Redcafe's All-Time Top 20. Left backs | Results

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
Post your list of 20 best left backs of all-time. I'll close the thread on the 19th of August (unless we decide to extend the vote).

Note: we've decided to separate right and left backs and to put versatile players only on the list of their preferred position. I'll provide a guide on the most known cases, if you doubt whenever the player you think of prefers left or right, please post the question in the discussion thread.



Note: all discussion goes to this thread
- http://www.redcafe.net/threads/redcafes-top-20-by-position.448431/

Note: you can post less than 20 names, but not more

The list should be posted in the required format:

  1. J. O'Shea
  2. P. Jones
...

20.

NB: After careful consideration, only players that had played at least a season after the 1950 WC are eligible.

The full list.
  1. P. Maldini - 1005
  2. G. Facchetti - 578
  3. N. Santos - 438
  4. R. Carlos - 409
  5. A. Brehme - 379
  6. R. Krol - 320
  7. A. Cabrini - 256
  8. A. Cole - 223
  9. B. Lizarazu - 220
  10. Junior - 170
  11. P. Breitner - 168
  12. Marcelo - 158
  13. S. Marzolini, K.-H. Schnellinger - 150
  14. --
  15. M. Bossis - 114
  16. D. Irwin - 110
  17. A. Demyanenko - 105
  18. J. A. Camacho - 97
  19. H.-P. Briegel - 82
  20. P. Evra - 64
  21. E. Abidal, A. Benarrivo - 22
  22. --
  23. J. Alba, R. Pavoni - 18
  24. --
  25. K. Sansom - 16
  26. M. Chagas - 14
  27. R. Gordillo, V. R. Andrade - 13
  28. --
  29. D. Alaba, T. Gemmel - 10
  30. --
  31. G. van Bronckhorst - 9
  32. A. Tarantini - 8
  33. Branko Zebec - 7
  34. J. Segarra - 6
  35. S. Pearce - 5
  36. Branco, A. Carboni - 4
  37. --
  38. R. Wilson, M. Lantos, R. Jarni - 2
  39. --
  40. --
  41. F. Luis, F. de Boer, G. Zambrotta, R. Marche, R. Byrne - 1
 
Last edited:

Moby

Dick
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
51,356
Location
Barcelona, Catalunya
  1. Paolo Maldini
  2. Giacinto Facchetti
  3. Nilton Santos
  4. Andreas Brehme
  5. Ruud Krol
  6. Roberto Carlos
  7. Antonio Cabrini
  8. Junior
  9. Bixente Lizarazu
  10. Ashley Cole
  11. Jose Antonio Camacho
  12. Sylvio Marzolini
  13. Hans Peter Briegel
  14. Dennis Irwin
  15. Eric Abidal
  16. Antonio Benarrivo
  17. Marcelo
  18. Karl Heinz Schnellinger
  19. Anatoliy Demyanenko
  20. Patrice Evra
 

BlackShark_80

Full Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
1,169
  1. Paolo Maldini
  2. Nilton Santos
  3. Giacinto Facchetti
  4. Karl-Heinz Schnellinger
  5. Roberto Carlos
  6. Andreas Brehme
  7. Antonio Cabrini
  8. Silvio Marzolini
  9. Leovegildo Junior
  10. Hans Peter Briegel
  11. Bixente Lizarazu
  12. Ashley Cole
  13. Jose Antonio Camacho
  14. Dennis Irwin
  15. Anatoliy Demyanenko
  16. Maxime Bossis
  17. Marcelo
  18. Antonio Benarrivo
  19. Ray Wilson
  20. Marinho Chagas
 
Last edited:

2mufc0

Everything is fair game in capitalism!
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
17,011
Supports
Dragon of Dojima
1. Maldini
2. Nilton
3. Facchetti
4. Brehme
5. Krol
6. Cabrini
7. Carlos
8. Marzolini
9. Lizarazu
10. Junior
11. Cole
12. Breitner
13. Evra
14. Briegel
15. Marcelo
16. Irwin
17. Bossis
18. Demyanenko
19. Schnellinger
20. Alba
 

Šjor Bepo

Wout is love, Wout is life; all hail Wout!
Joined
Mar 29, 2011
Messages
15,628
1. Maldini
2. Facchetti
3. Brehme
4. Krol
5. Cole
6. Nilton
7. Marcelo
8. Roberto Carlos
9. Cabrini
10. Evra
11. Lizarazu
12. Bossis
13. Irwin
14. Zebec
15. Marzolini
16. Demyanenko
17. Benarrivo
18. Alba
19. Junior
20. F. Luis
 
Last edited:

berbasloth4

Full Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2012
Messages
4,467
Location
ireland
  1. Maldini
  2. faccheti
  3. brehme
  4. nilton
  5. carlos
  6. irwin
  7. marzolini
  8. cole
  9. scherlinger
  10. cabrini
  11. lizarazu
  12. marcelo
  13. evra
  14. alba
  15. camacho
  16. pearce
  17. abidal
  18. gio van bronkhorst
  19. junior
  20. benavarrio
 
Last edited by a moderator:

oneniltothearsenal

Caf's Milton Friedman and Arse Aficionado
Scout
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Messages
11,114
Supports
Brazil, Arsenal,LA Aztecs
  1. Maldini
  2. Krol
  3. Nilton Santos
  4. Facchetti
  5. Kenny Sansom
  6. Roberto Carlos
  7. Cabrini
  8. Junior
  9. Breitner
  10. Marzolini
  11. Lizarazu
  12. Cole
  13. Camacho
  14. Demyanenko
  15. Schnellinger
  16. Marcelo
  17. Marinho Chagas
  18. Evra
  19. Bossis
  20. F. De Boer
 
Last edited:

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
  1. Maldini
  2. Facchetti
  3. Brehme
  4. Nilton Santos
  5. Roberto Carlos
  6. Krol
  7. Cabrini
  8. Breitner
  9. Irwin
  10. Cole
  11. Demyanenko
  12. Lizarazu
  13. Schnellinger
  14. Bossis
  15. Marcelo
  16. Junior
  17. Evra
  18. Briegel
  19. Marzolini
  20. Benarrivo
 

Physiocrat

Has No Mates
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
8,962
1. Maldini
2. Brehme
3. Krol
4. Facchetti
5. Nilton
6. Roberto Carlos
7. Cabrini
8. Irwin
9. Breitner
10. Briegel
11. Bossis
12. Camacho
13. Lizarazu
14. Cole
15. Demyanenko
16. Evra
17. Junior
18. Marzolini
19. Schnellinger
20. Abidal
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,324
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
  1. Paulo Maldini
  2. Giacinto Facchetti
  3. Roberto Carlos
  4. Nilton Santos
  5. Andreas Brehme
  6. Ruud Krol
  7. Ashley Cole
  8. Maxime Bossis
  9. Karl Heinz Schnellinger
  10. Anatoliy Demyanenko
  11. Bixente Lizarazu
  12. Hans Peter Briegel
  13. Jose Camacho
  14. Leo Junior
  15. Marcelo
  16. Antonio Cabrini
  17. Silvio Marzolini
  18. Rafael Gordillo
  19. Giovanni Van Bronckhorst
  20. Joan Segarra
 

Enigma_87

You know who
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
27,635
  1. Paolo Maldini
  2. Giacinto Facchetti
  3. Ruud Krol
  4. Andreas Brehme
  5. Nilton Santos
  6. Roberto Carlos
  7. Antonio Cabrini
  8. Ashley Cole
  9. Bixente Lizarazu
  10. Jose Antonio Camacho
  11. Paul Breitner
  12. Sylvio Marzolini
  13. Antonio Benarrivo
  14. Hans Peter Briegel
  15. Marcelo
  16. Dennis Irwin
  17. Leo Junior
  18. Eric Abidal
  19. Anatoliy Demyanenko
  20. Karl Heinz Schnellinger
 

Synco

Lucio's #1 Fan
Joined
Jul 19, 2014
Messages
6,446
  1. Maldini
  2. Facchetti
  3. N. Santos
  4. Krol
  5. Brehme
  6. R. Carlos
  7. Breitner
  8. Cabrini
  9. Schnellinger
  10. Lizarazu
  11. Marcelo
  12. Junior
  13. Marzolini
  14. Cole
  15. Bossis
  16. Abidal
  17. Irwin
 

Invictus

Poster of the Year 2015 & 2018
Staff
Joined
Mar 22, 2014
Messages
15,255
Supports
Piracy on the High Seas.
  1. Paolo Maldini
  2. Giacinto Facchetti
  3. Nílton Santos
  4. Andreas Brehme
  5. Roberto Carlos
  6. Leovegildo Júnior
  7. Ashley Cole
  8. Ricardo Pavoni
  9. Bixente Lizarazu
  10. Antonio Cabrini
  11. Marcelo da Silva Jr.
  12. José Antonio Camacho
  13. Silvio Marzolini
  14. Anatoliy Demyanenko
  15. Marinho Chagas
  16. Joan Segarra Iracheta
  17. Dennis Irwin
  18. Rafael Gordillo Vázquez
  19. Mihály Lantos
  20. Giovanni van Bronckhorst
 

BIG DUNK

Tank
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
977
Location
Europe
1 Paolo Maldini
2 Giacinto Facchetti
3 Nílton Santos
4 Ruud Krol
5 Andreas Brehme
6 Roberto Carlos
7 Antonio Cabrini
8 Leovegildo Júnior
9 Paul Breitner
10 Karl-Heinz Schnellinger
11 Ashley Cole
12 Marcelo
13 Bixente Lizarazu
14 Hans-Peter Briegel
15 Sergio Cervato
16 José Antonio Camacho
17 Maxime Bossis
18 Anatoliy Demyanenko
19 Silvio Marzolini
20 Roger Marche
 
Last edited:

Joga Bonito

The Art of Football
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
8,231
  1. Paolo Maldini
  2. Nilton Santos
  3. Giacinto Facchetti
  4. Andreas Brehme
  5. Ruud Krol
  6. Roberto Carlos
  7. Antonio Cabrini
  8. Paul Breitner
  9. Karl-Heinz Schnellinger
  10. Bixente Lizarazu
  11. Maxime Bossis
  12. Marcelo
  13. Leovegildo Júnior
  14. Silvio Marzolini
  15. Anatoliy Demyanenko
  16. Ashley Cole
  17. Dennis Irwin
  18. Patrice Evra
  19. H.P Briegel
  20. José Antonio Camacho
 

paulscholes18

Full Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
20,169
1 Roberto Carlos
2 Paolo Maldini
3 Nilton Santos
4 Giacinto Facchetti
5 Ruud Krol
6 Andreas Brehme
7 Marcelo
8 Ashley Cole
9 Patrice Evra
10 Dennis Irwin
11 Bixente Lizarazu
12 Paul Breitner
13 Leo Junior
14 Karl-Heinz Schnellinger
15 Antonio Cabrini
16 David Alaba
17 Jordi Alba
18 van Bronckhorst
19 Jose Camacho
20 Eric Abidal
 

Michaelf7777777

(∪。∪)。。。zzz
Joined
Aug 27, 2018
Messages
1,667
1. Paolo Maldini
2. Giacinto Facchetti
3. Nilton Santos
4. Ruud Krol
5. Andreas Brehme
6. Antonio Cabrini
7. Roberto Carlos
8. Victor Rodriguez Andrade
9. Anatoliy Demyanenko
10. Marcelo
11. Tommy Gemmell
12. Bixente Lizarazu
13. Ashley Cole
14. Rafael Gordillo
15. Silvio Marzolini
16. Ricardo Pavoni
17. Amedeo Carboni
18. David Alaba
19. Jordi Alba
20. Roger Byrne
 

freeurmind

weak willed
Joined
Mar 10, 2017
Messages
5,883
1. Roberto Carlos
2. Nilton Santos
3. Paulo Maldini
4. Andreas Brehme
5. Ruud Krol
6. Giacinto Facchetti
7. Bixente Lizarazu
8. Silvio Marzolini
9. Antonio Cabrini
10.Karl-Heinz Schnellinger
11. Ashley Cole
12. Paul Breitner
13. Alberto Tarantini
14. Dennis Irwin
15. Maxime Bossis
16. Patrice Evra
17. Jose Antonio Camacho
18. Marcelo
19. David Alaba
20. Jordi Alba
 

Indnyc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
4,537
  1. Paolo Maldini
  2. Giacinto Facchetti
  3. Andreas Brehme
  4. Ruud Krol
  5. Nílton Santos
  6. Roberto Carlos
  7. Bixente Lizarazu
  8. Marcelo
  9. Antonio Cabrini
  10. Ashley Cole
  11. Paul Breitner
  12. Maxime Bossis
  13. Silvio Marzolini
  14. Karl-Heinz Schnellinger
  15. Leo Júnior
  16. Dennis Irwin
  17. Patrice Evra
  18. Hans Peter Briegel
  19. José Antonio Camacho
  20. Anatoliy Demyanenko
 
Last edited:

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,685
Location
Inside right
1. Maldini
2. Roberto Carlos
3. Facchetti
4. Nilton Santos
5. Brehme
6. Ashley Cole
7. Breitner
8. Krol
9. Junior
10. Schnellinger
11. Bossis
12. Demyanenko
13. Lizarazu
14. Marcelo
15. Marzolini
16. Briegel
17. Cabrini
18. Camacho
19. Abidal
20. Chagas
 

GodShaveTheQueen

We mean it man, we love our queen!
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
6,434
1. Maldini
2. Facchetti
3. Krol
4. Brehme
5. Nilton
6. Cabrini
7. Carlos
8. Cole
9. Marcelo
10. Breitner
11. Junior
12. Bossis
13. Demyanenko
14. Schnellinger
15. Lizarazu
16. Camacho
17. Briegel
18. Irwin
19. Chagas
20. Branco
 
Last edited:

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
I'm closing this one. Tag me in the main thread if you wanted to contribute but wasn't able to do it in time.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
Finally compiled all the data. Will post the results soon.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
After a shit ton of wait, we're finally back.

41. Roger Byrne, Roger Marche, Gianluca Zambrotta, Frank de Boer, Filipe Luis (1 point)

All well-known names. Byrne — Busby Babes captain that died in Munich aged only 28. Marche had played more than 500 games in the French top division & earned 63 caps for France in the 50's. Zambrotta had appeared in the right back list but gets in here due to his versatility. Frank de Boer had made his name as a hybrid left-center back in the Ajax's 1990's vintage side; it was his cross that found Bergkamp at the edge of the Argentina's penalty box. Filipe Luis had been a part of arguably the best defensive unit of the decade, although his unsuccessful stint at Chelsea and relatively underwhelming international career stopped him from becoming a true great.

38. Robert Jarni, Mihály Lantos, Ray Wilson (2 points)

Robert Jarni had a decent club career, although he failed to become a started for both Juventus and Real Madrid. But he shined with his country, Croatia, for which he gained 81 caps (add this to his 7 caps for Yugoslavia), taking part in 3 World Cups and breaking his country's appearance record. Mihály Lantos was an overlooked part of the Mighty Magyars, cementing the team's foundation to unleash Puskas, Kocsis & co. Ray Wilson had won the World Cup with England in 1966 — a tournament, where Alf Ramsey introduced his Wingless Wonders, a team with no natural wingers that relied a lot on their fullbacks to participate in attack.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
36. Branco, Amedeo Carboni (4 points)

Branco was a Roberto Carlos before Roberto Carlos — World-Cup winning Brazilian wingback with a thunderous shot and great attacking skills. He spent 7 years of his career playing in Europe, although not for the traditional "top dogs" of Europe (Porto won a European Cup a year before his arrival though). Amedeo Carboni would be forever mixed up with Antonio Cabrini by less attentive fans, but he had a great career of his own. Although unsuccessful at the international stage with a certain Paolo Maldini occupying the left back spot, Carboni managed to became a legend at both Roma and Valencia (the latter was one of the finest teams of the early 00's, winning 2 La Liga titles and reaching 2 CL finals).

35. Stuart Pearce (5 points)

A player who motivated himself by playing the punk rock of The Stranglers and was known as 'Psycho'. "I knew that if I didn't tackle hard they would drop me." There was not a lot else to his game. He combined a high standard of defending with outstanding pace and seeming invulnerability going forward, qualities that have kept him in the England side since he took over from Kenny Sansom after the disappointing 1988 European Championship in West Germany.

34. Joan Segarra (6 points)

Known as the Great Captain, Segarra was one of the most charismatic players in the history of FC Barcelona. The legendary defender was part of the Barça of the Five Cups in the 1950s and is one of the players who has made most appearances for the Club. Segarra was a true gentleman on the pitch, and his noble and very proper attitude won him the admiration of respect of the entire footballing world. He was a versatile player, although his natural positions were at half back or left back. He was brave and dedicated and would never stop yelling encouragement to his team mates. He had the perfect physical shape, tremendous skills, and was a solid marker. Although he played at the back, he also had a fine shot and scored several decisive goals.

33. Branko Zebec (7 points)

A highly versatile player noted for his physical abilities and understanding of the game, Zebec was world class whether on the left wing or in the more defensive role of left fullback, although he was capable of playing almost every outfield position on the pitch. He was particularly well known for his pace, having been able to run 100 meters in 11 seconds with football boots. Until this day he is seen as one of the greatest ever Yugoslavian players.

32. Alberto Tarantini (8 points)

Alberto Tarantini's golden moment came in 1978, when he had won the World Cup with Argentina and got elected into the Team of the Tournament. Funnily enough, he wasn't representing any club at the time — a contractual dispute with Boca left him clubless, and Boca management pressured all Argentine clubs into denying him a new contract. After a brief spell in England he had returned to Argentina, eventually signing for River Plate, Boca's fiercest rivals.

31. @Gio van Bronckhorst (9 points)

Giovanni van Bronckhorst has had an exceptional career — he had played in 6 major tournaments with Netherlands, won the league in 3 different countries and won the CL with Barca by beating his previous club. And then there was that goal:

 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
29. David Alaba, Tommy Gemmell (10 points)

David Alaba looked like the greatest thing since sliced bread when he broke into the Bayern's first team. Aged only 17, he became the youngest ever debutant for the German powerhouse in the league and, later, in the CL, starting against Fiorentina in 2010. After a 6-month loan at Hoffenfeim he came back and earned a starting place at Bayern, for a team that would reach the CL final in 2012 (he missed it due trough a suspension), and that was when he was named the Austrian Footballer of the Year for the first time (he has 6 of them at the moment). Originally a central midfielder, he was mostly used as a left back, both in a more traditional interpretation of the role (he formed a fantastic understanding with Ribery on that left wing) and as a Guardiola's trademark false fullback. With 8 Bundesliga titles at 27, he'll probably end up as one of the most decorated footballers of all-time, but at the time it doesn't look like he's going to be considered an all-time great, despite his initial appearance.

Tommy Gemmell was one of the Lisbon Lions, immortalised by scoring the equalising goal in the ultimate final as Celtic lifted the European Cup in 1967. He also scored in the 1970 European Cup Final in a defeat to Feyenoord, making him one of only two British footballers to score in two different European Cup Finals*, the other being Phil Neal of Liverpool. Funnily enough, both were defenders. Gemmell also joins an elite club of right-footed left backs that includes Maldini, Facchetti and Nilton Santos; he was equally comfortable on either flank though.

Herald journalist Hugh McDonald said:
The Gemmell all-action reel would feature prominently a kick up the bahookie of Helmut Haller and a goal in the European Cup that came from a shot so thunderous it should have been followed by a shower of rain.
*Bale also joins this elite group, although he did it in a differently named competition.

27. Rafael Gordillo, Víctor Rodríguez Andrade (13 points)

A bit of info on Víctor, you can go & see the whole post if you're interested:
Víctor was José Leandro Andrade's nephew. He idolised his uncle so much he insisted on being referred to using both his parents' surnames, otherwise he would have just been one of a million Rodríguez's. He played as a right halfback just like him, although he was stronger in defensive phases while somewhat less adventurous going forward. His tactical discipline and submission to what the team needed was further demonstrated at the 1950 World Cup when, in the absence of good quality leftbacks and with a fair few good rightbacks around, it was Rodríguez Andrade who was deployed on the left with Juan Carlos González on the right and then Gambetta when he got injured against Spain. With Zizinho starting the final on Gambetta's side and Zizinho-to-Ademir being a proven devastatingly effective route to goal, things looked ominous. So Uruguay surprised Brazil on the day by starting Rodríguez Andrade on the right and Gambetta on the left. Within five minutes though, the entire issue was sorted. The first or second time Zizinho gets the ball Víctor puts in one of those skeleton-busting tackles which are honest but dare you to try what dishonesty could be like. Zizinho didn't want to, and was largely anonymous for most of the game.
Rafael Gordillo was a tremendously attacking left-wingback for Real Madrid and Spain — he had won 5 La Liga titles and reaches the Euros final in 1984 (he represented his nation in five international tournaments!). His quality, commitment and charisma on and off the pitch meant that he was admired by everybody, and his characteristically laid-back look, with his socks rolled down and his peculiar style of running, made him a much loved character among the fans. He overlapped with Camacho during his time in Madrid and they formed a devastating interchangeable duo on the left wing.

26. Marinho Chagas (14 points)

Marinho Chagas was a skilful and innovative right footed left back who was considered at the time one of the top players at his position. He was an attack minded full-back with a powerful shot, and is considered a pioneer, becoming very influential in helping the lateral position evolve into what it is in today's Brazilian football. He is best known for his flowing curly blond hair and his performance at the 1974 FIFA World Cup, in which Brazil finished fourth. That year was the highest point of his career — he got into the World Cup Team of the Tournament and finished 2nd in the South American Footballer of the Year award. At club level he is mostly associated with Botafogo FR of Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo FC, but he played for numerous other teams, as well as in the North American Soccer League, in a career which spanned from 1969 to 1987.

25. Kenny Sansom (16 points)

Kenny Sansom is one of the finest full-backs England has ever produced. And at Arsenal, he is held in similarly high regard. Sansom was an accurate passer and devastatingly quick over short distances. But with that pace came great adventure that, in his early years, was occasionally misjudged. Sansom's forays forward set the tone for the modern full-back and, as his tactical nous grew, the Arsenal man became the complete defender. Despite his relatively small stature, Sansom was strong in the air, and he was never one to dive in when the ball was on the deck. The Highbury crowd tagged him 'Kenny White-Shorts' as a result but it was a term of endearment for a man who won their hearts with his timely interceptions. Sansom earned international acclaim - his 86 England caps remains a record for a full-back - plus praise from his peers. For eight consecutive seasons he was named in the PFA Team of the Year at left-back, a record that no-one has come close to emulating.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
23. Jordi Alba, Ricardo Pavoni (18 points)



I had to show those 2 side by side. You all know Alba, of course. Pavoni, on the other hand, is a South American legend who had never played in Europe, but won an incredible 5 Copa Libertadores in Argentina.

Ricardo Pavoni began his football career with the Montevidean club Defensor. Disillusioned with life as a footballer, he was on the point of abandoning the game completely and going to work in a casino as a croupier until he was convinced to play football for Independiente of Argentina. The left-sided full-back has been described as a natural leader and the perfect man-marker. He was also responsible for scoring 57 goals. For twelve seasons (1965–1976) he was idolised by the Independiente fans. He was particularly remembered for his powering runs along the left wing, putting away free kicks with his left foot and for his frequent last-ditch efforts to clear the ball from the goal-line. He is considered by many to be the archetypal Uruguayan footballer. Pavoni (affectionately known as "el Chivo" — "a goat" if google doesn't lie to me) won many honours during his career, including the Argentine first division championships three times, the Copa Libertadores five times, the Copa Interamericana on three occasions and one Copa Intercontinental. He was also a member of the Uruguayan squad that took part in the World Cup of 1974, in West Germany. Since retirement, he has been involved with the club as a trainer with reserve and youth teams. He has also been caretaker manager of the first team on several occasions.

21. Eric Abidal, Antonio Benarrivo (22 points)

Antonio Benarrivo came to prominence during his time with Parma, joining the club in 1991; he won several domestic and European titles with the team and eventually became the club's record appearance holder in Serie A and in European competitions. Although he was usually deployed on the right, Benarrivo was comfortable playing on both flanks. An energetic offensive full-back, he was known for his attacking prowess, despite rarely scoring, and was sometimes employed as a wing-back, or as a makeshift wide midfielder, due to his pace, stamina, offensive capabilities, technique, crossing accuracy and ability to cover the flank both offensively and defensively; these attributes led him to be considered one of the best players in his position during the 1990s. For Italy, he had Paolo Maldini as a competition, so, understandably, he hadn't featured much in international tournaments. He had the 1994 World Cup to remember — starting as a right back he helped his country to reach the final (which they had lost on penalties).

Eric Abidal was an important member of Guardiola's Barca. At the time Pep used a loop-sided formation with Dani Alves playing an uber-attacking role and Abidal, on the other flank, dropping back to form a back 3 line with Puyol & Pique. He was equally comfortable centrally and on the left and was more than competent in his use of the ball, so there was probably no one better for that role at the time. In 2011 Barcelona announced that he had a tumour in his liver, and later he would undergo a series of surgeries. Incredibly, he continued his career 2 years later, although he never reached his previous level. At the time he is serving as the director of football at Barca.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
20. Patrice Evra (64 points)

The man, the myth, the legend. Easily one of the most likeable characters to play for United, talented, hilarious and genuinely a little insane. Personally I think that at some point he overcame Cole as the best left back in the league (and probably in the world), even though he wasn't on top for as long as Cashley did. And it's not like the rest of his career was bad, he reached CL finals with Monaco and Juventus (weird bit of trivia - he had won only 1 out of 5 of those).

 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
19. Hans-Peter Briegel (82 points)



Briegel reminds me of a T-1000 from the second Terminator movie. A frightening machine that you can't neither outrun or outmuscle, with a huge leap and a decent technique to boot. He wasn't perfect, as he struggled a bit against nimble dribblers with a low center of gravity and sometimes got caught out of possession, but he was very intimidating. He also regularly played as a center back & both defensive and midfielder; he played in midfield when he had won a Serie A title with Hellas Verona in 1985. Somehow, with 9 goals, he managed to outscore his teammate Elkjær and fellow countryman Rummenigge. It's a shame that his illustrious international career got spoiled by 2 lost World Cup finals, especially since he was not very convincing in either of them.
 

Pat_Mustard

I'm so gorgeous they want to put me under arrest!
Joined
Jan 17, 2008
Messages
13,802
Location
A never-nude? I thought he just liked cut-offs.
Brilliant work as ever @harms ! I'm probably going to repeat this in the match compilations thread in about 20 minutes time when I watch your Di Stefano video :).

I think we've discussed our shared annoyance at Cole being a Maldini-lite in drafts and Evra being a slight upgrade on Buttner but again I agree. Very little between their peaks and Evra was better at one stage. Also, great touch with the Pavoni and Alaba photos :lol:
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
18. José Antonio Camacho (97 points)



José Antonio Camacho was one of the best defenders who has played at the Bernabéu and defined an era for Real Madrid and Spain through his top class defending and, above all, his commitment and will to win. He was the team’s ‘Great Captain’. He spent 15 professional years at Real Madrid, appearing in more than 500 official matches with the team and helping win 19 major titles, including nine La Liga championships. Not even the serious knee injury that he suffered in 1978 and that kept him out of the game for nearly two years could stop him from winning more than ten trophies.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
17. Anatoliy Demyanenko (105 points)



When The Ukrainsky Futbol weekly had a poll to choose the best Ukranian player of all-time, Anatoliy Demyanenko came third — behind Oleg Blokhin and Andriy Shevchenko, unarguably the best outfield players in the Soviet and the Post-Soviet Ukraine's history respectively. Despite the usual bias towards attacking players in such ratings, Demyanenko, a tireless full/wingback, managed to overcome the likes of Igor Belanov (1986 Ballon d'Or winner) and Aleksandr Zavarov, a player that Juventus had chosen to replace ageing Michel Platini. He does have a surprising amount of personal honours for a defender — Soviet Footballer of the Year in 1985; Ukrainian footballer of the Year in 1982 and 1985; best player in the 1980's UEFA European Under-21 Championship, which USSR won.

He was the epitome of Lobanovsky's player — physically impeccable, tactically astute and capable of patrolling the entire flank from defence to offence. His usual role was that of a rampaging fullback, but he was equally at ease as a left winger or even as a centerback — the versatility of Lobanovsky's football earned him a comparison to Rinus Michel's totaalvoetbal.

Valeriy Lobanovskiy said:
Demyanenko impressed everyone with his attitude in training. To maximise his impressive athleticism we needed to give him as much space as possible, so we’ve put him at left back, where he began to play with freedom that was unseen before in Soviet football. He was an instant upgrade on Matvienko, who played there before him — he matched him defensively but, at the same time, he significantly improved our attack. He covered a 60-70 meters long zone on the left and after the game he looked like this hellish work actually makes him happy
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
16. Denis Irwin (110 points)



Fergie said:
Honestly, I would say Denis Irwin would be the one certainty to get in the team. I called him an ‘eight out of 10’. At Highbury in one game, he had a bad pass back in the last minute and Bergkamp came in and scored. After the game the press said: ‘You must be disappointed in that pass back.’ I said: ‘Well, one mistake in 10 years isn’t bad. He was an unbelievable player.
Alan Hansen said:
In any team of the decade, the full-back slots are already nailed down – Denis Irwin at right-back and Denis Irwin at left-back. Could play on either side as full-back and Manchester United man was one of the most consistent and reliable defenders I have witnessed.
Jack Charlton said:
Denis was the consummate professional: the best full-back to play for Manchester United, the best full-back to play for the Republic of Ireland, he was always our most consistent player, he never made mistakes, he never gave the ball away, he was always on time for training, always first on the bus for training, he never let you down or ever caused a problem. What a boring f**king bastard!

Fun fact: Dennis Bergkamp was actually named after Denis Irwin, although his parents added an extra 'n' to distance it from the common Dutch girl's name, Denise. This might not be factually true.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
@harms Great quote from Lobanovskiy there.
His book is really a delight for any football fan, he writes about everything with such clearance and honesty (well, maybe aside from the coups). Not sure if it's ever been translated to English though — the title is "The endless game/match ...".
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
15. Maxime Bossis (114 points)



When asked about his childhood idols, Marcel Desailly named Diego Maradona, Bernd Schuster and Maxime Bossis, The Giraffe — a player he looked up to the most while coming up through the ranks at Nantes. He was an outstanding defender — equally at ease in every defensive role, intelligent, fast and unexpectedly elegant with the ball. Alongside Manuel Amoros he was a mainstay in the French side of the 80's, providing a solid foundation for the beautiful attacking football by Platini & co. Despite the usual negative bias towards defenders in terms of the individual recognition, he was named French Player of the Year twice, in 1979 and 1981. Like many French players of the era he never played abroad, spending his whole career at his beloved Nantes with a short spell at the Racing Paris in the middle, yet he was widely recognised as one of the best defenders in the world at the time.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
13. Karl-Heinz Schnellinger, Silvio Marzolini (150 points)



It's quite fitting that those two ended up together — both were considered to be among the best defenders of the 60's and second only to Facchetti at left back.

Karl-Heinz Schnellinger had a long and illustrious career — after winning the league title with Köln in 1962 (that year he was chosen as a Footballer of the Year in Germany and also ended up 3rd in the annual Ballon d'Or vote) he moved to Italy, where he played for Mantova, Roma and AC Milan. He played nine seasons with the Rossoneri, obtaining several successes both at the national and European level. That stint earned him a place in the AC Milan Hall of Fame. For Germany he appeared in 4 World Cups, scoring only one goal — in the "Game of the Century", the legendary 1970 semi-final against Italy. An athletic and hard-tackling player, with a strong physique, he was nicknamed the "Volkswagen" for his continuity of performance, both in quantity and in quality, and for his versatility; indeed, although he was usually deployed as a full-back, he was capable of playing anywhere along the back, and could also play as a centre-back, as a sweeper, or even as a defensive midfielder.

Silvio Marzolini had spent 12 seasons at Boca Juniors, winning 5 league titles, and performed fantastically well for Argentina despite the relatively low amount of caps. His 28 appearances for his country included 2 World Cup campaigns, in 1962 and in 1966, and in the latter one he was elected as the best left back of that tournament.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
12. Marcelo (158 points)


Marcelo joined Real Madrid in 2007 with what seemed to be an unrealistic goal of filling Roberto Carlos' shoes. A young Brazilian failed to establish himself as a starting left back at first due to his questionable defensive skills, and multiple managers played him as a left winger — his crossing, dribbling and overall creativity was never in question. In 2009/10 he was tied with Guti as Madrid's best provider — both assisted 9 goals. At the end of the season Marcelo admitted, that he feels more at home playing as a winger than as a fullback.

Surprisingly, it was Jose Mourinho who put an offensive-minded Brazilian back to defence. Even the signing of Jose's compatriot Fabio Coentrao didn't stop him — at first the Portuguese's defensive prowess was preferred in the big games, but very soon Marcelo became an undisputed starter. After that things only got better for him. Marcelo formed a devastating partnership with Ronaldo on the left, his support gave Cristiano more freedom to roam around and get into goalscoring positions, while Marcelo himself established himself as a big-game player and a goalscorer. Roberto Carlos even admitted that his successor possesses a better technical ability than him.

Brazil's lack of recent success and especially the grandiose failure of 2014 probably stopped Marcelo from reaching the very top of our list. You can argue that his offensive contribution and club achievements are at least on par with those of Roberto Carlos, Brehme and Facchetti, but it's hard to see past his international record. He somehow got into the World Cup Team of the Tournament... twice, thanks to the new format when the result was given in the hands of random fans on the internet.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,000
Location
Moscow
11. Paul Breitner (168 points)



Probably the most unique fullback of all-time that got a little less votes here than he should've been because he also had an all-time midfield incarnation. But Breitner of the early 70's was such a unique sight — basically a libero from a left back position that roamed all around the pitch wreaking havoc to the opposition with his playmaking, dribbling and, of course, long distance shooting.

It was Breitner who took the ball and scored a screamer after witnessing how Elias Figueroa completely marked Gerd Müller out of the game. It was Breitner who took the ball and scored an equaliser from a spot in the World Cup final where West Germany faced the most feared team in the world.

Yeah, that's exactly where your left back should play in the attacking phase: