Rashford - New contract or sell?

What to do with Marcus Rashford...


  • Total voters
    1,226
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remember the geese

Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2018
Messages
6,728
Location
Northampton
You guys are so fickle. The guy have a few good weeks and 2 average years and its keep him now?? Sell him when you can still get a sucker, don't hold and regret. Think of him as a horrible stock that occasionally bursts up 3x 4x but will always crash down. He's at 4x now... if he remains 4x by summer ( miracle) sell him asap. The thing is by March his form would be gone again.... Rashford and martial are not title winners. The good news is united knows this and will get in some winners soon.

Rushford is good but over paid so should be gone
Martial is not good not even by Tottenham standards much less united
Who do we replace him with?
 

BABY_FACED_ASSASIN

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
18
we should ask ourselves, if we want him to sign for our rivals? this guy cost us nothing compared to other expensive players but he is more effective than them and I believe that Eth can get the best of him through coaching.
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,515
You guys are so fickle. The guy have a few good weeks and 2 average years and its keep him now?? Sell him when you can still get a sucker, don't hold and regret. Think of him as a horrible stock that occasionally bursts up 3x 4x but will always crash down. He's at 4x now... if he remains 4x by summer ( miracle) sell him asap. The thing is by March his form would be gone again.... Rashford and martial are not title winners. The good news is united knows this and will get in some winners soon.

Rushford is good but over paid so should be gone
Martial is not good not even by Tottenham standards much less united
:lol:
 

Dion

Full Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2010
Messages
4,327
If there isn't a place for someone as talented as Rashford around at United I don't really know what the point of the club is to be honest. He's more than good enough to be a squad player and he's Manc born and bred. That matters.
Still think the lad has a bit about him you know.
 

Rightnr

Wants players fined for winning away.
Joined
Jan 25, 2015
Messages
13,881
Just me who thinks he looks depressed in interviews?
Don't know about that. He looks very focused. You cannot perform the way he's at the moment without a bit of 'method acting'.

You can almost say he's absorbed a bit of that EtH seriousness and aspiration for perfection.

He's also in his mid-20s now and as much as people go on about what he did in the past, this comes with some maturity and level-headedness.

Now if he can just score a hattrick against Farca and throw them out, that'd be great.
 

tom8888sa

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 8, 2022
Messages
75
Supports
neutral
Who do we replace him with?
Harry kane or look deep at Eastern European Baltic strikers and Italian ones. Theres diamonds there..... bigger issue is martial of course but 'rashy' could be gone and united can make good $$$ and buy a true united player. If Rushford was Nigerian or Polish,his price will be halfed and he would not be playing for united. We all know this.
 

Red in STL

Turnover not takeover
Joined
Dec 1, 2022
Messages
9,332
Location
In Bed
Supports
The only team that matters
Harry kane or look deep at Eastern European Baltic strikers and Italian ones. Theres diamonds there..... bigger issue is martial of course but 'rashy' could be gone and united can make good $$$ and buy a true united player. If Rushford was Nigerian or Polish,his price will be halfed and he would not be playing for united. We all know this.
You don't get much truer than Rashford, he's playing for his home town which is what most kids dream of, he suits the team style, he's not going anywhere
 

redcucumber

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2022
Messages
3,165
Harry kane or look deep at Eastern European Baltic strikers and Italian ones. Theres diamonds there..... bigger issue is martial of course but 'rashy' could be gone and united can make good $$$ and buy a true united player. If Rushford was Nigerian or Polish,his price will be halfed and he would not be playing for united. We all know this.
Which Eastern European Baltic striker has proven as much as Rashford has, out of interest?
 

Rolaholic

Full Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2016
Messages
11,147
Local lad and academy graduate with a 100+ goals in United colors to his name at 25 yet he's not a 'true' United player and apparently wouldn't be in the team if he was foreign...

Even after years, the utter shite and tripe that you read on here sometimes is truly something to behold :lol::houllier:

It's like certain 'fans' seemingly hate everything that makes United United...
 

tom8888sa

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 8, 2022
Messages
75
Supports
neutral
You don't get much truer than Rashford, he's playing for his home town which is what most kids dream of, he suits the team style, he's not going anywhere
Seem like most
Local lad and academy graduate with a 100+ goals in United colors to his name at 25 yet he's not a 'true' United player and apparently wouldn't be in the team if he was foreign...

Even after years, the utter shite and tripe that you read on here sometimes is truly something to behold :lol::houllier:

It's like certain 'fans' seemingly hate everything that makes United United...
How am I wrong though? Be honest. If Rashford was Jamaican and his performances last 3 years was for Hetha Berlin or something, would United be trying to buy him? Yes or no.

Think back to his last 3 years. Now say he's just some Jamaican midfielder playing for some mid level bundesliga club. Is the last 3 years worthy of united dropping a 90m offer ? No. Of course not.

Also look at this poll, the results speak for itself. People just changed their mind over the last several weeks.. which is absurd.
 

tom8888sa

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 8, 2022
Messages
75
Supports
neutral
Which Eastern European Baltic striker has proven as much as Rashford has, out of interest?
Not eastern European but Harry kane dominates him. United cant afford hane unless they sell rashford and martial. Than use that money over summer to get kane.
 

bosnian_red

Worst scout to ever exist
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
57,585
Location
Canada
It's honestly wild to me just how against him people got, that 85% of this forum wanted him out... Shows how fickle fans are. Was always dumb as hell to write him off, but i guess some people are incapable of being objective and look at the full picture. It was a disaster season so everyone with the club should have left according to many.
 

gza the genius

Full Member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
5,106
Location
supply and command
It never made sense to sell this summer and he's making a lot of people look silly. I'm happy for him and he seems to be a lot happier too. Hopefully he can keep this up.
 

Andersonson

Full Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2013
Messages
3,768
Location
Trondheim
Harry kane or look deep at Eastern European Baltic strikers and Italian ones. Theres diamonds there..... bigger issue is martial of course but 'rashy' could be gone and united can make good $$$ and buy a true united player. If Rushford was Nigerian or Polish,his price will be halfed and he would not be playing for united. We all know this.
Are you well ? Why sell our best attackers and be left with the guys behind him??
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,515
Harry kane or look deep at Eastern European Baltic strikers and Italian ones. Theres diamonds there..... bigger issue is martial of course but 'rashy' could be gone and united can make good $$$ and buy a true united player. If Rushford was Nigerian or Polish,his price will be halfed and he would not be playing for united. We all know this.
If he was Nigerian, polish or from any other east European country, you would be posting for awesome the player is and United should sign him.
 

colombianmancunian

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 26, 2022
Messages
724
Looking at what he is doing, and the player he is becoming under ETH, the answer is obvious.

Hope he gets a hat trick against UEFAlona
 

dabronxolivera

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 22, 2022
Messages
131
Supports
Al Hilal
Wanted him out before but credit where its due he changed my mind. Guy is a beast this season, not only that he also worked hard off the ball. Looks like he regained his speed and technique which probably can be attributed to proper coaching. Coady was terrorized by him all night. He probably could be even better if he had a proper coach since the beginning of his career
 

fergiewherearethou

Full Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2022
Messages
1,579
Location
Lake Chargoggagoggmanchauggagoggchaubuna
Supports
Erik ten Hag
You guys are so fickle. The guy have a few good weeks and 2 average years and its keep him now?? Sell him when you can still get a sucker, don't hold and regret. Think of him as a horrible stock that occasionally bursts up 3x 4x but will always crash down. He's at 4x now... if he remains 4x by summer ( miracle) sell him asap. The thing is by March his form would be gone again.... Rashford and martial are not title winners. The good news is united knows this and will get in some winners soon.

Rushford is good but over paid so should be gone
Martial is not good not even by Tottenham standards much less united
Good strategy.
We can then buy Sanchos and Anthonys for 100 mil each to get us to the title and the CL.
Or maybe we get Mbappe or Benzema for the Rashford money to get things going.
 

Remember the geese

Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2018
Messages
6,728
Location
Northampton
Harry kane or look deep at Eastern European Baltic strikers and Italian ones. Theres diamonds there..... bigger issue is martial of course but 'rashy' could be gone and united can make good $$$ and buy a true united player. If Rushford was Nigerian or Polish,his price will be halfed and he would not be playing for united. We all know this.
Strikers are all well and good, but Rashford plays on the left. Unless we bring in Mbappe or Vinicius, there won't be any guarantee of getting an upgrade on Rashford.
 

Zippycup

New Member
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
1,041
You guys are so fickle. The guy have a few good weeks and 2 average years and its keep him now?? Sell him when you can still get a sucker, don't hold and regret. Think of him as a horrible stock that occasionally bursts up 3x 4x but will always crash down. He's at 4x now... if he remains 4x by summer ( miracle) sell him asap. The thing is by March his form would be gone again.... Rashford and martial are not title winners. The good news is united knows this and will get in some winners soon.

Rushford is good but over paid so should be gone
Martial is not good not even by Tottenham standards much less united
Bloody hell
 

Remember the geese

Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2018
Messages
6,728
Location
Northampton
A 100M+ rated forward without PL experience from abroad

Usually works out...
Yeah, I don't really see where he's coming from. Last season was obviously a bad season from everyone, but in the two years prior, Rashford hit 20 goals in all comps. He's on course for doing that again this season. Unless we can sign Vinicius Jnr or Mbappe, then there's no guaranteed upgrade out there.
 

Resonance

Full Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2009
Messages
947
Location
Manchester
You guys are so fickle. The guy have a few good weeks and 2 average years and its keep him now?? Sell him when you can still get a sucker, don't hold and regret. Think of him as a horrible stock that occasionally bursts up 3x 4x but will always crash down. He's at 4x now... if he remains 4x by summer ( miracle) sell him asap. The thing is by March his form would be gone again.... Rashford and martial are not title winners. The good news is united knows this and will get in some winners soon.

Rushford is good but over paid so should be gone
Martial is not good not even by Tottenham standards much less united
That is an absolute car crash of a post, at least the parts about Rashford.

One of our brightest players, who came through the academy, who we all knew had the potential, is having arguably the greatest season of his career whilst pretty much single handedly winning us games and you want to sell him?
 

R'hllor

Full Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2013
Messages
15,414
Dunno who was among those 85% but this thread is a car crash from both sides, do people think those 85% just woke up one day and decided to vote like that on random? Guess they got caught in the moment at the time just like how people are now and this all calling out one side dumb what not, reminds of Matic thread when he got his extension. Lets hope it wont turn like that this time if Rashford gets a new contract.

For my sake, there are good reasons worth a gamble and give him a new deal but on what you all base, should or shouldnt X player get a new contract, is it current form, his body of work last couple of seasons, what? Also there is question of wages, how much increase he would get, is there a breaking point number when you step back and think even if you loud to give him now.
 

glazed

Eats diamonds to beat thermodynamics
Joined
Sep 30, 2012
Messages
7,526
Dunno who was among those 85% but this thread is a car crash from both sides
Not really. The 85%-ers look idiotic. The rest look sensible. Rashford under a quality manager looks world class.

The biggest concern is that he is too good and leaves anyway. He may become a PSG/Madrid/City level player that we can't hang on to. Our version of Deklan Rice at West Ham
 

noodlehair

"It's like..."
Joined
Apr 1, 2004
Messages
16,181
Location
Flagg
Usually these threads look bad because of hindsight but honestly this one was one of the fecking dumbest things I've ever seen on here from the moment it was started. He was just off the back of scoring 20 goals two seasons in a row despite not being our main striker or penalty taker. There's literally no one realistic you can sign to replace that.

Who on earth watches Man Utd, even last season when we had a Sunday league standard defence and no midfield, and comes to the conclusion that we must get rid of Marcus Rashford to solve our issues?

It genuinely annoys me every time I see this thread. 85% of people who are frankly, dangerously stupid.
 

Superden

Full Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2013
Messages
2,081
Usually these threads look bad because of hindsight but honestly this one was one of the fecking dumbest things I've ever seen on here from the moment it was started. He was just off the back of scoring 20 goals two seasons in a row despite not being our main striker or penalty taker. There's literally no one realistic you can sign to replace that.

Who on earth watches Man Utd, even last season when we had a Sunday league standard defence and no midfield, and comes to the conclusion that we must get rid of Marcus Rashford to solve our issues?

It genuinely annoys me every time I see this thread. 85% of people who are frankly, dangerously stupid.
this thread is like mausoleum for the knee jerk FM playing armchair experts. players are either world class or utter dog shite (if they arent scoring a goal a game).
 

roseguy64

Full Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2010
Messages
12,172
Location
Jamaica
Usually these threads look bad because of hindsight but honestly this one was one of the fecking dumbest things I've ever seen on here from the moment it was started. He was just off the back of scoring 20 goals two seasons in a row despite not being our main striker or penalty taker. There's literally no one realistic you can sign to replace that.

Who on earth watches Man Utd, even last season when we had a Sunday league standard defence and no midfield, and comes to the conclusion that we must get rid of Marcus Rashford to solve our issues?

It genuinely annoys me every time I see this thread. 85% of people who are frankly, dangerously stupid.
This
 

tom8888sa

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 8, 2022
Messages
75
Supports
neutral
That is an absolute car crash of a post, at least the parts about Rashford.

One of our brightest players, who came through the academy, who we all knew had the potential, is having arguably the greatest season of his career whilst pretty much single handedly winning us games and you want to sell him?
Hes not single hand winning games. United defense and mid field is where united is winning.
In fact offense is where united is weakest.
 

Swiss_Red89

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2019
Messages
1,474
To be totally honest, I cannot take the general consens of the cafe serious anymore since i saw the 85% the first time.

And I know and agree, Rashford was absolutely dogshit last season and his effort was a disgrace. But it was 100% obvious that last summer definitely was not the right time to sell a local boy with huge talent and potential which he already showed several times. So many of you guys were just ready to sell him asap as it meant nothing. A very likeable local boy, lifelong United Fan and english international who had nearly scored 100 goals already for the club at the age of 24. I had to avoid the Rashford Threads in spring/summer because I started to feel really sad reading them. Honestly, shame on you all. :lol:

I'm so glad and happy that Marcus shuts all the doubters up (once again) this year and the Streetford End sings his song in full force (again). Long may it continue.
 
Last edited:

M Bison

Full Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2015
Messages
6,795
Location
In the Wilderness
Supports
York City
To be totally honest, I cannot take the general consens of the cafe serious anymore since i saw the 85% the first time.

And I know and agree, Rashford was absolutely dogshit last season and his effort was a disgrace. But it was 100% obvious that last summer definitely was not the right time to sell a local boy with huge talent and potential which he already showed several times. So many of you guys were just ready to sell him asap as it meant nothing. A very likeable local boy, lifelong United Fan and english international who had nearly scored 100 goals already for the club at the age of 24. I had to avoid the Rashford Threads in spring/summer because I started to feel really sad reading them. Honestly, shame on you all. :lol:

I'm so glad and happy that Marcus shuts all the doubters up (once again) this year and the Streetford End sings his song in full force.(again). Long may it continue.
and to cap it off, there are posters who are actually trying to justify voting to sell him and can’t admit they got it wrong :lol:
 
Joined
May 4, 2021
Messages
439
Location
Tangier
Hes not single hand winning games. United defense and mid field is where united is winning.
In fact offense is where united is weakest.
Yeah attack is where we're weakest, and brainiac here proposes we sell our top scorer, the only player in our attack that is actually functioning. I mean wut? Why??
 

Swiss_Red89

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2019
Messages
1,474
and to cap it off, there are posters who are actually trying to justify voting to sell him and can’t admit they got it wrong :lol:
There are still some lads in this thread who think we should "cash in" and sell him.

Yeah would be so cool to see him play for PSG next season while we bought the Gakpo's and Antony's for 90mio and then label them a flop after 3 months. (as it's already starting to be the case in the Antony thread).

Absolutely mindboggling.
 

OlsensHummelBoots

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 25, 2021
Messages
72
Harry kane or look deep at Eastern European Baltic strikers and Italian ones. Theres diamonds there..... bigger issue is martial of course but 'rashy' could be gone and united can make good $$$ and buy a true united player. If Rushford was Nigerian or Polish,his price will be halfed and he would not be playing
:lol:

Don't forget to pick up the methadone prescription in the morning mate.

I'll stand down to your superior knowledge if you can point me in the direction of these Eastern European, Baltic or Italian strikers?
 

Threesus

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 13, 2020
Messages
728
I still think he should do the Lucas Vasquez role and be a quality sub option. We can still do better in his position, I feel.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.