New contract for Young confirmed

I reckon this made a lot more sense in your head.

Logically speaking, Jones would still be worth decent money so it made sense to sign him up. Smalling's our 2nd best CB after Lindelof (on current form) he's also the most experienced. Young we needed for one more year to give Dalot more time to grow into his role, don't think it's anything to do with "getting the band back together".

With recent announcements I'd say Rojo, Darmian and Valencia will be sold this summer

One year is very logical for someone of his age, good squad player to have. No complaints.

1 year is fine. 5 Year contract for jones is another story.

That would be my hope, along with Mata.

Young has done more than enough to deserve his extension and barring an injury, has the legs to be a useful matchday squad player (mainly rotating)

Yeah

Yep, not much more to add really. He deserves the extension.

Personally I'm not half as bothered by this contrary to the Phil Jones contract extension. Mainly because of the length of the contract, it's a sensible move, and we can still move him in the summer if we please for a small amount.

Good for him,i think he has deserved it.

Great deal for both player and club.

Truth is with all the money the club generates we shouldn't need to keep old has-beens on for cover, we should be going out and getting prime quality for what we need.

Was he given a salary increase too?

He gives everything for the club, knows what it’s like to win and seems like a great ambassador and personality in the dressing room too. Nothing not to like, one year suits all parties. Anyone saying we should let a player of his experience who can cover probably four positions to at least a decent level, leave for nothing, is an idiot.

Do I think we need to get a first choice RB in? Yep. Do I think it’s our most critical area of recruitment? No chance. Young and Dalot would be fine so long as the positions that really need improving are improved.

I’d say we haven’t had a top right back since Gary Neville and we’ve got by.

Sanchez, Di Maria, Schneiderlin, Schweinsteiger, Fred, Micky, Depay were all players we thought would improve us big time and cost lots of money. Sadly it didn't work out for any of those (Sanchez and Fred remains to be seen). If we had invested that amount of money in players that actually worked out, we probably wouldn't have this discussion. We have invested a lot, but got little return.

Even if we are rich, we can't go out and buy 5-6 key players in one season. We need to improve RB, CB, RW, get a backup or starter for LB, get a backup for CM etc. It will take a few transfer windows to fix that. In that case, it's wise to keep the likes of Young.

Darmian, Rojo, Valencia and Mata are leaving I think, with Fellaini already in China.

There have been transfer mistakes no doubt but the fact remains we do have the money if what we made was plowed solely into the team and not divvy'd out into the pockets of the Glazers and share holders, but we are constantly having to taper our spending to feed these succubuses which is why we keep having to retain players like Young who aren't good enough. At the end of the day though this will only bother me if we don't buy a proper RB in the summer and just use Young as a back-up, if he's starting with the Captain's armband next season it'll be a big mistake IMO.

Solid citizen, well deserved contract.

His ability to play both sides makes this well worth as well as the fact he wont kick up a fuss if he doesn't start all the time.

I wouldnt extend his contract but as long i dont have to watch him waving his arms whole 90 min, while clearly playing opposition player onside for that one year. We need first choice RB asap.

He's a great professional and gives his all. But going into next season with him as first choice RB hopefully wont happen.

If we are still lining up next season with Young Jones and Smalling that's when these contract extensions become an issue for me

I think that's very possible, we'll be looking to move those three on.

One year for Smashley is fine by me. He'll play his part next year on and off the field but he shouldn't be in our first XI next year.

Not sure why so many people hate on Young. I'm hard pressed to find many better FB's in the league. Amazing how we love to underrate our own players. Especially the ones who have been around for a long time...

1 year makes sense.

Good decision.
No way we can afford to upgrade right-back, get a proper midfielder or two, a right-wing & possibly a high-class CB in the summer. Right-back is at least something that can be improved by a talent improving, and Young is a decent rotation-alternative for both right-back and left-back.

He's a shocking defender for a club of our stature. Always gets caught out by a runner and a bit weak in the challenge when he does get there. Despite the lack of crossing ability at least he does get up the pitch and attempt something, unlike his predecessor.

Makes sense. Happy it's a 1 year deal.

Good thing. If we sign a RB, he will be cover for Shaw. Otherwise, he will share the RB duties with Dalot (and hopefully Dalot makes the position his own by this time next year).

That's our back 4 sorted for the next season I guess. Get in.

Think the club is sweating over the Valencia deal. Will he sign the 3+1 deal or will he not?

I'm not sure if our fullbacks are limited or if there is a dearth of half decent options out there, it happens, there is similarly less supply than demand for defensive midfielders.

Maybe pep was onto something when he paid fortunes for reliable options on the market.

1yr is fine. No massive issue with this.

I get it. But if we have any title aspirations then he can only be a squad player next year

Nice,makes perfect sense....Since Valencia might leave this summer,it makes perfect sense to hang on to Ashley for another year.His experience and his ability to play well in both full back positions will definitely help next season...

Check Young's statement from today:
“Pay attention to what you’re saying. There are other criteria to consider.

www.express.co.uk/sport/football/1085562/Man-Utd-Ashley-Young-reacts-BADLY-Liverpool-question-PSG-Champions-League-latest-news/amp

Congrats Champ!!

That's not funny

Sell him.

I don't mind Young as a squad player so i'm not too annoyed about this. Still, we cannot seriously be going into another season with him as one of our first choice options at full-back.

Good decision. Dalot will get more chances and grow into a starter. Besides, even if we do sign a starting RB next season, Young is a better backup to anyone else we currently have in that position.

One year contract. He can cover cover both flanks. I am happy with this.

Forever Young.