wellbeck - should get 3 months at a team like Hull but chances are, he will stay in the squad and will get a few appearances here and there. overall chances of being a hit are excellent eagles - i think his time has come to move on. i think we should sell him, maybe get 3 million for him martin - sell to stoke perhaps, maybe get 1.5 million for him. overall, too light for united. campbell - i think we should loan him out for another season with Hull, same as watford with foster and see how he gets on. overall chances of making - good. worth 5 million i would think, if we sold him. dong - sell him. end of story. 2 million maximum, but we would be lucky to get 750,000. as to how he has not been loaned by now is very strange indeed. what about the others? thoughts please.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

26th May 2008, 12:47	#2 (permalink)
Cold_Boy Amit Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: somewhere i hate to live Posts: 9,830	Its not make or break for Welbeck. However it surely is for Martin,Eagles,Gibson.Actually I think all of the m will be sold to championship clubs soon. Campbell will have another year to prove himself good enough for United imo.Other wise he looks like he could have a good career at mid table clubs in premiership. Dong,I just don't undertstand the situation.

26th May 2008, 12:49	#3 (permalink)
FlawlessThaw most 'know it all' poster Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: London Posts: 10,628	Eagles will leave because his contract is up. He's been a terrific specialist reserve player though. Martin, always thought he had a lot of talent maybe it is time for him to leave or do what Eagles did this season. Campbell, I think he will return to us next season but if he isn't playing much then he will get loaned out come January. Dong - Chinese Gibson - not sure what will happen, maybe he will get loaned out.

27th May 2008, 00:49	#5 (permalink)
PS18 Reserve Team Player Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Ruud ftw Posts: 897	too early to be loaning Welbeck out imo. would rather keep him with us until January at least, keep him training with the first team, playing for the reserves and maybe getting the odd spot on the bench for the first team.

27th May 2008, 02:50	#6 (permalink)
Chris H Reserve Team Player Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: Self-imposed media blackout. Posts: 2,686	I don't see a future for Simpson either. He's 21, he needs games. Not going to get them here. Too bad Keane already bought Bardsley at RB or he might've been interested again, had a good loan period there in 2006/07. Might need another loan in order to go in the shop window, but I don't see him in a United shirt.

27th May 2008, 05:24	#7 (permalink)
Cold_Boy Amit Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: somewhere i hate to live Posts: 9,830	Simpson is as good as gone. He is not close to good enough.

2nd June 2008, 01:50	#8 (permalink)
Name Changed weso26 Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: Dublin Posts: 5,553	Any chance of Macheda getting near the first team squad?