Phil Foden - What Is His Potential?

P-Nut

fan of well-known French footballer Fabinho
Joined
Oct 16, 2015
Messages
21,602
Location
Oldham, Greater Manchester
If the player forced the move or not, the point also stands that players regularly move away from big clubs, don't develop, and then end up fading into obscurity. There is no correlation, there is no trend either way, so why is it always the first piece of advice handed out to ambitious young players?
I understand what your saying, however there is a correlation of players not getting playing time and stagnating.
 

Fridge chutney

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2016
Messages
8,871
Yep, good example. There's an argument that Lukaku did the same as well. So that's two players.

I'm gonna need more than that to understand why this advice is handed out to young players on such a regular basis.
I think it will be a shame for City if pep doesn't start integrating him into the first team. If he's as good as people say (and I have no reason to believe otherwise), then he needs to get his feet wet.

A loan move might also be beneficial. Kane went on loan before taking Spurs first team by storm. Loan him to Bournemouth or a Spanish club, for example, and that's a good way of gradually getting top experience.
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,514
I see this argument a lot, but I can't seem think of any world class players who started at a big club's academy, went to a smaller club n order to reach their potential, before going back to a big club for the rest of their illustrious career. He's better off staying at City and proving that he's good enough to take Silva's place in the side - if he does that then we know we have something special.
KDB left Chelsea for a smaller club to prove himself.
KdB wasn't from Chelsea academy.

Btw, one example is Pogba, then there are players like Fabregas, Pique, Alba, Mata and few more.
 

robinamicrowave

Wanted to be bran, ended up being littlefinger
Joined
Jul 29, 2013
Messages
2,739
Supports
Man City
I understand what your saying, however there is a correlation of players not getting playing time and stagnating.
But what constitutes "playing time"? We gave Kelechi 64 first-team appearances across two seasons, 46 in the Premier League, and all before the age of 21 (most of them before the age of 20). What about that suggests we weren't giving him playing time? If Phil Foden makes twenty appearances of any description this season (let's say, five starts in the Premier League + five sub appearances, three starts in the League Cup + one sub appearance, three starts in the FA Cup + one sub appearance, two sub appearances in the Champions' League), he'll have made thirty first-team appearances for a Premier League-winning, Champions' League-level club before the age of 19.

Would you expect McTominay to leave United for West Ham with those appearance numbers? Would you expect Lookman to force his way out of Everton? Would Maitland-Niles or Reiss Nelson try to engineer a move away from Arsenal? I don't think you'd see any of that happening. Foden hasn't proved a thing in open age football yet, so I'd say it's best to let him begin his development at a club he's grown up supporting, in an area where he's grown up and where his family are no doubt based, before we start shipping him off elsewhere.
 

P-Nut

fan of well-known French footballer Fabinho
Joined
Oct 16, 2015
Messages
21,602
Location
Oldham, Greater Manchester
But what constitutes "playing time"? We gave Kelechi 64 first-team appearances across two seasons, 46 in the Premier League, and all before the age of 21 (most of them before the age of 20). What about that suggests we weren't giving him playing time? If Phil Foden makes twenty appearances of any description this season (let's say, five starts in the Premier League + five sub appearances, three starts in the League Cup + one sub appearance, three starts in the FA Cup + one sub appearance, two sub appearances in the Champions' League), he'll have made thirty first-team appearances for a Premier League-winning, Champions' League-level club before the age of 19.

Would you expect McTominay to leave United for West Ham with those appearance numbers? Would you expect Lookman to force his way out of Everton? Would Maitland-Niles or Reiss Nelson try to engineer a move away from Arsenal? I don't think you'd see any of that happening. Foden hasn't proved a thing in open age football yet, so I'd say it's best to let him begin his development at a club he's grown up supporting, in an area where he's grown up and where his family are no doubt based, before we start shipping him off elsewhere.
You'll see many here advocating McTominay to go on loan and play more minutes than he'd get here. Lookin was trying to leave to go to Leipzig aswell.

It's not necessarily the amount of appearances, but the minutes they spend on the pitch. Also it's consecutive games, we're they can improve on what they did wrong the week before, instead of not getting a chance for another 4 weeks or until the next cup game rolls around.
 

Zehner

Football Statistics Dork
Joined
Mar 29, 2018
Messages
7,981
Location
Germany
Supports
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
Thought he was top class everytime I saw him. Hard to decide between him and Sancho.

I see this argument a lot, but I can't seem think of any world class players who started at a big club's academy, went to a smaller club n order to reach their potential, before going back to a big club for the rest of their illustrious career. He's better off staying at City and proving that he's good enough to take Silva's place in the side - if he does that then we know we have something special.
There are a few:

Toni Kroos
David Alaba
Dani Carvajal
Samuel Eto'o
Alvaro Morata

Just some names I could immediately think of. Most of them are related to the Bundesliga in some way so that may be why they came to my mind so easily. Probably one simply forgets about the way top players went before becoming world class quite easily.
 

Kag

Full Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2013
Messages
18,875
Location
United Kingdom
Foden will be a player. The torch-carrier for the progress made in English grassroots football. The first of many, ideally.
 

11101

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
21,201
He was brilliant, borderline unplayable, in the U17 World Cup. He certainly has the talent. It's how he grows with the men's game and if St. Pep actually gives him a chance in the first team.
 

endless_wheelies

feeling dizzy
Joined
Apr 22, 2014
Messages
3,224
Loan to Leeds under Bielsa would seem ideal. Then come back and slowly but surely interchange with Silva.
 

Zehner

Football Statistics Dork
Joined
Mar 29, 2018
Messages
7,981
Location
Germany
Supports
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
City paying 60 mil. pounds for players that gonna sit on the bench. Foden have no chance in such club even if he Messi level.
Guardiola is the coach who started using a completely unknown and not particularly talented Pedro ahead of Thierry Henry. The one who sold Ronaldinho to trust on a 20 year old Messi and Deco to hand the responsibility over the Andres Iniesta who was only a prospect back then. The list of Barca talents given the chance by Pep multiple times is long and there are some further stars like Busquets, Pique or Thiago as well as flops like Cuenca, Bojan, Tello and many many more who were forgotten.

I think if a young player shows the quality, willingness to learn and skill set for his system, Pep will give him playing time, even ahead of much more prominent competitors.
 

Don Alfredo

Full Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2018
Messages
2,071
Supports
Germany
Guardiola is the coach who started using a completely unknown and not particularly talented Pedro ahead of Thierry Henry. The one who sold Ronaldinho to trust on a 20 year old Messi and Deco to hand the responsibility over the Andres Iniesta who was only a prospect back then. The list of Barca talents given the chance by Pep multiple times is long and there are some further stars like Busquets, Pique or Thiago as well as flops like Cuenca, Bojan, Tello and many many more who were forgotten.

I think if a young player shows the quality, willingness to learn and skill set for his system, Pep will give him playing time, even ahead of much more prominent competitors.
You sure there? European Champion, 24 years old, 226 games for Barca including 41 CL games, all before Pep came. He was not some unknown guy.

The two academy graduates (not bought players) who were made by Pep into great players were Busquets and Pedro. You could include Pique as well if you are generous, because he was from La Masia and still young-ish.

His record with Academy graduates at Bayern was shocking though. Can't remember one decent player he pulled up from the academy.
 

Zehner

Football Statistics Dork
Joined
Mar 29, 2018
Messages
7,981
Location
Germany
Supports
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
You sure there? European Champion, 24 years old, 226 games for Barca including 41 CL games, all before Pep came. He was not some unknown guy.

The two academy graduates (not bought players) who were made by Pep into great players were Busquets and Pedro. You could include Pique as well if you are generous, because he was from La Masia and still young-ish.

His record with Academy graduates at Bayern was shocking though. Can't remember one decent player he pulled up from the academy.
Good point about Iniesta. Concerning the Bayern part: He famously gave Gaudino the chance in an opening match of the Bundesliga I believe and he looked like a world beater but it turned out he was a one hit wonder. And that was kind of symbolic for many promising young Bayern players around that time. All the supposedly great Bayern talents were given a chance but they didn't convince. And it is not like that there is one young player who left and set the world on fire afterwards. Gaudino, Kurt, Hojberg, Scholl, they all faded away without really shining. He still was a great supporter of Kimmich and Coman.

However,you can pretty much say that about all young players Guardiola coached. Either they succeeded under him or they never really did elsewhere anyway. I mean, there is no Salah, Eto'o or de Bruyne story where Pep ignored a talented youngster and he regretted it later on. I really can't think of any player that really proved him wrong (which of course doesn't mean that there are none, I am happy to be corrected).
 

Classical Mechanic

Full Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2014
Messages
35,216
Location
xG Zombie Nation
Guardiola is the coach who started using a completely unknown and not particularly talented Pedro ahead of Thierry Henry. The one who sold Ronaldinho to trust on a 20 year old Messi and Deco to hand the responsibility over the Andres Iniesta who was only a prospect back then. The list of Barca talents given the chance by Pep multiple times is long and there are some further stars like Busquets, Pique or Thiago as well as flops like Cuenca, Bojan, Tello and many many more who were forgotten.

I think if a young player shows the quality, willingness to learn and skill set for his system, Pep will give him playing time, even ahead of much more prominent competitors.
Messi came 3rd and 2nd in the Ballon D’Or the two seasons before Pep became manager. Hardly some great vision from Pep to keep playing him and sack of a guy who couldn’t be bothered training properly.
 

Don Alfredo

Full Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2018
Messages
2,071
Supports
Germany
Good point about Iniesta. Concerning the Bayern part: He famously gave Gaudino the chance in an opening match of the Bundesliga I believe and he looked like a world beater but it turned out he was a one hit wonder. And that was kind of symbolic for many promising young Bayern players around that time. All the supposedly great Bayern talents were given a chance but they didn't convince. And it is not like that there is one young player who left and set the world on fire afterwards. Gaudino, Kurt, Hojberg, Scholl, they all faded away without really shining. He still was a great supporter of Kimmich and Coman.

However,you can pretty much say that about all young players Guardiola coached. Either they succeeded under him or they never really did elsewhere anyway. I mean, there is no Salah, Eto'o or de Bruyne story where Pep ignored a talented youngster and he regretted it later on. I really can't think of any player that really proved him wrong (which of course doesn't mean that there are none, I am happy to be corrected).
How about Jadon Sancho? He should have promised him enough first team chances. If you are good enough for starting at Borussia Dortmund, then you are certainly good enough to be the sub for the last 10 mins instead of 50m Bernardo Silva. He keeps stockpiling 50m players for the RW (he has three now), yet he had Sancho and Brahim Diaz, two very highly rated youngsters.

That is not to only criticize Pep on that matter, many top clubs are too afraid to play their youth at an early age. When did the last Juventus academy graduate earn a first team spot? What players did Barcelona, Bayern, Chelsea etc. pull up into the first team from their academy in the last decade? I can only think of Sergi Roberto at Barca and Alaba at Bayern. One first team player in a decade is such a poor record. No excuses for that.
 

POF

Full Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2014
Messages
3,795
The parallels with Wilshere are striking. He seems a very similar player. I'd expect him to be hyped in a similar way when he starts to get more first team football, either at City or on loan.

Hopefully for him he can live up to the hype. Wilshere is evidence that talent alone guarantees nothing.
 

Posh Red

Full Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2013
Messages
3,438
Location
Peterborough, England
Sancho hasn't proven anything yet, so I'm not sure if you can use him as an example.

It is a problem that our academy hasn't produced many regular first team players in a decade. Our last graduate who got regular first team appearances was Dedryck Boyata under Mancini, and he was hideous. You could argue that Kelechi Iheanacho was an "academy graduate" of ours too, but you'd be stretching the rules a little. But I'd put our problems down to those players being vastly overrated by our fanbase while in the academy and turning out not to be good enough - maybe they lacked talent, maybe they weren't coached well enough, maybe they weren't given chances, maybe it's all three.

But you said it yourself, "If you're not [talented enough], you are a bust anyway." The amount of young players we've been promised at City since that Youth Cup-winning side in 2008 that have ultimately failed to deliver is through the roof. Of the twenty-five academy players who've made at least one appearance for our first team since then but are no longer attached to the club, only nine of them play in the the top five European leagues, and only two of them make regular appearances for "big clubs" (Denis Suarez, Marcos Lopes).

With those odds, it'd be better for Foden to stick around at City and try his hand at getting some game time here instead of taking a backwards step that has just as much chance of damaging his career prospects.
Do you not think it’s possible that your current club set up will never be conducive to bringing youth through? Domestically you’ve been very successful over the last few years, but as a United fan I can tell you that watching local players win trophies is a special feeling.
 

deafepl

New Member
Joined
May 19, 2017
Messages
2,974
Not sure about Foden, I have seen many players getting hyped as if they're going to become world class in the future but they mostly end up having a good career at midtable or lower. I'd guess there'd be better players than Foden in coming season, it's just unknown players who are not on radars for a big clubs. For an example, Rashford just came out of nothing, he wasn't hyped as Janauaj or Ravel Morrison who is said to be better than Pogba in youth.
 

Ace of Spades

Full Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
5,172
Talent is obviously there, but not more than Sancho, Hudson-Odoi, Sessengon and our very own Gomes.

It is about how these players progress and not stagnate that is the challenge.
 

amolbhatia50k

Sneaky bum time - Vaccination status: dozed off
Joined
Nov 8, 2002
Messages
95,334
Location
india
He's a good young player and he's going to be a very good player. Don't thing he's going to be Messi levels but he's going to be a top player.

He's the one City player I'd take if I could.
Q
You'd take him over KDB?
 

Bestietom

Full Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2013
Messages
8,021
Location
Ireland
I think it is all down to the young players attitude. They have to really want it. Train hard and when you get an opportunity take it.
 

Snow

Somewhere down the lane, a licky boom boom down
Joined
Jul 10, 2007
Messages
33,225
Location
Lousy Smarch weather
It's very hard for us arm-chair football fans to judge footballers that we've only see play reserve team football along with a bit of youth national games and some first team cameos. It's even hard for managers and coaches to judge when to give them opportunities and they watch them every day in training. For us it's pure speculation on far they'll make it since the most important aspect of their game (the mental part) hasn't been properly tested yet.
 

Lash

Full Member
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
11,888
Location
Buckinghamshire
Supports
Millwall, Saint-Etienne
More talent that Rooney at that age? Have a day off would ya.

Have to say looks extremely talented, but he’s not going to get the minutes he needs at City.
 

Yellow Black & Red

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 13, 2018
Messages
187
Supports
Watford
When was the last time City's graduated properly cement his place in 1st team after Arab money? None. Sancho forced his way out so he can get a proper 1st team football. If he talented enough he can go anywhere. Sancho proved it. If you are not, you are a bust anyway. Problem is Pep hardly look to his youth. Its proven last season anyway. Are you gonna deny it? Or are you gonna use Zinchenko as example cause he isnt your academy's grad.
Sancho isn't really a City academy grad either - he moved there from Watford just before his 16th birthday.
 

duffer

Sensible and not a complete jerk like most oppo's
Scout
Joined
Jun 24, 2004
Messages
50,137
Location
Chelsea (the saviours of football) fan.
More talent that Rooney at that age? Have a day off would ya.
Indeed. When Rooney had already played 60+ games for Everton, signed for Manchester United and played for England when he was 18.

Of course Foden is at a much better side than Everton was back then but he's played in just 10 top flight games, that's it.

Not saying Foden won't be a great but people forget who good Rooney was as a teenager.
 

Lash

Full Member
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
11,888
Location
Buckinghamshire
Supports
Millwall, Saint-Etienne
Indeed. When Rooney had already played 60+ games for Everton, signed for Manchester United and played for England when he was 18.

Of course Foden is at a much better side than Everton was back then but he's played in just 10 top flight games, that's it.

Not saying Foden won't be a great but people forget who good Rooney was as a teenager.
Yeah, when United did that video on him it really reminded me on how bloody good he was as a teenager. His CL debut was incredible!

Exactly my thoughts on it, he’s obviously talented, but let’s also not forget how dominant physically, Rooney was at that age, as well as technique. Foden would get chopped in half every other game if he was starting the same amount of games.
 

hasanejaz88

Full Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2017
Messages
5,812
Location
Munich
Supports
Germany
How about Jadon Sancho? He should have promised him enough first team chances. If you are good enough for starting at Borussia Dortmund, then you are certainly good enough to be the sub for the last 10 mins instead of 50m Bernardo Silva. He keeps stockpiling 50m players for the RW (he has three now), yet he had Sancho and Brahim Diaz, two very highly rated youngsters.

That is not to only criticize Pep on that matter, many top clubs are too afraid to play their youth at an early age. When did the last Juventus academy graduate earn a first team spot? What players did Barcelona, Bayern, Chelsea etc. pull up into the first team from their academy in the last decade? I can only think of Sergi Roberto at Barca and Alaba at Bayern. One first team player in a decade is such a poor record. No excuses for that.
Toni Kroos, David Alaba, Thomas Muller, Holger Badstuber (was a regular before injuries destroyed him). All have played more than 150 times for Bayern and played their first professional matches for the club.

Bayern are suffering with a lack of quality youth players now but for the past decade their teams base (including Lahm and Schweinsteiger) has been their youth products.
 

Offsideagain

Full Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Messages
1,683
Location
Cheshire
Foden is a City fan so he’ll take the crap ready to be doles out to him, believe the genius Pep that he has a great future and before he knowps it he’ll be 25 and played 6 games a season because the genius prefers Spanish players.
Then again, Guardiola will bugger off either next season, especially if they bomb in the CL again, or the one after.

Foden looks fragile too. He’s injured apparently for the match today. Wilshere mark2? Good luck to the lad though, but I fear for him at the soap opera that is Man City.
 

Don Alfredo

Full Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2018
Messages
2,071
Supports
Germany
Toni Kroos, David Alaba, Thomas Muller, Holger Badstuber (was a regular before injuries destroyed him). All have played more than 150 times for Bayern and played their first professional matches for the club.

Bayern are suffering with a lack of quality youth players now but for the past decade their teams base (including Lahm and Schweinsteiger) has been their youth products.
Kroos, Muller and Badstuber left the Bayern academy in 2009. That is not part of this decade, it means they have only pulled up one first team player in 9 years.

I stand by David Alaba being the only succesful youth product in a long time, and even he joined the team 7 years ago. I don't know why Bayern is lacking the talent in their academy. One decade is around 5 generations of U18 players, and there hasn't been one good player there (besides Alaba)? Maybe their coaching is lacking? I mean it's not like there is a general dearth of talent in German football. The usual suspects of Schalke and Stuttgart still went on to produce national team players, some of them are well on their way to become world class.

Anyway I feel were are drifting away a bit, since this the Phil Foden thread, not the Bayern academy thread.
 

deafepl

New Member
Joined
May 19, 2017
Messages
2,974
Which means he played for and graduated from City's academy. If you play for an academy you're a graduate of it. It's a simple concept.
He's not city graduate, he didn't sign a professional contract with City and City didn't give him debut.
 

LFCFAN

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 15, 2016
Messages
27
Supports
Liverpool
The u17 team that won the World Cup was brilliant and I wouldn't be surprised if at least 2 from the likes of Hudson-Odoi, Sancho, Foden, Brewster, Gomes, Panzo went on to become World Class.