Recent content by JeffFromHK

  1. Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager

    yes, all the 5 managers (interim Rangnick exluded) were either 2nd tier managers or 1st tier managers already on a decline We never managed to hire a real 1st tier manager
  2. Marcus Rashford | 2023/24 Performances

    Yay, the opinions of "football experts" on Skysports or inside United's management/coaching team (e.g. we shall play basketball-esque transition football) must matter more then. Tell me what Rashford offers apart from his occasional goals (once per 5 games on average) then? Why should we stick...
  3. Marcus Rashford | 2023/24 Performances

    His season rating on this forum is 4.3 - the lowest amongst all senior squad members. He offers nothing apart from occasional goals. Any fan who think he is not a problem is delusional
  4. Recruitment blooper No. 129...Mount v Palmer

    I think some of the United (and Liverpool as well) fans are indoctrinated with the belief that only those fans holding "don't criticise, just give support" attitudes are "true loyal Devils (or Reds)"
  5. Recruitment blooper No. 129...Mount v Palmer

    I remember the fans who questioned the signing in July last year were mocked by some fellow fans on RedCafe "arghhaha, you think you know football more than the professional football managers and hierarchy?"
  6. Who replaces Rashford?

    He is an attacking midfielder (who drifts to LW from time to time)
  7. Who replaces Ten Hag?

    I think Xavi worths a try. He apparently respects us a lot (from his previous interviews) and he is a possession based coach with experience of leading top sides. We won't win important trophies (UCL/PL) with him shortterm but it is good to hire him for 2-3 years for him to build our pattern of...
  8. Marcus Rashford | 2023/24 Performances

    an unreasonable opinion held by many then. tell me which aspect of football he is good at, apart from scoring occasionally goals (once per 5 games this season - which is pretty average)? Is he a good dribbler? or good passer? or is he good at carrying the ball forward or recycling the ball? is...
  9. Marcus Rashford | 2023/24 Performances

    Sorry to say it but it is a very poor take. "Judging people" is a weird thing and people can go very very wrong, hence many people do actually believe that Stalin/Mao Zedong are great men and many abused wives think their husbands are nice men
  10. Harry Maguire | 2023/24 Performances

    Was interesting to see him surging forward at the wing, shielded the ball and got a shot on target from tight angle. My instant thinking was - "wow, why is that our REAL left winger, Rashford, has never managed to do similar things for years?"
  11. Marcus Rashford | 2023/24 Performances

    me and my friends all came into consensus that "he was just faking injury to hide embarrassing performance" when we saw him walked off the pitch.
  12. If ten Hag was sacked tonight, who would you have as an interim?

    just for the FA Cup final. Mourinho would love to have one more FA Cup in his trophy cabinet and it will help him find another job
  13. Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager

    The rate at which we rejuvenate our squad is criminally slow. We still keep half of the players got trashed 0-4 Everton 5 years ago! And look at Arsenal's starting lineup 5 years ago, almost all of them have left the club
  14. Marcus Rashford | 2023/24 Performances

    I think we should just accept the highest bid on him, whichever the amount it, we receive on him this summer - be it 20M or even 10M as long as we can get rid of his toxicity it is good for the team
  15. If ten Hag was sacked tonight, who would you have as an interim?

    Ole/Mourinho as interim until the end of the season, with no extension however well we perform during the period.