Sneijder or Modric?

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:06

Sneijder all day long for me.

A poll would be nice.

Lance Uppercut · 31st May 2011, 14:07

Sneijder.

Red Defence · 31st May 2011, 14:09

Without doubt Sneijder.

ricky-romeo · 31st May 2011, 14:09

sneijder.

i got a feeling fergei will sign modric though...

Bref · 31st May 2011, 14:09

Modric, proven in PL in a similar system to ours

Solius · 31st May 2011, 14:10

Modric, can play in a midfield 2.

Ekeke · 31st May 2011, 14:10

Banega

ha_rooney · 31st May 2011, 14:11

Modric

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by Solius

Modric, can play in a midfield 2.

Are you saying Sneijder can't?

championo · 31st May 2011, 14:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ekeke

Banega

Agenda driven to derail thread or what? See thread title please.

Ubik · 31st May 2011, 14:12

Yes please.

Solius · 31st May 2011, 14:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryan_Munich

Are you saying Sneijder can't?

No, but Modric can do it much better and suits it more.

Rado_N · 31st May 2011, 14:14

Schweinsteiger

Raoul · 31st May 2011, 14:15

Lets get a few more options and we can make it a poll.

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by R_Nick

Schweinsteiger

Cock.

Clique · 31st May 2011, 14:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raoul

Lets get a few more options and we can make it a poll.

Sneidjer
Modric
Banega
Pastore
Schewiestiger
Yvan M'Vila
Hamsik
Defour
Diarra L
Charlie Adam

Those are all the midfielders we've had on our wish list on the caf this summer

Of course, the mandatory Eboue!.

Wibble · 31st May 2011, 14:17

Why only 1? Or either?

Blair · 31st May 2011, 14:19

We need 2.

Modric and Schweinsteiger would be my preferred options.

Rado_N · 31st May 2011, 14:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryan_Munich

Cock.

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wibble

Why only 1? Or either?

I was just curious to find out which one (of the two) the majority on here would prefer.

Donkey's Ears · 31st May 2011, 14:20

Modric out of the two because he's far more mobile with the ball.

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by R_Nick

Derailing my thread, have you any idea how much thought has gone into this.

Raoul · 31st May 2011, 14:23

Good point about needing two. Which would make it a bit problematic in terms of creating a poll.

Rado_N · 31st May 2011, 14:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryan_Munich

Derailing my thread, have you any idea how much thought has gone into this.

I won't answer that

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raoul

Good point about needing two. Which would make it a bit problematic in terms of creating a poll.

You mean we can't have a poll with just 2 options?

Boss · 31st May 2011, 14:27

Sneijder every single time,

serious redcafe, have a word here.

Rado_N · 31st May 2011, 14:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryan_Munich

You mean we can't have a poll with just 2 options?

He means picking 2 from a selection of 8-10.

Keep up Bryan!

Clique · 31st May 2011, 14:29

We're getting TWO big signings this summer?. Is it the cynic in me or is that just a bit unbelievable?.

We've always prided ourselves on developing players rather than buying finished products, it also makes more sense financially. A 20-22 year old player who has potential to be world class is who we'll be getting along with a big signing to satisfy the signings.

Which is the reason why for some reason Yann M'vila seems to be the type of player we're going to buy.

McGrathsipan · 31st May 2011, 14:29

wesley
modric
fabregas
schweinsteiger
danny tiatto

VoetbalWizard · 31st May 2011, 14:31

both.
carrick --> busquets

modric ---> chavvy

sneijder --> iniesta

MadDogg · 31st May 2011, 14:32

Modric.

Sneijder can play in a midfield two, but his best performances have always been pushed further up the field. So the question becomes, can Sneijder play in a 442 better than Modric can? I think he'd unbalance us a bit, myself.

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:32

I was just curious to find out which one (of the two) the majority on here would prefer.

I'm not interested in the other options for the purpose of this thread to be honest.

Raoul · 31st May 2011, 14:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryan_Munich

You mean we can't have a poll with just 2 options?

We could, but it would mean other posters couldn't vote for who they wanted if their choices fell outside the two, which would make for an underwhelming poll.

Raoul · 31st May 2011, 14:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by McGrathsipan

wesley
modric
fabregas
schweinsteiger
danny tiatto

Kaiketsu_Zorro · 31st May 2011, 14:36

both

Bryan_Munich · 31st May 2011, 14:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raoul

We could, but it would mean other posters couldn't vote for who they wanted if their choices fell outside the two, which would make for an underwhelming poll.

Fair enough, how about a simple poll as follows then?

Sneijder

Modric

Other

Kaiketsu_Zorro · 31st May 2011, 14:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryan_Munich

Fair enough, how about a simple poll as follows then?

Sneijder

Modric

Other

+ Both

Sunny Jim · 31st May 2011, 14:42

Scholes circa 99/00

Wes · 31st May 2011, 14:48

The Yaak

I'm always right · 31st May 2011, 14:49

Seriously, imagine them both with Carrick behind.... fuck me! Now that'd rival Barca.

View Poll Results: Which midfielder should we buy?
Modric	71	35.68%
Sneijder	108	54.27%
Other	20	10.05%
Voters: 199. You may not vote on this poll

31st May 2011, 14:06	#1 (permalink)
Bryan_Munich Aka RichieRich12 Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: In Arsène We Rust Posts: 11,639	Sneijder or Modric? Sneijder all day long for me. A poll would be nice.

RedCafe.net

The Leading Manchester United Forum

Member's Login

Sneijder or Modric?

Latest Forum Topics

Jump to Forum

Not yet registered?

31st May 2011, 14:07	#2 (permalink)
Lance Uppercut First Team Regular Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: NOBODY, calls Dugan a turd. Posts: 19,808	Sneijder.

31st May 2011, 14:09	#3 (permalink)
Red Defence First Team Sub Join Date: May 2009 Location: “United stands for attacking, attractive football played at high speed, with one-touch passing combinations, individual skill and unpredictability. That’s all conducted at pace, with intent.” Posts: 7,809	Without doubt Sneijder.

31st May 2011, 14:09	#4 (permalink)
ricky-romeo First Team Sub Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: kota bharu Posts: 6,675	sneijder. i got a feeling fergei will sign modric though...

31st May 2011, 14:09	#5 (permalink)
Bref Reserve Team Player Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Dublin Posts: 656	Modric, proven in PL in a similar system to ours

31st May 2011, 14:10	#6 (permalink)
Solius I am a mod, I swear Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Everybody will be dancing and be doing it right. Posts: 49,511	Modric, can play in a midfield 2.

31st May 2011, 14:10	#7 (permalink)
Ekeke First Team Regular Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 26,459	Banega

31st May 2011, 14:11	#8 (permalink)
ha_rooney First Team Regular Join Date: Dec 2008 Posts: 15,155	Modric

31st May 2011, 14:12	#11 (permalink)
Ubik Reserve Team Player Join Date: Jul 2010 Posts: 3,348	Yes please.

31st May 2011, 14:14	#13 (permalink)
Rado_N Came from nowhere, yet still a better modmin than Weaste ever was Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: mishy gishy gushy gushy mishy meshy mushy, motherfucker Posts: 45,365	Schweinsteiger

31st May 2011, 14:15	#14 (permalink)
Raoul Administrator Join Date: Aug 1999 Location: Afghanistan Posts: 42,437	Lets get a few more options and we can make it a poll.

31st May 2011, 14:17	#17 (permalink)
Wibble In Gadus Speramus Join Date: Jun 2000 Location: Centre Back Posts: 54,201	Why only 1? Or either?

31st May 2011, 14:19	#18 (permalink)
Blair Reserve Team Player Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Scotland Posts: 4,054	We need 2. Modric and Schweinsteiger would be my preferred options.

31st May 2011, 14:20	#21 (permalink)
Donkey's Ears Reserve Team Player Join Date: Sep 2004 Posts: 1,635	Modric out of the two because he's far more mobile with the ball.

31st May 2011, 14:23	#23 (permalink)
Raoul Administrator Join Date: Aug 1999 Location: Afghanistan Posts: 42,437	Good point about needing two. Which would make it a bit problematic in terms of creating a poll.

31st May 2011, 14:27	#26 (permalink)
Boss Melodramatic, attention seeking space-attacker Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: I left you with enough memories to resurrect me with Posts: 24,076	Sneijder every single time, serious redcafe, have a word here.

31st May 2011, 14:29	#28 (permalink)
Clique First Team Sub Join Date: May 2009 Location: Mermania Rulez!!!...Merms come back!!! Posts: 5,124	We're getting TWO big signings this summer?. Is it the cynic in me or is that just a bit unbelievable?. We've always prided ourselves on developing players rather than buying finished products, it also makes more sense financially. A 20-22 year old player who has potential to be world class is who we'll be getting along with a big signing to satisfy the signings. Which is the reason why for some reason Yann M'vila seems to be the type of player we're going to buy.

31st May 2011, 14:29	#29 (permalink)
McGrathsipan First Team Regular Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Jasmin Harmans is a Lasher! Posts: 11,630	wesley modric fabregas schweinsteiger danny tiatto

31st May 2011, 14:31	#30 (permalink)
VoetbalWizard Banned Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: at the altar of ryan giggs Posts: 12,597	both. carrick --> busquets modric ---> chavvy sneijder --> iniesta

31st May 2011, 14:32	#31 (permalink)
MadDogg First Team Sub Join Date: Apr 2002 Location: “Manchester United never lose, they just run out of time” Posts: 6,864	Modric. Sneijder can play in a midfield two, but his best performances have always been pushed further up the field. So the question becomes, can Sneijder play in a 442 better than Modric can? I think he'd unbalance us a bit, myself.

31st May 2011, 14:32	#32 (permalink)
Bryan_Munich Aka RichieRich12 Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: In Arsène We Rust Posts: 11,639	I was just curious to find out which one (of the two) the majority on here would prefer. I'm not interested in the other options for the purpose of this thread to be honest.

31st May 2011, 14:36	#35 (permalink)
Kaiketsu_Zorro Reserve Team Player Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Poland Posts: 1,934	both

31st May 2011, 14:42	#38 (permalink)
Sunny Jim First Team Regular Join Date: May 2007 Location: Warsaw...that's too far away from Edinburgh... Posts: 16,266	Scholes circa 99/00

31st May 2011, 14:48	#39 (permalink)
Wes Banned Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Dublin, in the Irish Republic Posts: 9,948	The Yaak

31st May 2011, 14:49	#40 (permalink)
I'm always right Banned Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: Mêlée Island Posts: 15,933	Seriously, imagine them both with Carrick behind.... fuck me! Now that'd rival Barca.