the season we signed Rio we won the league with the best defensive record in the league. The season after that we were first place, undefeated until Rio missed the drug test in Jan and then Arsenal went on that run and won the league. In 2005 we conceded only 26 goals, the 2nd least after Chelsea. Ferdinand made the PFA team of the season in 2002 and 2005 also. I dunno who told you he was a major flop. Maybe that was in another country.
Why would anyone tell me? I just watch the games and make up my own mind.
I watched Rio mature into a top class defender at Leeds. I was delighted when United signed him after the fiasco that was Blanc and I was expecting a Stam-like leader at the back.
But it didn't happen. He was back to the error prone, shaky defender from his West Ham days. His partnerships with Silvestre and Brown were real weak links of those sides where they still had one of the best midfields in Europe sitting in front of them. It always felt frantic and lacking organisation.
If you compare that to the feeling of absolute assurance that the team had during the Vidic years. Whether it was Vidic/Rio, Vidic/Evans or even Smalling or Jones next to Vidic, there was no feeling of dread as the ball came into the box or when the opposition attacked.
Rio is a fantastic media man. He's excellent in the media and his PR spin post his career has made him come across as a leader within the club driving standards for others to aspire to.
In reality, he was the idiot who forgot to do his drug test and with all of his "merked" nonsense was the Jesse Lingard of that era.
I'm sure he developed into more of a mature figure within the group as he got more experienced and wiser in his later years but he was Leeds captain when Fergie signed him and he clearly intended him to be the future club captain. But, it never happened and Vidic got the gig instead. Why do you think that is?