Player Ratings

sincher · 3rd May 2007, 00:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sultan

He should have been replaced with Richardson after about 10 minutes.

Wow. That's prettay prettay bad.

Sultan · 3rd May 2007, 00:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by ricardinho

everyone was poor.but it seems that Scholes cant do no wrong in this forum even when he has a bad game .

Some were more poor than others.

Scholes was by far the best player playing for United, by some distance.

Did Scholes not finish third in the PFA awards?

CheadleBeagle · 3rd May 2007, 00:49

Everyone a 4 except VDS -6, Scholes-7, Rooney-5.

They all looked like they had no emotion and no energy.Perhaps too many matches lately coming from behind. You can't keep doing that. Hope they show up for City.

sidsutton · 3rd May 2007, 01:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by golden_blunder

VDS 7 - kept United in it..unfortunately his colleagues didnt step it up to match
OShea 5 - gave the ball away a lot
Vidic 5 - Kaka went around him as if he wasnt there at times. Got better as the game went on. Rusty.
Brown 4 - was he playing?
Heinze 4 - his first half performance actually made me angry. Kept giving 'hospital balls'. Complete liability and if that had been Mickey Silvestre he would have been hung,drawn and quartered by the cafites.
Fletcher 6 - one of few to come out with a little credit. worked his socks off
Carrick 5 - poor game. Needed to be a lion but instead was a mouse.
Scholes 7 - best United player on pitch...but that wasnt saying a lot
Ronaldo 4 - awful touch, sloppy passing
Giggs 4 - gave the ball away more than he actually passed to his colleagues
Rooney 5 - why, why, why do we keep isolating him on his own against arguably the best defence around?

Management: 3
I thought we were going to have a go? Lined up defensively, left Rooney on his own, no surprise the ball kept coming back. Their fullbacks were allowed to bomb forward. Why wait to 15 mins from time to make a sub?
Dare i say it, Smithy should have been on to kick a few of the cunts.

Nice one Geebs, pretty accurate. I`d drop Fletcher down to a 5. and Carrick to a 4. Agree big time about the management.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Feed Me

sometimes the boss can do no more than send the players out. it's too easy to blame fergie. the buck stops with the players ultimately.

sometimes I feel that is about all Fergie`s tactics amount to: send the players out and hope they play they play well. It was truly bizarre, his refusal to make any changes until 75mins.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Livvie

In that case, there should have been a lot more knighthoods handed out in 1999.

When a team does well, it's the manager who gets a lot of the credit, so why not a share of the blame too?

He should get a share.

Plechazunga · 3rd May 2007, 01:07

VDS - did nowt wrong
Sheasy - lacked his usual composure
Wes - only defender who turned up at all...still pretty crap; orange
Vidic - crap
Heinze - sorry all you Gaby enthusiasts, but I hope that's the last time I see him in a European match. Not a top-level full-back.
Carrick - never at the races
Scholes - absolute class
Fletcher - didn't half try, but failed
Rooney - not that bad but not very good either
Ronaldo - terrible
Giggs - even worse

Fuck

Romaleouf · 3rd May 2007, 02:40

VDS 6 - might have done more to prevent the third goal

JOS 5 - some times played ridiculous balls upfield instead of keeping it simple on the ground
WB 5 - some good tackles, overall did not make the defense confident
NV 5 - still in need of match practice
GH 4 - more was expected of him

DF 4 - a decent player but when switch to the right wing was an absolute liability to the team. screwed the layoff from Rooney which could have meant an away goal to build upon. Gave possession away with a wayward pass while attacking which resulted in the 3rd goal. Passed to own defenders in tight situations which led to Heinze's disaster. But, still the usual huff and puff, engine, around the pitch.
PS 6 - just could not exert himself, perhaps the yellow hanging over his head did affect his performance.
MC 5 - stray passes, and slow reaction from a normally efficient Carrick
RG 5 - Never really get into the game, opted for the fancy when a simple pass would have suffice.

CR 5 - tried too hard to run at the Italians, and with Gattuso double-teaming against him, it was going to be futile.
WR 6 - playing the lone striker is not suitable for Rooney, he would have been better if he was paired with Saha or Smith.

LS 6 - No impact

kelvinhole · 3rd May 2007, 06:36

VDS 7.5 - Kept us in it at 2-0 down. Solid throughout.
OShea 5.5 - Kept giving the ball away
Vidic 4.5 - Dominated by Kaka. Lacks match fitness
Brown 5 - Not very good
Heinze 3.5 - Absolute tripe
Fletcher 6.5 - Hard worker, had his moments here and there
Carrick 4.5 - Invisible
Scholes 6.5 - Our best player on the night, not saying much though
Ronaldo 5.5 - Not the 'best player in the world', that's for sure
Giggs 4 - Slow
Rooney 5 - Isolated, worked his balls off all the same but made little happen against a comfortable Milan defense

Saha 5 - Too little too late. Did little of note

Shambolic

Freak · 3rd May 2007, 07:10

VDS - 6: His defenders let him down.
O'Shea - 5: Get ball, hoof.
Vidic - 5: Rusty. Struggled with the pace of kaka.
Brown - 5: Pretty shit.
Heinze - 4: Worst player on the pitch.
Carrick - 5: Quite a poor performance.
Scholes - 7: Best united player. Worked his socks off.
Fletcher - 6: Worked very hard.
Giggs - 5: Gave the ball away cheaply on most occasions.
Ronaldo - 5: Quite shit.
Rooney - 5: Crowded out by the milan defence.

Fergie - 4: Why the feck do you wait until 75 minutes to bring on saha?

CnutOfAllCnuts · 3rd May 2007, 07:21

van der Sar - 7

O'Shea - 5
Heinze - 3
Brown - 6
Vidic - 6

Fletcher - 6
Scholes - 5
Carrick - 4

Giggs - 5
Rooney - 4
Ronaldo - 4

ILBB15 · 3rd May 2007, 07:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by noodlehair

VDS - 6 Goalkeeper

O'Shea - 6 Didn't really do much
Brown - 5 Joined Giggsy and Carrick unerneath their rock
Vidic - 5 "Better than Ferdinand" - My arse
Heinze - 4 Embarrassing and a liability. What's happened to him lately?

Carrick - 5 May aswell not have bothered
Scholes - 8 Terrific effort. The only thing that stopped Milan completely swamping the pitch
Fletcher - 6 Tried, got his arse handed to him

Ronaldo - 5 PASS THE FUCKING BALL!!
Giggs - 5 "uh oh, the ball's coming towards me again"
Rooney - 6 Admirable effort, but nullified by Milan

Gattuso - Psychopath
Inzaghi - Really crap
Ref - Surprisingly decent

Dont judge him because of this game, that´s pretty unfair.

When you´ve been away for a month or something like that and come directly in to a champions league game, you´re not the same player.

Livvie · 3rd May 2007, 08:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by ILBB15

Dont judge him because of this game, that´s pretty unfair.

When you´ve been away for a month or something like that and come directly in to a champions league game, you´re not the same player.

Absolutely.

He's been our best defender all season, but he can't be match fit. Or any kind of fit.

Red Indian Chief Torn Rubber · 3rd May 2007, 09:30

VDS 7 - kept United in it..with little help from his back four
OShea 5 - gave the ball away a too much
Vidic 5 - Too rusty. Missed Rio badly.
Brown: 1 - He get one for just being on pitch. Useless

Heinze 5 - Terrible first half. Gave away the ball. Caused the second goal with stupid pass into our box. A liability like Silvestre at center half. Stepped up second half but the damage was done. Sillvestre would have done better than him tonight at left back. I'm certain. I still feel he is our best left back on recent evidence. That injured Frenchman.....

Fletcher 7 - one of few to come out with a little credit. worked his socks off
Carrick 4 - Poor game. Out classed.
Scholes 7 - best United player on pitch...
Ronaldo 4 - awful touch, sloppy passing..His worst United game of the season
Giggs 0 - He was the captain. showed no leadership no drive. Couldn't pass, control the ball or beat a man. Worst game of his career imo...

Rooney 5 - why, why, why do we keep isolating him on his own against arguably the best defence around?

Worse still why the fuck did he go for a bicycle kick when the logical thing as to head the ball

Management: 2

We were going to have a go eh?

Lined up defensively, Rooney on his own, standing off rather than closing down as a team, too deep in our own half. Concede a goal with in 15 minutes

. No wonder Milan had all that space to curve us open. Their fullbacks were allowed to bomb forward into acres of space because we lacked natural width and this standing off crap. .. Worse still they waited to 15 mins from time to make a sub?

Why not arrest the slide at halftime by bringing on Rio, Saha and Smith for the ineffective Giggs, Carrick and Brown? Questions, questions....

Wizard Keyaz · 3rd May 2007, 09:41

The whole team ges 4/10 from me.

When the fuck have we had Rooney playing as a lone striker and we won the game comfortably?

Salvation · 3rd May 2007, 09:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plechazunga

Wes - only defender who turned up at all...still pretty crap; orange

The above summed up Wesley's performance yesterday

VdS - Steady in every game, which is a huge improvement from Carroll and Howard or even Barthez but I have seen all three of them pull off some blinders. Better than most keepers around, not in the class of Cech and co. and currently not even Freidel. As I said before, at times I do hope he pulls off a blinder in a game

O'Shea - No composure which summed up the defence
Vidic - Not match fit. Clearly lacked a yard of pace
Heinze - Woeful. Still, huge overreactions by many.

Fletcher - Put some effort into it. Which was better than anyone in the team
Carrick - Read Brown
Scholes - Was the only player looking to do something in the second half. Rubbish first

Ronaldo - Worst game of the season, by a country mile
Giggs - Poor. Gave away possession far to cheaply
Rooney - Out of position, hence rubbish

Fergie/Queiroz - idiots. All season long we have attacked our way out to beat teams. Tried to see of the game

Ringo 07 · 3rd May 2007, 16:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by Parks Life

Scholes was miles better than Pirlo, in both games.

everyone was poor.but it seems that Scholes cant do no wrong in this forum even when he has a bad game .

Apart from last night where weve lost the game in defense and midfield - its fair to say that being over run by well organized midfields has been our downfall in europe over the years. Midfield is where the likes of liverpool,chelsea and Milan win their games in europe. In 99 the only powerful organised midfield we came up against was Bayern in the final. So in ten years we have suffered at the hands of Monaco, Leverkusen, Dortmund, Milan x2, Real x 2, Potro, Benfica, Bayern etc And I believe that scholes inability to control a midfield against powerful opposition has been one of the main factors. Fergies midfield tactics are also a factor. Scholes attacking game and vision is second to none and he played 1 or 2 decent passes last night but that was about it. Pirlo for example is stong in both attack and defense even though he has seedorf and gattuso beside him

rednev · 3rd May 2007, 16:05

VDS 7

OShea 5
Vidic 4.5
Brown 5
Heinze 5

Fletcher 6
Carrick 5
Scholes 7
Ronaldo 5
Giggs 5

Rooney 5

Saha 5

Fearless · 3rd May 2007, 16:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by sincher

I've chosen to invert my view of this match.

United:
VDS - 7 Nothing much to do. Looked oddly black.
O'Shea - 7 Something Oddo about him in this match.
Heinze - 7 Got forward well.
Brown - 7 Not much to do but coped well. Weirdly non-orange.
Vidic - 7 Looked a bit greasy, but kept it tight.
Carrick - 9 An absolute monster. Must have grown his beard overnight, and strangely become a hairy dwarf.
Scholes - 7 Shite free-kicks. Good to see him rid of his ginger hair though.
Fletcher - 7 Looked like the tall one out of Dumb and Dumber, but did ok.
Ronaldo - 9 Superb finish for the first goal
Giggs - 8 Showed his class.
Rooney - 7 Like a weird flea.

subs:

Saha - 7 Took his goal well

Milan:

Dida - 6 OK
Oddo - 4 Spooned it upfield most of the game, not comfortable at this level
Jankulovski - 4 Woeful passing, though thought the first goal was Nesta's fault
Kaladze - 5 Orange
Nesta - 5 Didn't look fit, and made some rash challenges
Gattuso - 4 Didn't get any time on the ball, and showed that he needs it
Pirlo - 6 Their best player - ginger
Ambrosini - 5 Decent work rate and passing, not really at fault
Kaka - 5 Disappointing. Kept trying to do it all himself. It's a team game, not an ego trip.
Seedorf - 5 Not much cop
Inzaghi - 5 Not really in the game

Subs:

Gilardino - Had no effect.

All in all, I thought it was a great 3-0 win for the lads in black.

I agree.

Milans lack of history, experience and finesse was terribly exposed.

Their total reliance on the long ball explains just why Serie A is an inferior, obselecent product compared to the Prem.

Bit off far more than they could chew.

Raven_Blade · 3rd May 2007, 16:48

Manchester United Ratings

Van Der Sar - 6: Couldnt really do much more. Heavily let down by team.

O'Shea - 4: Bad Defensive Play. Bad Attacking Play.
Vidic - 4: Lacking everything. Slow, Out of sorts due to time out injured.
Brown - 5: Best defender. Overall poor game though.
Heinze - 4: Awful Game. Defending sloppy. Distribution wayward.

Carrick - 4: Stage Fright. Couldnt pass or play for shit.
Scholes - 6: Best of a bad bunch. Which doesnt say much.
Fletcher - 5: Ran about and worked hard enough. Quality was not there.

Giggs - 4: Experience didnt show through at all. Played like a newbie.
Ronaldo - 4: Why you gotta be Anonymous? Shockingly bad.
Rooney - 5: Bad service-He is not fookin Crouch! Still woeful though.

An Absolutely Disgraceful Night of Shame

Ixion · 3rd May 2007, 16:50

Surprised Scholes is getting decent rating to be honest, I really don't think he stood out any more than anyone else.

Ole_Gunnar · 3rd May 2007, 17:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by vuc

Fucking spot on

Quote:

Originally Posted by ricardinho

everyone was poor.but it seems that Scholes cant do no wrong in this forum even when he has a bad game .

He was the only who didn't panic on the football, looked like he had time and tried his best to make things happened. Looking around him for something to aim at but there was nothing for him. He was the captain of a sinking ship and to see Gattuso rubbing it in his face made me

as fook!!!!!!!!!!!!

MrK · 3rd May 2007, 17:41

Strange. Lots of people are saying Brown was rubbish and invisible, others are saying he was united's best defender/player. I didn't really notice him that much myself, especially for the third goal, so what did he do so well?

Davo · 3rd May 2007, 18:11

VDS 7

O'Shea 6
Brown 5 - better than Carra
Vidic 5 - slow
Heinze 4 - pub player

Fletcher 5 - Fletcher
Carrick 5 - Carrick
Scholes 6 - great effort, little end product

Ronaldo 5
Rooney 5
Giggs 5

That was absurdly easy for Milan. I'm sure you're already aware of this...

Sultan · 3rd May 2007, 18:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fearless

I agree.

Milans lack of history, experience and finesse was terribly exposed.

Their total reliance on the long ball explains just why Serie A is an inferior, obselecent product compared to the Prem.

Bit off far more than they could chew.

Stick to the CE forum.

DanNistelrooy · 3rd May 2007, 18:18

VDS - 7 mom. Solid
O'shea - 5.5 Defensively good, with the ball awful
Vidic - 5 Wasn't fit, sloppy
Brown - 5 Never got going
Heinze - 4 Terrible
Ronaldo - 4 Same as above
Scholes - 7 Feel sorry for him. Deserves to play in a CL final, worked his sicks off
Carrick - 5 Never got going
Fletcher - 5.5 Worked hard
Giggs - 4 Awful
Rooney - 5 FFS he's not a striker who holds the ball up with his back to goal.

Raven_Blade · 3rd May 2007, 18:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by MrK

Strange. Lots of people are saying Brown was rubbish and invisible, others are saying he was united's best defender/player. I didn't really notice him that much myself, especially for the third goal, so what did he do so well?

He was our best defender on the night. But overall our defensive players were quite woeful. Brown was less sloppy than the others.

3rd May 2007, 00:49	#43 (permalink)
CheadleBeagle Reserve Team Player Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: Only in Canada. Pity! Posts: 1,215	Everyone a 4 except VDS -6, Scholes-7, Rooney-5. They all looked like they had no emotion and no energy.Perhaps too many matches lately coming from behind. You can't keep doing that. Hope they show up for City.

3rd May 2007, 01:07	#45 (permalink)
Plechazunga Phones, soup, paint and chairs are troubling. Join Date: May 2003 Location: In the principality is chief executive of David evroshampiona Gil. Posts: 49,809	VDS - did nowt wrong Sheasy - lacked his usual composure Wes - only defender who turned up at all...still pretty crap; orange Vidic - crap Heinze - sorry all you Gaby enthusiasts, but I hope that's the last time I see him in a European match. Not a top-level full-back. Carrick - never at the races Scholes - absolute class Fletcher - didn't half try, but failed Rooney - not that bad but not very good either Ronaldo - terrible Giggs - even worse Fuck

3rd May 2007, 02:40	#46 (permalink)
Romaleouf Reserve Team Player Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: 80 miles off Equator Posts: 968	VDS 6 - might have done more to prevent the third goal JOS 5 - some times played ridiculous balls upfield instead of keeping it simple on the ground WB 5 - some good tackles, overall did not make the defense confident NV 5 - still in need of match practice GH 4 - more was expected of him DF 4 - a decent player but when switch to the right wing was an absolute liability to the team. screwed the layoff from Rooney which could have meant an away goal to build upon. Gave possession away with a wayward pass while attacking which resulted in the 3rd goal. Passed to own defenders in tight situations which led to Heinze's disaster. But, still the usual huff and puff, engine, around the pitch. PS 6 - just could not exert himself, perhaps the yellow hanging over his head did affect his performance. MC 5 - stray passes, and slow reaction from a normally efficient Carrick RG 5 - Never really get into the game, opted for the fancy when a simple pass would have suffice. CR 5 - tried too hard to run at the Italians, and with Gattuso double-teaming against him, it was going to be futile. WR 6 - playing the lone striker is not suitable for Rooney, he would have been better if he was paired with Saha or Smith. LS 6 - No impact

3rd May 2007, 06:36	#47 (permalink)
kelvinhole Hello Kevin Join Date: Oct 2003 Location: Hong Kong Posts: 5,340	VDS 7.5 - Kept us in it at 2-0 down. Solid throughout. OShea 5.5 - Kept giving the ball away Vidic 4.5 - Dominated by Kaka. Lacks match fitness Brown 5 - Not very good Heinze 3.5 - Absolute tripe Fletcher 6.5 - Hard worker, had his moments here and there Carrick 4.5 - Invisible Scholes 6.5 - Our best player on the night, not saying much though Ronaldo 5.5 - Not the 'best player in the world', that's for sure Giggs 4 - Slow Rooney 5 - Isolated, worked his balls off all the same but made little happen against a comfortable Milan defense Saha 5 - Too little too late. Did little of note Shambolic

3rd May 2007, 07:10	#48 (permalink)
Freak Born a freak always a freak. Join Date: May 2004 Location: C.Ronaldo > England! Posts: 8,063	VDS - 6: His defenders let him down. O'Shea - 5: Get ball, hoof. Vidic - 5: Rusty. Struggled with the pace of kaka. Brown - 5: Pretty shit. Heinze - 4: Worst player on the pitch. Carrick - 5: Quite a poor performance. Scholes - 7: Best united player. Worked his socks off. Fletcher - 6: Worked very hard. Giggs - 5: Gave the ball away cheaply on most occasions. Ronaldo - 5: Quite shit. Rooney - 5: Crowded out by the milan defence. Fergie - 4: Why the feck do you wait until 75 minutes to bring on saha?

3rd May 2007, 07:21	#49 (permalink)
CnutOfAllCnuts Bald Boring Cnut Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 21,096	van der Sar - 7 O'Shea - 5 Heinze - 3 Brown - 6 Vidic - 6 Fletcher - 6 Scholes - 5 Carrick - 4 Giggs - 5 Rooney - 4 Ronaldo - 4

3rd May 2007, 09:30	#52 (permalink)
Red Indian Chief Torn Rubber Thus says Kemo Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: Football Fanatics Central..Equator branch Posts: 20,870	VDS 7 - kept United in it..with little help from his back four OShea 5 - gave the ball away a too much Vidic 5 - Too rusty. Missed Rio badly. Brown: 1 - He get one for just being on pitch. Useless Heinze 5 - Terrible first half. Gave away the ball. Caused the second goal with stupid pass into our box. A liability like Silvestre at center half. Stepped up second half but the damage was done. Sillvestre would have done better than him tonight at left back. I'm certain. I still feel he is our best left back on recent evidence. That injured Frenchman..... Fletcher 7 - one of few to come out with a little credit. worked his socks off Carrick 4 - Poor game. Out classed. Scholes 7 - best United player on pitch... Ronaldo 4 - awful touch, sloppy passing..His worst United game of the season Giggs 0 - He was the captain. showed no leadership no drive. Couldn't pass, control the ball or beat a man. Worst game of his career imo... Rooney 5 - why, why, why do we keep isolating him on his own against arguably the best defence around? Worse still why the fuck did he go for a bicycle kick when the logical thing as to head the ball Management: 2 We were going to have a go eh? Lined up defensively, Rooney on his own, standing off rather than closing down as a team, too deep in our own half. Concede a goal with in 15 minutes . No wonder Milan had all that space to curve us open. Their fullbacks were allowed to bomb forward into acres of space because we lacked natural width and this standing off crap. .. Worse still they waited to 15 mins from time to make a sub? Why not arrest the slide at halftime by bringing on Rio, Saha and Smith for the ineffective Giggs, Carrick and Brown? Questions, questions....

3rd May 2007, 09:41	#53 (permalink)
Wizard Keyaz Caf's Confucious Join Date: Dec 2003 Location: To overcome evil with good is good, to resist evil by evil is evil - Mohammed (PBUH) Posts: 10,740	The whole team ges 4/10 from me. When the fuck have we had Rooney playing as a lone striker and we won the game comfortably?

3rd May 2007, 16:05	#56 (permalink)
rednev First Team Sub Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: North Wales Posts: 5,645	VDS 7 OShea 5 Vidic 4.5 Brown 5 Heinze 5 Fletcher 6 Carrick 5 Scholes 7 Ronaldo 5 Giggs 5 Rooney 5 Saha 5

3rd May 2007, 16:48	#58 (permalink)
Raven_Blade Attention Whoring Common Crow Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: In Man Utd's Defence. Posts: 18,234	Manchester United Ratings Van Der Sar - 6: Couldnt really do much more. Heavily let down by team. O'Shea - 4: Bad Defensive Play. Bad Attacking Play. Vidic - 4: Lacking everything. Slow, Out of sorts due to time out injured. Brown - 5: Best defender. Overall poor game though. Heinze - 4: Awful Game. Defending sloppy. Distribution wayward. Carrick - 4: Stage Fright. Couldnt pass or play for shit. Scholes - 6: Best of a bad bunch. Which doesnt say much. Fletcher - 5: Ran about and worked hard enough. Quality was not there. Giggs - 4: Experience didnt show through at all. Played like a newbie. Ronaldo - 4: Why you gotta be Anonymous? Shockingly bad. Rooney - 5: Bad service-He is not fookin Crouch! Still woeful though. An Absolutely Disgraceful Night of Shame

3rd May 2007, 16:50	#59 (permalink)
Ixion Reserve Team Player Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Greater Manchester Posts: 3,492	Surprised Scholes is getting decent rating to be honest, I really don't think he stood out any more than anyone else.

3rd May 2007, 17:41	#61 (permalink)
MrK Reserve Team Player Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: In an aeroplane over the sea Posts: 541	Strange. Lots of people are saying Brown was rubbish and invisible, others are saying he was united's best defender/player. I didn't really notice him that much myself, especially for the third goal, so what did he do so well?

3rd May 2007, 18:11	#62 (permalink)
Davo Still waiting for my team to make a title challenge. Join Date: Feb 2000 Location: It's Ours For Keeps Posts: 55,283	VDS 7 O'Shea 6 Brown 5 - better than Carra Vidic 5 - slow Heinze 4 - pub player Fletcher 5 - Fletcher Carrick 5 - Carrick Scholes 6 - great effort, little end product Ronaldo 5 Rooney 5 Giggs 5 That was absurdly easy for Milan. I'm sure you're already aware of this...

3rd May 2007, 18:18	#64 (permalink)
DanNistelrooy First Team Sub Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: London Posts: 5,761	VDS - 7 mom. Solid O'shea - 5.5 Defensively good, with the ball awful Vidic - 5 Wasn't fit, sloppy Brown - 5 Never got going Heinze - 4 Terrible Ronaldo - 4 Same as above Scholes - 7 Feel sorry for him. Deserves to play in a CL final, worked his sicks off Carrick - 5 Never got going Fletcher - 5.5 Worked hard Giggs - 4 Awful Rooney - 5 FFS he's not a striker who holds the ball up with his back to goal.