Puyol and Pique definitely belong in this thread.
Not saying neither was a good player, but their careers are massively overrated. Pique was getting one world XI nomination after the other when his performances barely showed for it.
I think he has 4 or 5 world XI appearances which is ridiculous when you consider that the likes of Chiellini or Jerome Boateng have none. Also Vidic and Ferdinand have just a single nonination.
Puyol is another one. His career being massively overrated after his playing days due to a few fairplay videos going viral. He was an average CB for the most of his career. Good leader though.