Just as we get some depth, people start questioning if we have too much
I think we probably have players coming through the youth who could be better than Mctom or Fred. Either that or we can certainly buy better. Fred cost £52 mill VDB £35 mill according to media. Now Fred is nowhere near VDB quality and I'm sure there are other midfielders out there under £40 mill who are better as well. If we can get £35 mill+ for Fred we should snap their hands off. Whoever wanted him, Mourinho or Woody, he has been a poor buy for the outlay and what he has done here.How OGS manages this will be an interesting reflection on his ability to manage players. He now has genuine competition in the centre of the park.
VDB, Pogba and Bruno play, in all important games, that is the starting three and that's a given. The others have to sit and wait. Fred will not like that. McTominay may (may) be OK... for a season.
But I'm not sure either will accept this long term. Why should they?
We are stuck with Fred, unless we accept he’s going for a massive loss. He was never worth £50m when we bought him, we won’t get £35m for him, would be lucky to scrape £20m for him.I think we probably have players coming through the youth who could be better than Mctom or Fred. Either that or we can certainly buy better. Fred cost £52 mill VDB £35 mill according to media. Now Fred is nowhere near VDB quality and I'm sure there are other midfielders out there under £40 mill who are better as well. If we can get £35 mill+ for Fred we should snap their hands off. Whoever wanted him, Mourinho or Woody, he has been a poor buy for the outlay and what he has done here.
We already had depth. Now we have players who should be playing football and will get better offers than getting 10 starts a season for us.Just as we get some depth, people start questioning if we have too much
We have an injury crisis and look short every year, plus always seem to have an atrocious bench.We already had depth. Now we have players who should be playing football and will get better offers than getting 10 starts a season for us.
Lingard, Pereira, Mata to cover our midfield. Great depth.We had depth?
Not in midfield. Last year was the first time we'd had a first choice CM out for a long period. Its usually in defence where Fred isnt going to helpWe have an injury crisis and look short every year, plus always seem to have an atrocious bench.
Bumping this as we see yet again that McTominay is unable to fill the DM role in the side on the weekend.Obviously both have been in really good form this season and Fred especially has seen a huge jump in performances and consistency.
However, with the bruno, pogba, matic (classic DM) midfield 3 we have started to deploy, neither of them really fits. Neither are creative enough or disciplined enough to play any of the 3 roles effectively.
Of course we will need different systems and be adaptable throughout matches, but if we feel that pogba, bruno, matic is our best 3, and we need cover / a replacement for matic and a rotation option for bruno / pogba, do we actually need both players going forward or are they taking up space in a squad that would be better suited to someone who is a better fit.
I'm not saying we need to get rid of them immediately and we clearly have more important areas of the squad to trim, it just struck me as weird that 2 players who earlier in the season would have been guaranteed starters now don't fit our best 11 and no one is calling for them to be included. Thought it warranted discussion.
I think we definitely need a specialist DM but I also think we need to give Fred a go this season. He was important in not letting our midfield get pressed into oblivion against Sevilla and with how many teams are now employing a high-press in the PL we should be looking to integrate him instead of Matic whose inability to press/resist the press and mobility is beginning to form big question marks over his place in the team.Loads of chat around us needing a DM, yet we have
Fernandes
Pogba
Vdb
Matic
Mctominay
Fred
For 3 positions. While depth is important it raises the original question again, and I think the answer more than ever is no. Mctominay and Fred are arguably not he right depth because neither are the best option for any position. Or arguably even fit that well. We need one gone to invest in another specialist DM to compete with and eventually replace matic.
We all know why they're complaining. Their beloved managers job is in danger - we could've signed prime Messi, Ronaldo, Xavi and co this summer but the excuses would've still would've been out in abundance on why can't be expected to be in top 4 once again - not enough depth, too many primadonnas, too much depth, low morale, players weren't signed early, players were signed too early, the star signs aren't aligning.They are good depth. Not sure what people are complaining about.
I would keep both Fred and McTominay over Pogba. Pogba is the real dead wood.Loads of chat around us needing a DM, yet we have
Fernandes
Pogba
Vdb
Matic
Mctominay
Fred
For 3 positions. While depth is important it raises the original question again, and I think the answer more than ever is no. Mctominay and Fred are arguably not he right depth because neither are the best option for any position. Or arguably even fit that well. We need one gone to invest in another specialist DM to compete with and eventually replace matic.
That is exactly what should have happened in this window because it's clear as day that Scott & Fred aren't capable of playing that defensive role we badly needBumping this as we see yet again that McTominay is unable to fill the DM role in the side on the weekend.
Which brings up back to the point of wtf is the point of McTominay and Fred? This “amazing depth” people claim proves to be useless time after time due to the evident reason neither of them can actually play any of the roles we use in midfield. So what use are they outside the 20% of matches we play defensively? Why do we need two players to fill a role we only use on select occasions?
Get rid of one and get a midfielder actually capable of playing the role we need.
There is too much sentiment from the club for that to have happenedWe should of moved Fred on and got an actual #6. We only have Matic who can play that role.
It's actually crazy.I can’t believe we are having a go at them when they are actually playing well atm
They are not the reasons that we didn’t win yesterday
Greenwood and Pogba for James and Mata and we would have won
Absurd isn't it?I can’t believe we are having a go at them when they are actually playing well atm
They are not the reasons that we didn’t win yesterday
Greenwood and Pogba for James and Mata and we would have won