I agree with the sentiment of some, it isnt based on seven games, it is his third season now. personally I think he has been overly criticised by a lot of fans and done quite a few things well within the transfer market....but simply not enough.
Forgettign the back room staff (contract extensions....why?), his tactics, teams selections, holding on to players too long, often seeming fairly happy with mediocre performances and failure to win any trophies are all negatives against him. He has generally done good signings for me though, he has addressed the youth set up...............
However for me, his failure this last window especially to address the central midfield problems in his whole time here bar signing VDB who hasnt played much (and I always tought was the wrogn signing) is really poor management. Bar die hard loyal fans of any player in a United shirt, I think for the vast majority, it is blindingly obvious our central mifield is weak and this has been evident for a good coupel fo seasons already, let alone these seven games when even average sides are bypassing us and on to our overly exposed defence....at will. Roy Keane is overly critical but his ""you wotn win trophies with that midfield" is so so true. Not only do they leav eour defence exposed, they also dont really bar Pogba (who cant play there as defensively he is a liability) offer much at all going forward. The limtied number of chances we are creating is partly due to our midfield as well.
We remind me a bit of Keegans Newcastle, great attackign line up, crap defence, same with us but its midfield....they were entertainign though