I often feel the 2 Liverpool lads bully Neville a bit, they certainly won't do that with Keano. You can see a totally different demeanour with both of them when dealing with Keano. They will both argue their point as they should do, but that arrogant way they almost shout over and talk down to Gary isn't there. Good to see. I also liked the way Keano didn't pussy about when talking about Martial and Pogba just because Evra was there. Rightly or wrongly, I happen to believe rightly, although I know and respect many others don't, but that's his viewpoint and he didn't alter it knowing it went against his "teammate" thoughts. Good to see from all of them, punditry where pundits give their views and not some generic cliched responses.
Keane joins Sky Sports
- Thread starter stubie
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
Love his Sky punditry 
He's hilarious. Roy picking man it's players in this team because he has loyalty to Giggs and doesn't know mane
He so wants to batter carragher surely theyre going to have a celeb boxing match at some point.
He so wants to batter carragher
surely theyre going to have a celeb boxing match at some point.He's taking the piss now
You’re not putting giggs in?
The absolutely flabbergasted look on his face was hilarious.
The absolutely flabbergasted look on his face was hilarious.
This is hilarious I don't know Mane.
I don't know Mane.He's right IMO.
not sure if Keane is being serious or just trolling Carraghar He looked devastated when told Giggs was not going to be in
This is brilliant
I agree
Slamming Arsenal celebrations about 5 minutes into the show was my highlight
Bloody hell why get Keane to do this
This team selection game has been a good one. Carragher trying to be so fair
This is absolute gold, his face when Jamie said he wouldn't put Giggs in! He'd have eleven United players if he could get away with it.
Keane is right. Im not having Mane over Giggs no way
Fecking brilliant.
Top form. That’s how an ex-red should talk about us. Nev would be squeezing as many scousers as possible into his team!
Mane over Giggs? Is that some kind of joke?
Mané is far better than Giggs tbh.
When Carragher meantioned the points that Liverpool have I wish Keane turned round and said
United played Barcelona, Bayern, Inter, Juventus and Bayern again to win the Champions League
United played Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal to win the FA cup.
We won the treble facing the hardest opposition throughout all the trophies. The Champions League is set up for easy routes these days. The FA cup they haven’t even had their manager attend one match.
United played Barcelona, Bayern, Inter, Juventus and Bayern again to win the Champions League
United played Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal to win the FA cup.
We won the treble facing the hardest opposition throughout all the trophies. The Champions League is set up for easy routes these days. The FA cup they haven’t even had their manager attend one match.
Disagree, if Giggs played today as a wide forward he would destroy this league IMO
No white text?
Keane on absolute top form tonight
Looked properly thrilled with the win straight after the game too
Looked properly thrilled with the win straight after the game too
That team selection thing had me laughing out loud so many times
Love Roy!
Love Roy!
Better at what?
If you speaking just on the 99 season then yeah Carragher is right about Mane over Giggs. But career wise Giggs hands down.
Mane could end up better, but there is still no competition if we look at it overall.
So so good. Now this is brilliant TV.
Love Keane. Despite his troubles with Fergie, he is United through and through.
Love Keane. Despite his troubles with Fergie, he is United through and through.
Giggs was a brilliant young player, but after that, he was never the ‘best’ player for me. He had great longevity, but for shorter periods, there were players who came in and were better than him I think.
Probably the most naturally gifted out of his fellow Fledglings, but behind Beckham and Scholes for me.
No, no white man, on this occasion.
No he fecking couldn’t
he’s not even a pimple on Giggs’ arse.What a ridiculously skewed metric.
What does ‘overall’ mean?
Opinions I guess, I think Becks and Scholes were better overall. As a winger in the PL Giggs is top 3/4 ever along with Pires Ronaldo and Hazard
I agree. Giggsy is 46 and past his best.
"Mane better than Giggs"
What am I reading!
What am I reading!
"Are going in Roy as a box to box midfield player...a sitting midfield player...what could you do?"
"Everything."
"Everything."
Can someone put the Curb Your Enthusiasm tune over that bit?
He looked devastated when told Giggs was not going to be in