Leeds (dirty thugs) discussion

Kasper

Full Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2013
Messages
3,579
Supports
Hansa Rostock / Bradford City
Lampard's response

Haha, suddenly everything is "par for the course" yet he was super shocked and outraged when Bielsa had someone watch his training? A thing that teams have been doing for decades and barely any ex-player was surprised by it. What a clown.
 

GazTheLegend

Full Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2014
Messages
3,595
Two things here - 1. Are you sure other clubs don't do in-depth statistical analysis? 2. Does it matter how a club gets promoted/does well ? If Burnley do well without Excel sheets, I doubt they're going to care much.
  1. It varies from club to club I’m sure. Do most clubs use an analytic department? Yes. Do I think it’s trusted by football managers and coaches? No.
  2. It matters. A lot. Leeds United were a shit side last season. Little has changed personnel wise yet they are performing incredibly well. Guardiola is known for being a control freak over every aspect of the game. Doesn’t matter as much as the ability of your players but it matters. I feel like England lagged behind in European terms mainly as we lacked such intelligence in our methodology compared with the Germans and Spanish. We had the best team in the world in 2006, but not the best coaches.

As I showed before though, our coaching staff didn’t even know what position James Wilson played, so you tell me if it’s commonplace or if it matters.
 

SirAF

Ageist
Joined
Sep 28, 2003
Messages
37,563
Location
  1. It varies from club to club I’m sure. Do most clubs use an analytic department? Yes. Do I think it’s trusted by football managers and coaches? No.
  2. It matters. A lot. Leeds United were a shit side last season. Little has changed personnel wise yet they are performing incredibly well. Guardiola is known for being a control freak over every aspect of the game. Doesn’t matter as much as the ability of your players but it matters. I feel like England lagged behind in European terms mainly as we lacked such intelligence in our methodology compared with the Germans and Spanish. We had the best team in the world in 2006, but not the best coaches.
As I showed before though, our coaching staff didn’t even know what position James Wilson played, so you tell me if it’s commonplace or if it matters.
"Wilson in the hole?" Not sure if I was going to laugh or despair!
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,350
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
Haha, suddenly everything is "par for the course" yet he was super shocked and outraged when Bielsa had someone watch his training? A thing that teams have been doing for decades and barely any ex-player was surprised by it. What a clown.
He’s right. I’m sure that analysis is par for the course. Like I said a few times, the fawning reaction from journos is ridiculous. You’d think Bielsa had cracked nuclear fission.

As for being shocked about someone spying on their training. I can’t remember the police ever getting involved in something like this. So it really is unprecedented. Unless there’s another incident I’m forgetting about?
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,350
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
Read this and it's far below the level of detail Biesla went into. It basically observes that Shearer flicks onto Owen.
It’s also 13 years old. Fairly sure that was in the days when even assists weren’t published online. These days there’s an absolute shit ton more data, which even schmucks like us can find on t’internet. So stands to reason that analysis for professionals has got miles more complex.
 

Dave89

Full Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2007
Messages
17,553
Is there a full video of the conference anywhere? All I can find is clips and the transcript.
 

Kasper

Full Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2013
Messages
3,579
Supports
Hansa Rostock / Bradford City
He’s right. I’m sure that analysis is par for the course. Like I said a few times, the fawning reaction from journos is ridiculous. You’d think Bielsa had cracked nuclear fission.

As for being shocked about someone spying on their training. I can’t remember the police ever getting involved in something like this. So it really is unprecedented. Unless there’s another incident I’m forgetting about?
Well the police got involved because they were called by Derby. They did nothing in the end because, as pointed out before, the man did nothing wrong.
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,350
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
Well the police got involved because they were called by Derby. They did nothing in the end because, as pointed out before, the man did nothing wrong.
That’s neither here nor there. My point was that it’s a novel situation for a manager to get involved with. The police being called to deal with an employee of a rival club spying on his training session. Hence Lampard’s dealing with questions I’ve never heard any other football manager have to deal with.

So there’s nothing even remotely strange about him a) finding Bielsa’s analysis “par for the course” and b) being taken aback by what happened.
 

Kasper

Full Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2013
Messages
3,579
Supports
Hansa Rostock / Bradford City
That’s neither here nor there. My point was that it’s a novel situation for a manager to get involved with. The police being called to deal with an employee of a rival club spying on his training session. Hence Lampard’s dealing with questions I’ve never heard any other football manager have to deal with.

So there’s nothing even remotely strange about him a) finding Bielsa’s analysis “par for the course” and b) being taken aback by what happened.
My point is, the situation is novel because Lempard and Derby made them that way. If I call he police because someone on my street is eating an apple citing "Neighborhood disturbance" or something, the situation didn't arise because the man was eating an apple but because I made the decision to call the police.

Lampard can't call the police and then be "taken aback by what happened" based on the police envolvement. A guy was watching their training session which happens all over the world, Fat Frank decided to cry about it, end off.
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,350
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
My point is, the situation is novel because Lempard and Derby made them that way. If I call he police because someone on my street is eating an apple citing "Neighborhood disturbance" or something, the situation didn't arise because the man was eating an apple but because I made the decision to call the police.

Lampard can't call the police and then be "taken aback by what happened" based on the police envolvement. A guy was watching their training session which happens all over the world, Fat Frank decided to cry about it, end off.
Lampard didn’t call the police.
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,325
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
This discussion about spying training is a bit irrelevant, tbh. There are little to no secrets about the opposition in a highly competitive and money oriented sport like modern football, and you can't really fully prepare a new offensive or defensive pattern within a week.

Bielsa is just being OCD levels of spying IMHO
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,444
Supports
Mejbri
This discussion about spying training is a bit irrelevant, tbh. There are little to no secrets about the opposition in a highly competitive and money oriented sport like modern football, and you can't really fully prepare a new offensive or defensive pattern within a week.

Bielsa is just being OCD levels of spying IMHO
The most sensible take on this I've seen. I think some managers are far too precious about this. And the "par for the course" bit I thought was funny.

Sure, everyone has data analysts and scouts, but not everyone will personally get stuck into every minute detail. The guy is known for being a mad eccentric and this is one of the offshoots of that.

If you were preparing some really specific tactical plan that you wanted to keep secret, you'd not train it outdoors if you had a healthy level of paranoia which you'd do well to have given the stakes, media environment etc.

The TL;DR of this whole episode is a bit:

Bielsa spies on Derby.
Moral outrage ensues.
Holds press conference to show detail of planning.
UK Press is like "wow, there is planning!"
Caf is like "everyone plans, it's standard."
UK managers are like "we all do this, this is not special".

I think it's the personal hands on approach and obsessing about details that isn't "par for the course". Someone here said PL managers are competent by virtue of being PL managers. As if being appointed somehow proves that you are worthy. Makes no sense. Some are good, some are OK, some terrible and a few exceptional.
 

André Dominguez

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
6,325
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Benfica, Académica
The most sensible take on this I've seen. I think some managers are far too precious about this. And the "par for the course" bit I thought was funny.

Sure, everyone has data analysts and scouts, but not everyone will personally get stuck into every minute detail. The guy is known for being a mad eccentric and this is one of the offshoots of that.

If you were preparing some really specific tactical plan that you wanted to keep secret, you'd not train it outdoors if you had a healthy level of paranoia which you'd do well to have given the stakes, media environment etc.

The TL;DR of this whole episode is a bit:

Bielsa spies on Derby.
Moral outrage ensues.
Holds press conference to show detail of planning.
UK Press is like "wow, there is planning!"
Caf is like "everyone plans, it's standard."
UK managers are like "we all do this, this is not special".

I think it's the personal hands on approach and obsessing about details that isn't "par for the course". Someone here said PL managers are competent by virtue of being PL managers. As if being appointed somehow proves that you are worthy. Makes no sense. Some are good, some are OK, some terrible and a few exceptional.
Bielsa is clearly a case of wanting to keep the hands on the dirty work, and he clearly thinks that his eyes can see details that others can't. In a lot of cases that might be true, I reckon, but the data analysis software nowadays is very advanced, and if the person who's doing the inputs understands very well the purpose of his job, there will be little error margin.

About preparing the secret tactic: the best you could do is preparing a different approach on set-pieces, because tactically speaking, the tactical training on offense and defense is based on patterns and templates:
players will learn how to react to a determined template / pattern as a unit and using different scenarios. you can't simply prepare your team to defend / attack a new pattern / template in 3/4 days, unless you manage a top club, who has super gifted players that will immediatly understand what the coach wants and will be able to execute the pattern in just a few atempts.

About the last sentence, tottally agree. Marco Silva wasn't that rated in Portugal and ended up being a EPL manager. Sometimes the appointments are totally out of the blue.
I'm sure Chelsea fans were surprised with Scolari appointment.
 

duffer

Sensible and not a complete jerk like most oppo's
Scout
Joined
Jun 24, 2004
Messages
50,138
Location
Chelsea (the saviours of football) fan.
Why did Leeds owners formally apologise and say they would have a word with Bielsa about ethics?

Seems the only people to have a problem with it are Derby and the Leeds owner.
 

the_irish123

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 2, 2018
Messages
865
I'm sorry Bielsa is so overrated. The man who failed to go past group stage with Argentina and lost a copa america to 4th string Brazil. His only titles are the argentinean league 20 years ago.
 

Samid

He's no Bilal Ilyas Jhandir
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
49,157
Location
Oslo, Norway
"Of course we needed another alternative for the goalkeeper postion, the arrival of a goalkeeper like Casillas excludes any comet from my side. For him to choose Leeds is a succes for the institution. The responsable of this arrival is Victor Orta"

All the spies, scouts and player reports in the world, yet he somehow thinks they have signed Casillas :lol:
 

Ayush_reddevil

Éire Abú
Joined
Mar 22, 2014
Messages
10,665
Boggles my mind that so many people in this thread actually believe that not every club in the top 3-4 leagues in England don't do this
 

Keeps It tidy

Hates Messi
Joined
Jun 6, 2013
Messages
17,638
Location
New York
Boggles my mind that so many people in this thread actually believe that not every club in the top 3-4 leagues in England don't do this
I think all the clubs definitely do this level of opposition analysis. But, I really do not think every club send spies to opposition training sessions.
 

Skorenzy

Full Member
Joined
May 2, 2011
Messages
5,945
"Of course we needed another alternative for the goalkeeper postion, the arrival of a goalkeeper like Casillas excludes any comet from my side. For him to choose Leeds is a succes for the institution. The responsable of this arrival is Victor Orta"

All the spies, scouts and player reports in the world, yet he somehow thinks they have signed Casillas :lol:

Kiko Casilla, not Iker Casillas.
 

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,444
Supports
Mejbri
Bielsa is clearly a case of wanting to keep the hands on the dirty work, and he clearly thinks that his eyes can see details that others can't. In a lot of cases that might be true, I reckon, but the data analysis software nowadays is very advanced, and if the person who's doing the inputs understands very well the purpose of his job, there will be little error margin.

About preparing the secret tactic: the best you could do is preparing a different approach on set-pieces, because tactically speaking, the tactical training on offense and defense is based on patterns and templates:
players will learn how to react to a determined template / pattern as a unit and using different scenarios. you can't simply prepare your team to defend / attack a new pattern / template in 3/4 days, unless you manage a top club, who has super gifted players that will immediatly understand what the coach wants and will be able to execute the pattern in just a few atempts.

About the last sentence, tottally agree. Marco Silva wasn't that rated in Portugal and ended up being a EPL manager. Sometimes the appointments are totally out of the blue.
I'm sure Chelsea fans were surprised with Scolari appointment.
Of course it's developed as quickly as everything else in that realm but the need for human intelligence and knowing how to apply it and interpret it is still required. You can see in the Sunderland 'til I die docu-series what they do there, which appears quite minimal compared to Bielsa. Anyone can have the same software, but expertise and competence is a spectrum, it's not just a binary yes or no, or a full on AI.

With regards to the secret tactic, spot on. Which makes it even more pointless to be complaining about someone looking at your training. You really should expect that.

I don't think anyone would have expected Leeds to be doing as well as they are. The people here who are saying Bielsa is an overrated manager have no idea. Never coached in England and look where they are now and how they play.
 

amolbhatia50k

Sneaky bum time - Vaccination status: dozed off
Joined
Nov 8, 2002
Messages
95,336
Location
india
The most sensible take on this I've seen. I think some managers are far too precious about this. And the "par for the course" bit I thought was funny.

Sure, everyone has data analysts and scouts, but not everyone will personally get stuck into every minute detail. The guy is known for being a mad eccentric and this is one of the offshoots of that.

If you were preparing some really specific tactical plan that you wanted to keep secret, you'd not train it outdoors if you had a healthy level of paranoia which you'd do well to have given the stakes, media environment etc.

The TL;DR of this whole episode is a bit:

Bielsa spies on Derby.
Moral outrage ensues.
Holds press conference to show detail of planning.
UK Press is like "wow, there is planning!"
Caf is like "everyone plans, it's standard."
UK managers are like "we all do this, this is not special".

I think it's the personal hands on approach and obsessing about details that isn't "par for the course". Someone here said PL managers are competent by virtue of being PL managers. As if being appointed somehow proves that you are worthy. Makes no sense. Some are good, some are OK, some terrible and a few exceptional.
And is Bielsa good, ok, terrible or exceptional?

I imagine every manage doesn't go into this sort of detail I'm pretty sure plenty go into as much detail as they need to be effective. I also think that competence is found throughout top level management (not everybody but it's fairly commonplace) just like you'd expect the top 50 tennis players to be competent. Let's not assume someone who doesn't draw up excel sheet isn't competent.

It's also interesting how the people in your TLDR version who come across badly are the media, fans and British manager with Bielsa the intellectual hero of this tale I presume.

My view is limited to feeling there's been a rather over the top hoopla over both the spying and Bielsa himself.
 
Last edited:

Bastian

Full Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2015
Messages
18,444
Supports
Mejbri
And is Bielsa good, ok, terrible or exceptional?

I imagine every manage doesn't go into this sort of detail I'm pretty sure plenty go into as much detail as they need to be effective. I also think that competence is found throughout top level management (not everybody but it's fairly commonplace) just like you'd expect the top 50 tennis players to be competent. Let's not assume someone who doesn't draw up excel sheet isn't competent.

It's also interesting how the people in your TLDR version who come across badly are the media, fans and British manager with Bielsa the intellectual hero of this tale I presume.

My view is limited to feeling there's been a rather over the top hoopla over both the spying and Bielsa himself.
In tennis you can only rely on yourself really. You can be a bit of a clueless manager, or very very limited, and have a coaching setup around you and individual talent that gets you over the line (mind, not achieve any significant success).

The UK angle you mentioned in my post is maybe there because of people like Glenn Roeder, Tim Sherwood, Alan Pardew and the sort. People I think disprove the theory that because you are in charge of a PL club you are somehow competent. After all, the people who appoint you have to be competent too. Which of course is not always the case, and again, is a spectrum from low to high.
 

Solius

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Staff
Joined
Dec 31, 2007
Messages
86,292
I think he's hilarious. Love that he didn't give a shit.
 

amolbhatia50k

Sneaky bum time - Vaccination status: dozed off
Joined
Nov 8, 2002
Messages
95,336
Location
india
In tennis you can only rely on yourself really. You can be a bit of a clueless manager, or very very limited, and have a coaching setup around you and individual talent that gets you over the line (mind, not achieve any significant success).

The UK angle you mentioned in my post is maybe there because of people like Glenn Roeder, Tim Sherwood, Alan Pardew and the sort. People I think disprove the theory that because you are in charge of a PL club you are somehow competent. After all, the people who appoint you have to be competent too. Which of course is not always the case, and again, is a spectrum from low to high.
Well of course not every appointment is competent. That would be silly. But plenty are. To be a competent PL manager is not an anomaly.

You didn't answer though - which category does Bielsa fall in? I'm sure he's influential but why on earth has all this competence landed him at the lofty heights of Leeds United?