What I'm saying is the majority of people don't watch Shaw/United every week and they also don't watch Robertson/Liverpool every week. These aren't attacking players where you can see a ton of their quality in MOTD highlights and statistical output. So the result is people overweight team success and defensive record when judging defenders very often. His set piece delivery has been poor. That's about all I agree with. His attacking play has not been, especially of late where it seems with Martial out he has more license to get forward to provide width on the left. He often is restricted in attacking play because when Martial/Sanchez play ahead of him he has to stay back to give them free reign as well as Pogba who plays CM but often occupies areas forward on the left flank. Robertson provides the width for Liverpool as their CMs aren't creative outlets. Comparing the two and simply saying Robertson does more in attack and Shaw's attacking play is shite simply doesn't take into account context. Like I said, I'd edge it to Robertson, but there's not the wide gap between them "neutrals" think there is.