Should VDS be beaten and sunk in the Irwell?

DanNistelrooy · 25th April 2007, 16:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by One United

yeah yeah yeah...so you lot support this cunt? He has been a clown show for the last 4 matches he has played and only our attack has saved us. You can take him and Rio and shove them firmly up your ass. They both will be happy there because they both stink of shite when they play.

He couldn't do anything about the 2 goals yesterday and he didn't take out Heinze, he went down and got the ball, which is actually very good goalkeeping, Kaka pushed Heinze who jumped over to avoid a collision. And he was our best player vs Boro, and without him the point difference with Chelsea could be 2 points not 3.

He has quite clearly had an outstanding season, remember he kept us in the game at Anfield, with that unbelievable save vs Crouch. I have full confidence in him, despite his recent errors.

jbuuty · 25th April 2007, 17:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by One United

Has Van Der Sar been bought off? He keeps like a granny! I have tried to forgive the embarrassment of Wet Ham in December. I have tolerated the 'shakey' this and that talk but own goal in Pompey? Punching out the ball in the CL and still doing it in the Premiership costing us another loss? He almost took Heinze out today. He is a fucking menace to our chances. He is highly over rated and should be removed. I have no faith in him anymore.

While there are some exaggerations and silliness in this post, there is some truth also. If we had someone like Petr Cech in goal we'd be at least 8 points clear of Chelsea, and quite possibly up 2 goals in front of Milan right now. The first goal by Kaka was stoppable, though it would have taken a good save.

I wonder if age and knocks are catching up to VDS. It seems that his form has dropped this past month. A weakened back four may contribute to it, but now is when we need him to be virtually error-free.

R.Nilsson7 · 10th July 2008, 07:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by One United

Has Van Der Sar been bought off? He keeps like a granny! I have tried to forgive the embarrassment of Wet Ham in December. I have tolerated the 'shakey' this and that talk but own goal in Pompey? Punching out the ball in the CL and still doing it in the Premiership costing us another loss? He almost took Heinze out today. He is a fucking menace to our chances. He is highly over rated and should be removed. I have no faith in him anymore.

Quote:

Originally Posted by One United

I can see your point but diving at it would have been nice to see instead of looking at it go by. VDS has been looking stunned a lot in our last few games he has started. I am not even confident with pass backs to him. He is a growing concern, and you can get behind him because 'you support the club' or you can just point out this bloke is fucking up, A LOT. Not the right part of the season to be burnt up or fucking up, A LOT. As for you mutts calling me an idiot and the such, debate the issue and do not deflect it or you have nothing to say. VDS is an issue and his keeping is suffering. Defend him all you like. His record in the last 4 showings is poor.

Quote:

Originally Posted by One United

Glad you took the time to write that, Smashed. I have responded to each comment turned my way. I have not been aggressive in any way. VDS is looking like he is going to bottle the season. His judgement of depth has been poor, his positioning is questionable at times. He makes some great saves and then lets in a dribble like today. I do not trust him between the poles and yes would rather go back to the spirit of 99 which I hear you lot laud on about comparing this season to though they have nothing in common. If my first string is not working or injured I will reach to my subs, we have been forced to do it and seen JOS and Fletch shine. Why so hesitant about Kuzz? I can't spell his name so will not embarrass myself trying to type it. VDS is shot. He is fucking up. Can you not see that? Are you so Red blind you cannot see he is pretty dodgey? He is overrated at this point in the season and looks arthritic rather than lithe in responding to strikes. Now if you cannot see that who is the muppet. Getting behind the club is one thing and talking shite another. Fucking replace him he is spent. As for all the offside comments, who cares...the thread is about VDS and that is all I am discussing. Who cares if you do not like it. It is a concern.

What a spastic!

hotshot2004 · 10th July 2008, 07:55

Funny how things change around in football, one day you are responsible for the loss and everything was your fault, the next day you become f*cking legend, Amazing how people jump to conclusion without looking past or present.

Same thing happened with Giggs, with people calling to axe him off from first team. The same man sealed the 17th title and scored in Cl final.

Marcus · 10th July 2008, 08:16

Yes, VDS has done well and is a legend. But keepers do have a sell-by date. I remember that in the '99 season, the Great Dane had a catastrophic number of howlers early in the season only to go on to be part of the mighty treble winning team after being sent on a mandatory 2 week holiday by Fergie. VDS had quite a few dodgy games in 2007, including identical fisting of the ball into dangerous areas inside the penalty box. Did get me wondering ...

But never mind, he has since done a marvelous job.

Lot 49 · 10th July 2008, 08:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by hotshot2004

Same thing happened with Giggs, with people calling to axe him off from first team. The same man sealed the 17th title and scored in Cl final.

Coming off the bench in both occasions which is what people who wanted him axed from the first team had been saying we needed to do all season.

Decotron · 10th July 2008, 14:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Marcus

Yes, VDS has done well and is a legend. But keepers do have a sell-by date. I remember that in the '99 season, the Great Dane had a catastrophic number of howlers early in the season only to go on to be part of the mighty treble winning team after being sent on a mandatory 2 week holiday by Fergie. VDS had quite a few dodgy games in 2007, including identical fisting of the ball into dangerous areas inside the penalty box. Did get me wondering ...

But never mind, he has since done a marvelous job.

You stole my point, you point stealing sun of a gun! VDS has one full season left in him and maybe 1 after that with hopefully Foster ready to take over his mantle. Also he has to be given the GK coach job.

Sky1981 · 10th July 2008, 18:08

This thread resurgence is an indication of lack of summer transfer muppetry

SmashedHombre · 10th July 2008, 18:21

Feck I was in a sour mood that day

Sorry One United

davisjw · 10th July 2008, 18:31

Wow pointless bump of a thread... Wow worthless post by me...

ZIDANE · 10th July 2008, 18:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Uzi

welll, guys t be fair i have noticed it as well. Edwins performances are getting a bit edgy now as compared to when he first signed for us. However the notion that he's past it and is shite now is only a narrow minded approach. And it's only oen fo a handful of explanations.

He's played close to sixty games this season, he's not a spring chicken no more at the age of 36/37 now is he>?< The season is going to have some serous effects on him man, he'll be collecting his pension before long with a giro slip. lol.

Then next his age, reflexes and stuff not as they used to be/ bollox excuse. edwin wasn't shite y'day., kaka's first goal was sheer class... he noticed edwin took a split half second longer to position himself and kaka tapped it in while he was doing so...

I feel he just needs a good rest which he can't get at this important part of the season. He IS the best keeper since The Great Dane.

To those who think he's had it, would you rather have Thomaz in goal than him in the CL final? *dum dum dum dummm*

An Uzi post not fully in txt speech. A rare sight.

*dum dum dum dummm*

Wandering Red · 11th July 2008, 03:07

One United should be beaten and sunk in the Irwell.

reddevilcanada · 11th July 2008, 04:58

*shakes his head*

hycool · 11th July 2008, 06:11

*vomits*

Nanison · 11th July 2008, 12:34

What a thread

And most people here on the caf think I am spastic

10th July 2008, 07:55	#84 (permalink)
hotshot2004 Reserve Team Player Join Date: May 2007 Location: Promise Land Posts: 1,157	Funny how things change around in football, one day you are responsible for the loss and everything was your fault, the next day you become f*cking legend, Amazing how people jump to conclusion without looking past or present. Same thing happened with Giggs, with people calling to axe him off from first team. The same man sealed the 17th title and scored in Cl final.

10th July 2008, 08:16	#85 (permalink)
Marcus Couldn't buy a clue Join Date: Oct 1999 Location: Dream Team: Ole - reserve coach, Cantona - Asst Manager, Schmikes - Goalie coach Posts: 2,418	Yes, VDS has done well and is a legend. But keepers do have a sell-by date. I remember that in the '99 season, the Great Dane had a catastrophic number of howlers early in the season only to go on to be part of the mighty treble winning team after being sent on a mandatory 2 week holiday by Fergie. VDS had quite a few dodgy games in 2007, including identical fisting of the ball into dangerous areas inside the penalty box. Did get me wondering ... But never mind, he has since done a marvelous job.

10th July 2008, 18:08	#88 (permalink)
Sky1981 Fending Off the Urge Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: The reminiscence of long lost glory from the past Posts: 2,827	This thread resurgence is an indication of lack of summer transfer muppetry

10th July 2008, 18:21	#89 (permalink)
SmashedHombre Has a date with the Grim Reaper - lol Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Slightly more handsome, intelligent and talented than Rams. Far more likely to shag sheep than most rams too. Posts: 18,051	Feck I was in a sour mood that day Sorry One United

10th July 2008, 18:31	#90 (permalink)
davisjw Reserve Team Player Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 1,258	Wow pointless bump of a thread... Wow worthless post by me...

11th July 2008, 03:07	#92 (permalink)
Wandering Red Reserve Team Player Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: In nomine Patri. Et Fili. Spiritus Sancti. Posts: 687	One United should be beaten and sunk in the Irwell.

11th July 2008, 04:58	#93 (permalink)
reddevilcanada First Team Sub Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 9,550	shakes his head

11th July 2008, 06:11	#94 (permalink)
hycool CR7 fanboy Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: München mag dich Posts: 2,320	vomits

11th July 2008, 12:34	#95 (permalink)
Nanison Reserve Team Player Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 1,356	What a thread And most people here on the caf think I am spastic