Go Back   RedCafe.net > Football Discussion > Manchester United Forum

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 25th January 2012, 10:35   #161 (permalink)
Needs Help
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Let me please introduce myself, I'm a man of wealth and taste
Posts: 10,952
Quote:
Originally Posted by antohan View Post
Harry Gregg would shit all over any of the keepers as far as impact/contribution goes.
Not really.
narnar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 10:40   #162 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
468 appearances and 127 goals for United. My favourite player after Robson when I was growing up. Between him and Rowley that's over 300 goals for United in my front line




Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Andersen
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 11:22   #163 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,273
Sir Matt Busby's first captain, he skippered the team from 1946 till his retirement in 1953



Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Andersen
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Polaroid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 13:31   #164 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
I think Cal? is unavailable - Jayvin has been making his picks in the other draft
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 13:41   #165 (permalink)
Shit stirrer (Literally)
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Northern Ireland. W3101, Row 29, Seat 174
Posts: 5,498
Really like Polaroids team
Cutch is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 13:52   #166 (permalink)
from Redcafe (matchfixing department)
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: It's our perch now...
Posts: 19,957
Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Andersen, 8. Phil Neville
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Cal? is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 14:01   #167 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 982
Wes Brown



Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Jayvin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 14:03   #168 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 3,970
Send a message via Skype™ to Ralaks
Damn you, damn you to hell! He was going to be my next pick
Ralaks is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 14:06   #169 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
Lots of good right backs left if you use the whole of the period to choose from - it's the left side I'm worrying more about. I might end up with Ralph Milne if I'm not careful
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 14:11   #170 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 3,970
Send a message via Skype™ to Ralaks


Paul Parker

Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker,
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Ralaks is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 14:22   #171 (permalink)
Needs Help
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Let me please introduce myself, I'm a man of wealth and taste
Posts: 10,952


Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker,
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
narnar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 14:25   #172 (permalink)
Needs Help
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Let me please introduce myself, I'm a man of wealth and taste
Posts: 10,952


Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker,
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
narnar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 14:30   #173 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 3,970
Send a message via Skype™ to Ralaks
Picking Gordon McQueen



Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Ralaks is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 15:24   #174 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 982
Nice pic, Ralaks.

Tony Dunne



Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Jayvin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 15:34   #175 (permalink)
Needs Help
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Let me please introduce myself, I'm a man of wealth and taste
Posts: 10,952
I was sure Dunne had been taken earlier! Ah well, Albiston's still a good LB.
narnar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 18:07   #176 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,273
Pics for Cal's earlier picks


Polaroid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 18:13   #177 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,273
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cutch View Post
Really like Polaroids team
Thank you your vote would be very much appreciated when the matches come around as the managers have all picked very good teams and it will be a very competitive tournament
Polaroid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 18:20   #178 (permalink)
First Team Sub
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Montevideo
Posts: 5,919
Quote:
Originally Posted by narnar View Post
Not really.
If it is about legendary status based on overall contribution to the club you would have to factor in him saving Busby, Charlton and Viollet and playing on as a makeshift team started finding it's own way again.

That's more than any other keeper ever did for this club, trophies or no trophies.
antohan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 18:20   #179 (permalink)
Shit stirrer (Literally)
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Northern Ireland. W3101, Row 29, Seat 174
Posts: 5,498
Quote:
Originally Posted by Polaroid View Post
Thank you your vote would be very much appreciated when the matches come around as the managers have all picked very good teams and it will be a very competitive tournament
Aye it'll be competitive alright but i think yours is the best to date i've seen. A lot of players there that had a massive impact on the club, and can't really see a weak link.
Cutch is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 19:28   #180 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
Polaroid's turn?
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 19:42   #181 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,273
Renewing his midfield partnership with Big Dunc - Eddie 'Snakehips' Colman




Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. pending
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Polaroid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 19:48   #182 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588


Prolific left-sided forward Billy Whelan. Tragically taken from us too early in Munich


Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. pending
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Billy Whelan
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 19:57   #183 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,273
Quote:
Originally Posted by antohan View Post
If it is about legendary status based on overall contribution to the club you would have to factor in him saving Busby, Charlton and Viollet and playing on as a makeshift team started finding it's own way again.

That's more than any other keeper ever did for this club, trophies or no trophies.
Hero of Munich
For the purpose of this tournament though, voters only need to consider Gregg the footballer. I will add the word "footballing" such that it will read "overall footballing impact/contributions to United" in the match threads

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cutch View Post
Aye it'll be competitive alright but i think yours is the best to date i've seen. A lot of players there that had a massive impact on the club, and can't really see a weak link.
Thank you very much, 3 more players to pick, hope I can keep it that way
Polaroid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 20:01   #184 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,273
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crustanoid View Post


Prolific left-sided forward Billy Whelan. Tragically taken from us too early in Munich


Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. pending
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Billy Whelan
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Crustanoid, he has less than 100 appearances for United
Polaroid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 20:05   #185 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
Quote:
Originally Posted by Polaroid View Post
Crustanoid, he has less than 100 appearances for United
OK going for my back up left winger David Pegg

Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 20:09   #186 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. pending
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. David Pegg
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 22:01   #187 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 982
Already got Pegg several turns ago, Crustanoid.
Jayvin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 22:04   #188 (permalink)
First Team Sub
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Manchester
Posts: 6,720
Anyone going to be around late tonight? Will send my picks to them as I am off soon
DanNistelrooy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 22:18   #189 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 982
Yeah PM me, DanNistelrooy.
Jayvin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 23:27   #190 (permalink)
First Team Sub
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Montevideo
Posts: 5,919
Quote:
Originally Posted by Polaroid View Post
Hero of Munich
For the purpose of this tournament though, voters only need to consider Gregg the footballer. I will add the word "footballing" such that it will read "overall footballing impact/contributions to United" in the match threads
Fair enough.

Any plans to track down the "golden oldies" on the Caf? Polls aside, it would add a different dimension to the comparisons/exchange of views if we had people who have actually seen the lot (or most) of them.

I would find it very difficult to actually cast a vote based on google knowledge, but would certainly be interested to see what they have to say.
antohan is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 23:39   #191 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jayvin View Post
Already got Pegg several turns ago, Crustanoid.
Fuck just seen this - need to do some research or it's going to be Ralphie
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 23:43   #192 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588


Gordon Hill

Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. pending
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Gordon Hill
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 23:45   #193 (permalink)
First Team Regular
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 13,588
I PMed Cling Bak at 8:00 if that is relevant
Crustanoid is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 23:46   #194 (permalink)
Needs Help
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Let me please introduce myself, I'm a man of wealth and taste
Posts: 10,952
Quote:
Originally Posted by Polaroid View Post
Pics for Cal's earlier picks

How can we be sure he didn't mean Vivian?
narnar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 25th January 2012, 23:55   #195 (permalink)
Needs Help
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Let me please introduce myself, I'm a man of wealth and taste
Posts: 10,952
Quote:
Originally Posted by antohan View Post
If it is about legendary status based on overall contribution to the club you would have to factor in him saving Busby, Charlton and Viollet and playing on as a makeshift team started finding it's own way again.

That's more than any other keeper ever did for this club, trophies or no trophies.
Yea, and I do appreciate what he did for the club. As well as playing in the make shift team, he helped pull people out of the plane after it had crashed. It's hard to imagine what went through his head as he lined up again at Old Trafford, having seen his team mates die around him.

I just think it's a bit unfair to use that experience against the other keepers, and claim he "shits all over them". What happened was a massive misfortune and I very much doubt he sees himself as a hero for what happened.
narnar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 26th January 2012, 00:09   #196 (permalink)
Hi, I'm Barry Scott
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 6,391
David Sadler




Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. Henning Berg
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Gordon Hill
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey, 9. David Sadler
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen

Last edited by Cling Bak; 26th January 2012 at 00:37. Reason: Berg added
Cling Bak is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 26th January 2012, 00:31   #197 (permalink)
from Redcafe (matchfixing department)
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: It's our perch now...
Posts: 19,957
Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. Henning Berg
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Gordon Hill
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey, 9. David Sadler
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. O'Shea, 8. Olsen
Cal? is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 26th January 2012, 00:48   #198 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Australia
Posts: 982
DanNistelrooy picks...

Ray Wilkins



and...

Kevin Moran



Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. Henning Berg
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Gordon Hill
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey, 9. David Sadler
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. John O'Shea, 8. Jesper Olsen 9. Ray Wilkins 10. Kevin Moran
Jayvin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 26th January 2012, 01:09   #199 (permalink)
Hi, I'm Barry Scott
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 6,391
Noel Cantwell




Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. Henning Berg
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Gordon Hill
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey, 9. David Sadler, 10. Noel Cantwell
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. John O'Shea, 8. Jesper Olsen 9. Ray Wilkins 10. Kevin Moran
Cling Bak is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 26th January 2012, 05:42   #200 (permalink)
Reserve Team Player
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,273


David Herd - 1963 FA Cup Final match-winner, 145 goals in 265 appearances for United, the fourth best scoring ratio after Law, Van Nistelrooy and Taylor

Narnar: 1. Peter Schmeichel, 2. Jaap Stam, 3. Norman Whiteside, 4. Dwight Yorke, 5. Andrew Cole, 6. Lou Macari, 7. Sammy McIlroy, 8. Arthur Albiston, 9. Shay Brennan
Ralaks: 1. Eric Cantona, 2. Pat Crerand, 3. Denis Irwin, 4. Darren Fletcher, 5. Dennis Viollet 6. Lee Sharpe, 7. Ji-Sung Park, 8. Paul Parker, 9. Gordon McQueen
Jayvin: 1. George Best, 2. Paul Ince, 3. Rio Ferdinand, 4. Tommy Taylor, 5. Gary Neville 6. Nicky Butt 7. David Pegg 8. Wes Brown 9. Tony Dunne
Cal?: 1. Cristiano Ronaldo, 2. Wayne Rooney, 3. Nemanja Vidic, 4. Van der Sar, 5. Michael Carrick 6. Ronny Johnsen, 7. Anderson, 8. Phil Neville, 9. Henning Berg
Polaroid: 1. Ryan Giggs, 2. Duncan Edwards, 3. David Beckham, 4. Paul McGrath, 5. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, 6. Patrice Evra, 7. Harry Gregg, 8. Johnny Carey, 9. Eddie Colman, 10. David Herd
Crustanoid: 1. Bryan Robson, 2. Paul Scholes, 3. Martin Buchan, 4. Steve Bruce, 5. Steve Coppell, 6. Alex Stepney, 7. Jack Rowley, 8. Brian McClair, 9. Gordon Hill, 10. pending
Cling Bak: 1. Bobby Charlton, 2. RvN, 3. Bill Foulkes, 4. Nobby Stiles, 5. Luis Nani, 6. Teddy Sheringham, 7. Johnny Berry, 8. Gary Bailey, 9. David Sadler, 10. Noel Cantwell
DanNistelrooy: 1. Denis Law, 2. Roy Keane, 3. Gary Pallister, 4. Mark Hughes, 5. Roger Byrne, 6. Andrei Kanchelskis, 7. John O'Shea, 8. Jesper Olsen 9. Ray Wilkins 10. Kevin Moran
Polaroid is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

 


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:12.

Back to top


Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO