simplyared
Full Member
My choice:
Overrated: Jordan Henderson
Underrated: Chris Smalling
Overrated: Jordan Henderson
Underrated: Chris Smalling
Well we do have a lot of Liverpool fans on here, and you know how they tend to rate their players...I must have missed all those posts where everyone was saying how good Jordan Henderson is!
Salah, De Gea? Obvious ones, of course.These threads always confuse me. Has anyone got any examples of players who are rated just right?
I'd say Matic, Valencia, Lukaku are perfect examples from our current squadThese threads always confuse me. Has anyone got any examples of players who are rated just right?
Fellaini. Rated as mostly ineffective, with some uses here and there.These threads always confuse me. Has anyone got any examples of players who are rated just right?
Seriously Giroud? He was first team under Wenger for way too long and cost us the league title in 15/16 when he decided to go 15 games without a goal at the business end of the season. Strictly a squad player no way is he starting quality at any top 4 club.Overrated : Hazard. Guy is good without a doubt but is he really up there among the best? Shows up for a season and then hides for 2.
Underrated : Giroud. I am astonished he wasn't used more under AW, but in recent years AW seems to of gone senile.
Is he really overrated if you can't even spell his name correctly though?Overrated - Vierra
Underated - Kevin Phillips
Harry Kane is actually very underrated. He doesn't get credit for at least 142 of the goals he's scored this season.Fellaini. Rated as mostly ineffective, with some uses here and there.
Matic. Rated as mostly effective, with some dips here and there.
Harry Kane. Rated as a snowflake. He is one
You think Mata would be rated lower if he was English...?Overrated: Juan Mata
I hate to say it but I think his personality and being a handsome little Spanish attacking midfielder contributes a lot to people's perception. If an Englishman called John Matty put in the exact same performances, they wouldn't be viewed nearly as highly.
I do, the same way I think that if someone put in the performances that Shelvey does and they were Brazilian they would be rated higher.You think Mata would be rated lower if he was English...?
Honestly mate, if an English player was as good as Mata has been since joining the PL, he'd be an undroppable megastar.
Incorrect. If he were English, media would have been writing long articles about his every pass, even if it came once in 5 matches. You underestimate the overrating English players get on regular basis.If an Englishman called John Matty put in the exact same performances, they wouldn't be viewed nearly as highly.
Only Jose thinks he is super awesomeFellaini and Fellaini
Paul Scholes was incredibly underrated until he was about 32. Either way, missing the point of what I was saying.Incorrect. If he were English, media would have been writing long articles about his every pass, even if it came once in 5 matches. You underestimate the overrating English players get on regular basis.
From a lower tier, Groß is also underrated.Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
He's top amoungst all the positive stats for Chelsea this season, even in 15/16 he was like 7th in the key chances created chart.Overrated : Hazard. Guy is good without a doubt but is he really up there among the best? Shows up for a season and then hides for 2.
.
There are plenty, actually. In my opinion of course.These threads always confuse me. Has anyone got any examples of players who are rated just right?