Jadon Sancho| Staying at Dortmund for now

Status
Not open for further replies.

limerickcitykid

There once was a kid from Toronto...
Joined
Oct 3, 2012
Messages
14,051
Location
East end / Oot and aboot
Apart from that. Anyone who watched the under 17 world cup triumph could see Sancho, Foden and Brewster were top dogs. Amongst the huge pool of serioustalent england had including Hudson Odoi and Gomes. To name a few
Brewster is nowhere near a top dog and looked shit half the time despite the goals.
 

Bobski

Full Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2017
Messages
9,662
Zaha-Hudson Odoi similarities do spring to mind. I think Hudson-Odoi is a smoother mover than Zaha though, who in bulking up as he has aged has lost some of that fluidity of movement. Technically I think that Hudson-Odoi looks more advanced, even at this age. First touch was an issue for Zaha at Utd, and he still has problems with it at times.

Don't see Zaha having the game to be a success at a big club, very much a big fish in small pond type to my eyes, Hudson-Odoi just looks a better prospect even on the limited mins I have seen of him, plays a smarter, more team orientated game.
 

Adisa

likes to take afvanadva wothowi doubt
Joined
Nov 28, 2014
Messages
50,309
Location
Birmingham
Absolutely agree with that reasoning. We should sign players that what to make a name for themselves at the club and not just some stop on their journey after already proving themselves. I'd pick Sancho ahead of Bale everyone even though Bale is clearly the better player.
 

breakout67

Full Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2017
Messages
9,050
Supports
Man City
Absolutely agree with that reasoning. We should sign players that what to make a name for themselves at the club and not just some stop on their journey after already proving themselves. I'd pick Sancho ahead of Bale everyone even though Bale is clearly the better player.
IMO Sancho is better this season and their career paths are heading in different directions. Bale has lost a bit of sharpness to his game, he's still a good player but makes poor touches more often and isn't as effective at dribbling. He's still lightning quick and has a rocket of a left foot though. Wage demands alone would put me off Bale.
 

Beaucoup

Full Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2016
Messages
1,563
Would you say that if Hudson-Odoi had scored 10 goals this season in the PL? Or is it because it doesn't fit your narrative?
Sancho is further along with his development, If he’d stayed at City I would imagine his stats would be equal to, or worse than Hudson-Odoi.
 

Litch

Full Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
10,183
Of course it does. Playing for a top team in Germany expecting to challenge for the title is exactly the same. If he can do it there he can do it here.

If you don’t rate him that’s fine, but I guarantee if we sign him he will be top class.
Germany is like Scotland....99% of the time, you are playing for 2nd and the rest of the teams know that. Each to their own but for me it's ridiculous to make the comparison with the two leagues. What I can guarantee you is, Bayern isn't winning the league here every season.

Never said don't rate him, just don't think he's worth the figures being talked about.
 

Litch

Full Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
10,183
But you would be happy to spend 80m and then loan him back and then he comes a year after and we find out then he doesn't have the mentality? I don't understand your logic.
I'd like to think we'd have worked that out before transferring the money. Wasn't suggesting loaning him back after buying him was a 'test', more the opportunity to continue to grow away from the pressure and the spotlight of our media. Isn't that what happens with young players anyway?
 

Negan

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 30, 2018
Messages
647
If we don’t sign Sancho and Koulibaly in the summer, we’re not winning anything.

On top of us simply not signing them, one of our rivals are going to instead.
 

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,029
I'd like to think we'd have worked that out before transferring the money. Wasn't suggesting loaning him back after buying him was a 'test', more the opportunity to continue to grow away from the pressure and the spotlight of our media. Isn't that what happens with young players anyway?
It's slightly confusing. So you are happy to spend 80m based on one breakthrough season as long as we loan him back, but not happy to spend 80m based on one breakthrough season if he has to join immediately?

Which younger players for United? Actually quite a few of them that made it big here at United came and developed under the pressure and spotlight in our media. Granted some did develop away but lately I believe our success with loans vs players who stayed is in favour of those who stayed.
 

Litch

Full Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
10,183
It's slightly confusing. So you are happy to spend 80m based on one breakthrough season as long as we loan him back, but not happy to spend 80m based on one breakthrough season if he has to join immediately?

Which younger players for United? Actually quite a few of them that made it big here at United came and developed under the pressure and spotlight in our media. Granted some did develop away but lately I believe our success with loans vs players who stayed is in favour of those who stayed.
You see this is what happens on here as the discussion moves away from the original point. My point wasn't about being 'happy', it was a compromise to paying 80m at 18, playing for the biggest club in the world and being crushed in the media and on here if it doesn't work out. The numbers are unusual but the principles of this practice is common in football.
It's very different developing at your club than signing for it as the player cost nothing.

Pogba signed for 90m and even winning things and putting in some decent performances still today its questioned whether he was worth it. When we lose, people question every aspect of his life negatively as a contributing factor. He is completely under the spotlight. I can't imagine the pressure exerted on this lads shoulders if he's signed for more than Pogba and becomes the poster boy of English football. Sterling is another example too.....
 

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,029
You see this is what happens on here as the discussion moves away from the original point. My point wasn't about being 'happy', it was a compromise to paying 80m at 18, playing for the biggest club in the world and being crushed in the media and on here if it doesn't work out. The numbers are unusual but the principles of this practice is common in football.
It's very different developing at your club than signing for it as the player cost nothing.

Pogba signed for 90m and even winning things and putting in some decent performances still today its questioned whether he was worth it. When we lose, people question every aspect of his life negatively as a contributing factor. He is completely under the spotlight. I can't imagine the pressure exerted on this lads shoulders if he's signed for more than Pogba and becomes the poster boy of English football. Sterling is another example too.....
Indeed and Sterling has done well. Rooney did too.
What I mean is where are the examples of a loan working in this case?
I'm not saying your wrong, I just can't think of many.

For me if you decide to pay 80m then you bring them in. If you don't believe they can handle that pressure, you don't spend the 80m
 

Litch

Full Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
10,183
Indeed and Sterling has done well. Rooney did too.
What I mean is where are the examples of a loan working in this case?
I'm not saying your wrong, I just can't think of many.

For me if you decide to pay 80m then you bring them in. If you don't believe they can handle that pressure, you don't spend the 80m
Not the same but I like how PSG handled the Mbappe transfer. He was signed on loan and whilst we know what he cost, it was deferred and almost went under the radar (as best paying 180m could do) in a way that it won't have if he was signed in a more traditional way. I understand there were more factors to this and it helped having Neymar profile at the club but that's what loaning him back could achieve. Whilst we know he's coming, just arrives in a different way deferring the interest and hysteria.

I think it's easy for us all to forget, irrespective of the figures involved, can't fast track how you grow emotionally and maturely. Like I said, it hard enough signing for this club under normal circumstances but under this situation with the backstory of potentially Ole's first major signing, ex city, his age, being English, probably the no.7 shirt, the fee and his wages at 18....the pressure to succeed is going to be immense.
Loan idea might be a crap one but these kind of signings are unprecedented and require a different approach....
 
Last edited:

Paxi

Dagestani MMA Boiled Egg Expert
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
27,678
If we go for Bale instead of Sancho I'll fecking cry.
 

Cassidy

No longer at risk of being mistaken for a Scouser
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
31,029
Not the same but I like how PSG handled the Mbappe transfer. He was signed on loan and whilst we know what he cost, it was deferred and almost went under the radar (as best paying 180m could do) in a way that it won't have if he was signed in a more traditional way. I understand there were more factors to this and it helped having Neymar profile at the club but that's what loaning him back could achieve. Whilst we know he's coming, just arrives in a different way deferring the interest and hysteria.

I think it's easy for us all to forget, irrespective of the figures involved, can't fast track how you grow emotionally and maturely. Like I said, it hard enough signing for this club under normal circumstances but under this situation with the backstory of potentially Ole's first major signing, ex city, his age, being English, probably the no.7 shirt, the fee and his wages at 18....the pressure to succeed is going to be immense.
Loan idea might be a crap one but these kind of signings are unprecedented and require a different approach....
It didnt go under the radar. The cost was known and everyone knew it was done to avoid FFP

The interest and hysteria wasnt deffered at all to be honest.

I actually agree with what you’re saying overall. That it might be too soon for Sancho to handle the pressure and may need more time.

If thats the case don’t pay 80m. Pay a lesser fee and loan him out.

But if the club feel he does have the mentaloty then get him in. Personally I think he actually might have it.
 

Litch

Full Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
10,183
It didnt go under the radar. The cost was known and everyone knew it was done to avoid FFP
Isn't that what I already alluded to that there were other factors and as much as paying 180m for a teenager, it def didn't have the same impact as loaning him first irrespective of the motivation behind it.
 

beingshe7don

Full Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2016
Messages
2,735
We can't afford to blow our budget on Sancho.... even though he's good. Dortmund don't want to sell him. He's English and he's only 18.... He's gonna cost us close to 130m and we can't be pulling off another stupid decision again... Lukaku ended up costing us 90m and he's not been a 90m worth player.. He's at best a 60m player..... so we ended up paying 30m extra for absolutely horseshit. We need to be a lot shrewd in the market. Rabiot would be an intelligent buy..... He's only 23 and would have a good resale value... Essentially his transfer fee in the future would pay for his wages at United. Pepe from Lille would be a good value buy as well. I don't see anyone going for him which would prevent the price to be inflated. Pepe for 50m would be great value. I think we should get 2 CBs..... Alderweireld for 25m would be a good coup while we try and nab Koulibaly. Lindelof, Smalling, Alderweireld, Koulibaly would be great options for us. I would use Bailly in the transfer of Koulibaly to drive the price down. Bailly is worth about 35m..... Baiily + 55m would be good deal for us and Napoli. We need another CM even if Herrera resigns with us. I just don't trust Pereira and Fred to come good. Pereira can actually play in the No. 10 role for us but Fred just doesn't seem like he will fit the PL. I would definitely try to get Ndombele... We rely heavily on Pogba for our play making abilities.

We need to move Sanchez on just to deal with his wages. He's also eating up on playing time. The benefit of getting Pepe in is that he's 24 which gives Greenwood and Chong time to develop and take over when Pepe is moved on. With Sancho, I have a feeling that Greenwood and Chong's development may get stifled.
 

sport2793

Full Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2012
Messages
3,161
Location
USA
What budget? Ed Woodward doesn't mind as Sancho will sell him plenty of shirts and contribute to a marketing campaign that "wittily" included Alexis playing the piano.
 

Frank Grimes

Full Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2014
Messages
8,608
Location
Newbies 15/16 FPL Champion.
If we don’t sign Sancho and Koulibaly in the summer, we’re not winning anything.

On top of us simply not signing them, one of our rivals are going to instead.
Those 2 would cost 180-200m. If we were to get Sancho I'd be happy. Alderweireld, Rabiot and Sancho in the window with possibly another mid priced signing. Not convinced Koulibaly is all that for 80m, we can find better value.

Alderweireld 25m
Rabiot Free
Sancho 100m
Lozano or Fernandes 50m

That would be a decent window.

--------------------------DDG----------------------
Dalot----------Alderweireld----Lindelof--------Shaw
-------------------------Rabiot--------------------------
----------------Fred/Fernandes--------------Pogba--------------------
Sancho-----------------Lukaku-------------Lozano/Martial
 

Adam-Utd

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
39,954
Bale's talent has never been in doubt, but he never wanted to join us when he had the chance. I don't want players joining that are only coming because they've no other choice.

He's also hugely injury prone and will be on massive wages - another player hard to shift when he fails.
 

SirAF

Ageist
Joined
Sep 28, 2003
Messages
37,563
Location
Bale's talent has never been in doubt, but he never wanted to join us when he had the chance. I don't want players joining that are only coming because they've no other choice.

He's also hugely injury prone and will be on massive wages - another player hard to shift when he fails.
Bingo. He’ll also be useless when his pace starts to decline.
 

Adam-Utd

Part of first caf team to complete Destiny raid
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
39,954
Bingo. He’ll also be useless when his pace starts to decline.
Which has already happened arguably. He's still a good passer and can score goals out of nowhere but we will be lucky to get 2 seasons max.

Worryingly though we know Woody has a hard on for Bale, he seems to have tried for him every summer.

Ole has been quite vocal in saying he wants a young option though, I think he wants us to run a lot and press, I can't see Bale doing that anymore.
 

sincher

"I will cry if Rooney leaves"
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
25,587
Location
YSC
I actually watched the piece this came from and it was him and Matt Holland doing a dream team for next season and I think it is paraphrased slightly. It doesn't come across as either or exactly when you watch it. Not saying that Phil isn't a bit of a tit at times mind you :)

For anyone who gives a shit :
Muppets R Us
 
Status
Not open for further replies.