His balance is just not very good, he stumbles around a lot even on his mazy dribbles. I reckon it has something to do with his gangly legs. Just not the ideal centre of balance or whatever the phrase is? But then I don’t know anything about physique or balance or any of that tbh. Might be something to do with his core…but presumably there’s some fitness folks in here with a real answer?
I think it's more to do with the fact that he tries dribbles, shimmys, feints and does other ball carrying techniques in high risk and low percentage situations, which imo is down to several things we've discussed and dissected many times already e.g overdoing it, taking too much responsibility because there's no movement in front of him, playing too deep etc.
When he's further up the pitch and able to isolate players or in transition i.e where there's open space, his dribbling and 'strength' of ball retention is usually very good. To over simplify, It's when he's in the centre of the pitch, trying to take a ball under pressure and turn with players at all angles that I find he puts himself in those situations where he gets barged off etc.
We've seen two good examples in the previous two games already. That heavy touch when he caught Neves and again the touch after his step over just before the Lingard assist was him trying to do a hesitation and create space/angle to take on/draw a player in. Any other player would take a very simple and
steady touch before playing it. He likes 'loose' and 'open' touches so he can manipulate the ball for more passing angles and the opening of his body.
It's fantastic to watch and I love it but it's high risk.