Werewolf: Game#4 "The Masonic Order" [living players only]

B20

lol. way to incriminate both us.

B20

of us.

stupid edit rule

Top

Because I suspect by the time the Seer comes out and verify my allegiance to the village, I'll be dead. Thus it'd be a waste.

By the way, you going offline and then suddenly appearing with one thought-out post makes me suspicious of you.

Heh, I love being able to just post whatever comes through my mind this time around

Irwynwastheking

What did you think of the point that some where making that I was doing the wolfs jobs for them by drawing up a list and that this was a pointless exercise?

Excal

You weren't doing the wolf's exercise for them but it was a pointless exercise.

B20

we have witnesses and bodyguards though. It would make sense to have them follow those newly declared.

mehro

Too much to read so I've decided to read only Top's posts.


I dont get it. If I was a wolf I would want to be highly active and not sue the invisible mode at all.

I think the wolves should kill Top tonight. I dont like him.

Of course people listen to me, you cnut. Watch me get you lynched tomorrow. And I did influence the village in the last game although that got 2 villagers killed.

I didn't exactly miss you. I hadnt ruled you out. But I was surer on Sky.

RedSky At Night

I think its fairly obvious who the experienced pro players are in this game. The Wolves will know this and be looking to take some out early doors, thats what I would do anyway.

What we can't risk is the Seer picking targets who are obvious villagers like Vivs did with some of her choices last game. I have faith that the Seers will choose wisely this time around. Go for people who are lurking in the background and not really saying/doing much would be my tactic.

As for the Witness role. I know just how goddamn difficult it is, does he go for the safe option? Does he go for the risky option? There could be 2/3 choices for each option. Frankly its a lottery, espically early on in the game.

Its about trying to second guess the Wolves tactics rather than protecting pro players. Thats my advise anyway.

WR

I only jumped on you because you were new, and a Liverpool fan!

It is easier to act naive as a newbie as suspicious comments can be defended with it

RedSky At Night

I'm just going to be a bit more logical this time around and go back to my style of Game 1. I think at times I let excitement cloud my judgement last game and therefore i'm going back to being calm, cool and logical. Vulcan like

Top

I meant miss as in longing for my helpful presence. You're the Robin to my Batman, gayo.

JayWalker

So basically, everyone has a role except 4 of us who are plain villagers, right?

Irwynwastheking

Funny enough, I would have the witness and bodyguard also follow Crappy and Redsky tonight if I had my own way.

RedSky At Night

Er, there isn't a bodyguard... just the witness!

mehro

I find crappy harder to read than RedSky so if we have to choose between them then check out crappy. But honestly Top was pretty good as a wolf last time and he's playing very different this around. Which could mean that maybe he's changing his game to throw off the villagers? Same goes for Irwin. I dont remember him being so active before.

Irwynwastheking

It's like shawshank in here.

Everyone of us will be claiming to be a plain villager so 23 people are liars.

Top

Nah the witness should follow me. Or not. Or do. Do you dare take the chances, wolves? Well do you, punks!?

Irwynwastheking

I was just going by B9's post 206.

Scrumpet

Depends. The four lovers and the ghost could have other roles and the priests probably haven't trained anyone yet. At most there are 21 players with roles other than just Villager (plus 2 priests to come), or there could be just 16.

Top

I don't know what I would have done, had I been named a wolf again. I actually think I dislike this game, when I'm a wolf. That's why I was actually telling you the truth in the last game when I told you I was fed up with the game. I hate, hate being a wolf.

Being a villager makes the game so much more fun.

WR

There is a 85% chance you're lieing.

mehro

Irwynwastheking

I've been one of the top 2-3 posters in every game I've played up until I got lynched wrongly each time.

Please read Zarlaks post in the last page and allow yourself to absorb his words of wisdom.

Zarlak

Not really, it's irrelevant information. It would be a silly idea for anyone to play the next game the same way they did in the game before, talk about giving away a pattern for people to work you out with! Everybody remembers the last game. It would make more sense to assume that everybody is going to post differently, rather than treat it as suspicious.

Maybe too much emphasis was put on the way I said to shut up about it, what I meant was stop making it paramount. For example in game 1 I was heavily vocal, in game 2 I planned to be quiet but I had to be vocal because of vivs, game 3 I was quiet because I was busy and I was accused of being a wolf. On all 3 occasions I was a villager. This has happened with other innocent people as well.

The catching you and Sky as wolves because of your change in posting styles is outweighed by all the innocent villagers and PVs that have been outed/forced to waste our time defending themselves because it's been pointed out that they are posting differently to a game that's no longer relevant when the criteria changes from game to game.

So maybe it would be good if you notice straight away something that's massively different, but the whole 'omg this guy is posting less than he did last time, that means he's a wolf' and then 5 people going 'oh yeah! you're right! Wolf! Wolf! Wolf!' etc is silly, what's the point in trying to come up with theories and think about the game, if someone is just going to say 'this guy is acting differently to how he did a few weeks ago, I reckon I've cracked the case' etc. Such a big deal is made out of things and before you know it it's like the persons just come out and said 'I'm a wolf' when it's nowhere near.

JayWalker

Interesting. The chances of a PV getting slaughtered in the morning are very high in that case.

mehro

I dont know. First game was a lot of fun. Second one, not really. Not sure why.

RedSky At Night

Probably due to my awsome wolves kicking booty

Shame PJ was kicked off as inactive otherwise we'd have the best wolf survival rate!

Top

We'll make this one fun then.
I've decided I'm teaming up with you. We'll take down these wolf bastards one by one.

mehro

Sorry. I have a rubbish memory. Seer, can you check out irwin in that case?

Zarlak

I've missed yo-yo Mehro.

Irwynwastheking

Hence why I think we should base very little on peoples perceptions of earlier games. I said this in the sign-up thread and I quoted that post in page two of this thread.

mehro

I meant the third one. I left the second one after day 1.

Hehe. Lets do it.

RedSky At Night

Lets just lynch the fecker like normal and be done with it!

Joking of course Irwin!!!

WR

Seer - whoever you are, check who you want and not what people are suggesting.

The only thing people are being suggested on is experience and past games, which has no bearing on this game at all. Whoever the seers are, we won't know for a few days anyway so it's rather pointless throwing every name around and making lists

RedSky At Night

Oh yeah, that was the reason why we went after lynching Irwin! Now I remember

Fuckin ell, my memmorys just as bad as yours!

Top

Your past behavior was what had me so convinced you weren't a wolf in game 2, when quite a few started suspecting you. The same with Sky.

Irwynwastheking

I usually last to turn 2-3.

Top

It'll be awesome, we'll be like Superior Masons, doing our communication out in the open.

Zarlak

Lists are very useful, but it's best to be making them private at this stage. If you post the list now the wolves will react to it, if you keep it for a bit and observe who votes where and how and keep it quiet, the wolves don't know they've been picked up on, you can come out later and say well X voted with Y twice and stuck up for him in this post and then again here and etc etc etc, rather than posting real time updates that the wolves can react to. That's one of the problems with these games so far is that it's a double edged sword, if you stay quiet you're voted off for inactivity, if you come out and say what you think when you think, the wolves will read it and think 'huh, he's got a good point, let's do exactly the opposite.'

Where as if you watch first and come out with quite a few bits of damming evidence that it's too late for them to react to, you're onto a winner but you don't really get a chance to do it.

Irwynwastheking

But as proved in the previous game I'll put the game above myself, and even though this saved me before I think it does more harm than good.