United's rebuild has not even started and won't start any time soon and here's why

Lentwood

Full Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
6,827
Location
West Didsbury, Manchester
No, I disagree with that. Hodgson had the same tools Klopp had, but he wasn't up to the task of re-building Liverpool. Klopp re-built Liverpool. Pep transformed City from being a top 4 teams to a dominant winning machine.

We have the resources, we have the platform, but we don't have the right manager in charge.
Not having the right manager in charge is debatable

I can’t be bothered to keep arguing the point with people though. Just look at the timeline of City and Liverpool’s transformations. Michael Edwards was appointed as Sporting Director shortly before Klopp was hired. City told us all their plan and executed it brilliantly by getting Tkiki to lay the foundations for Guardiola’s arrival.

As I’ve said before, it’s a team effort. Put Hamilton in a Lotus, he doesn’t win a single Grand Prix. Put me in a Mercedes and they don’t win a single Grand Prix.
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,616
Not having the right manager in charge is debatable

I can’t be bothered to keep arguing the point with people though. Just look at the timeline of City and Liverpool’s transformations. Michael Edwards was appointed as Sporting Director shortly before Klopp was hired. City told us all their plan and executed it brilliantly by getting Tkiki to lay the foundations for Guardiola’s arrival.

As I’ve said before, it’s a team effort. Put Hamilton in a Lotus, he doesn’t win a single Grand Prix. Put me in a Mercedes and they don’t win a single Grand Prix.
He was promoted as Sporting director after Klopp took charge, he was at Liverpool long before that but in different role.
 

The Irish Connection

Full Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2017
Messages
2,320
I agree and right wing has frustrated me for years! We also bought Sanchez and played him on the left when Martial had been on a good run there. All the while completely neglecting the right. Can't get my head round the logic. There's been a lack of proper planning for a long time. The neglect of the squad has been ridiculous and dates back to before Fergie retired. Should never have required a rebuild - the team should see a natural evolution but thats impossible now and maybe Fergie saw that.

I actually think enough money has been invested post Fergie, but not wisely enough. Nowhere near it. So now we need to spend more. Far more.
yes, it's madness.

with Sanchez, surely the first thing you make certain of is he will play most games on the right, otherwise, it's a poor decision and an unnecessary signing.

for me, on paper it looks like we've spent a lot but I'm convinced the money men are influencing the dithering and bargain bin signings.
my guess is managers are being told to try to sign a player for under 30 million say, e.g. bailly, lindelof, dalot, Herrera etc. whereas we would have been better off spending 50-70m on one proper player instead of getting two average ones in the hope they become much better.

in the transfer market of the last 5 years, most top quality players cost at least 50 million, especially for us.