Right now he is the flavour of the month in the PL with pundits and fans alike. He was Sir Alex's last signing and in a way looks like something we are missing right about now. So why didn't it work? Bad timing? Moyes? Too much pressure? Couldn't handle the move up north? Overrated? All of the above? I would have loved him to do well at United but it didn't work. Looking at him now though you have to think it's a shame as he's a really talented player.