What are you going on about? How is my argument flawed? That post was not in response to the 4-4 draw, it was in response to spaghettihairs post. And it's quite clear that I'm referring to the whole season not just the draw with Everton (which btw Rooney was much better in) as opposed to his horror displays against Villa in the 4-0 and Wolves in the 5-0. <<<That's me detaching analysing someones performance from the result of the match. It's what people who don't see things in black and white do.