If that was the other way round then no way do I defend the Utd player in a million years.
Get rid of VAR NOW! We want our game back! (...or not, some are happy)
- Thread starter RedFish
- Start date
It's not like the ref didnt see Mason going down but in fairness he may not have seen the challenge in real time which is where VAR needs to step in.
If Greenwood had been stretchered off, he'd have watched it on the monitor and sent him off, I've zero doubt about that.
The point of making it a red is to deter those tackles, not when it is a broken leg.
I sense that all fans across all clubs are growing increasingly frustrated about the lack of consistency in this VAR madness
The FA needs to have weekly reviews of all controversial VAR decisions and clarify why the decisions were made. The NFL is brilliant at this and there's rarelt any doubt of why a decision was made
In the PL the line seeks to vary from week to week or even game to game. No consistency, no clear line and no damn logic is present in any way at all.
The FA needs to have weekly reviews of all controversial VAR decisions and clarify why the decisions were made. The NFL is brilliant at this and there's rarelt any doubt of why a decision was made
In the PL the line seeks to vary from week to week or even game to game. No consistency, no clear line and no damn logic is present in any way at all.
VAR is a fecking joke, I can't believe they didn't think that wasn't a sending off, Romeu almost broke Greenwood's ankle.
Easy way to fix VAR is simply use it correctly. They review and advise ref if there is something to look at. On field ref makes the call simples.
All this nonsense of not wanting to overturn refs decision is a joke.
Its just making the whole of English football look inept
All this nonsense of not wanting to overturn refs decision is a joke.
Its just making the whole of English football look inept
The clear and obvious error bit hasn't exactly worked well in England.
It's a combination of issues, the refs are a bit shit and going against another ref is a bit like wanking in front of your nan, you¨ll do it but only if it's an emergency.
Mike Riley has made a mess of things, especially the pitchside monitors. They'll happily spend 5-6mins drawing up lines to see if the tip of a players knob is an inch offside or not, but allowing the ref 2 mins to jog to a monitor on the side to review a situation is considered too time consuming and ruins the flow of the game.
Yeah they should have told him to go and have a look at the screen but didn't think it was worthy for some daft reason
Please clarify the emergency which would necessitate you wanking off in front your nan?
I'm fairly sure I'm wrong on this but there is the faintest idea of a slip or double movement on the Romeu red.
It's a very good example of how VAR ref doesn't want to overrule Ref #1.
To which the obvious answer is the pitch side monitor but that has problems for authority and player behaviour I think they would say.
I'd focus that by asking what is VAR saying when he sends Ref#1 to the screen. They're obvs very keen to avoid this anyway.
Except when they said they would but still carried on not doing wasn't it?
It's a very good example of how VAR ref doesn't want to overrule Ref #1.
To which the obvious answer is the pitch side monitor but that has problems for authority and player behaviour I think they would say.
I'd focus that by asking what is VAR saying when he sends Ref#1 to the screen. They're obvs very keen to avoid this anyway.
Except when they said they would but still carried on not doing wasn't it?
Didn't want to start a new thread but is Walker-Peters handball not a red card offence? Surely it was an intentional handball to stop a goal scoring opportunity. I thought that was a part of the rules, like the last man tackle?
Blatant penalty in the city game missed inevitably
How that pen on Jesus wasn't given is insane.
That was an incredible decision there for the foul on Jesus.
It even looked nailed-on in real time, never mind in any of the five angles they showed afterwards.
Shambles.
It even looked nailed-on in real time, never mind in any of the five angles they showed afterwards.
Shambles.
The handball by Silva?
Why wasn’t there any discussion of Alexander-Arnold’s horror tackle last night in any post-match analysis? It was a clear red card and even in real time, it looked quite bad.
What are these clowns in Stockley Park watching?!
What are these clowns in Stockley Park watching?!
That's a palace penalty for me. Don't know if the VAR bottled it as it would have cancelled out our goal or if he just doesn't know what he's doing.
We're so lucky with VAR.
We're so lucky with VAR.
Yawn. Watch all the outrage now. Whilst Romelu was merely mentioned.
Didn't the ball only go out of play when Rashford scored after the penalty appeal?
Looked like a penalty to me yeah. Hard to justify VAR (seemingly) not even having a look. We've definitely not been unlucky with VAR in general. The only good thing I can say about it.
I think that scenario has happened before. If it is a penalty they chalk off the goal scored and bring it back for the pen.
Yeah, should have been a penalty in my view. Can’t understand why it wasn’t given.
Mane’s kick out at Holding as well.Why wasn’t there any discussion of Alexander-Arnold’s horror tackle last night in any post-match analysis? It was a clear red card and even in real time, it looked quite bad.
What are these clowns in Stockley Park watching?!
I don't think you can tell what's happening. You're just assuming there's a trip somewhere - presumably just before he falls over.
What actually happens - not a clue.
Also the 2nd angle looks totally different.
What actually happens - not a clue.
Also the 2nd angle looks totally different.
It's getting boring now, every week they miss blatant fouls. Incompetence or corruption, i don't think i even care anymore. They should all be fired on the spot but we all know it's not happening. The league is going to be about how much a gap can you create before the referees feck you over.
Greatest thing ever created by human.
Sadly for Ayew his foot his slightly bigger than wan Bissakas
Do we love it again?
Love VAR...
No doubt that Ole’s United has benefited most from Var. Probably have given him 20 pts this season
That's harsh for Palace. Millimeters probably.
Anyways, the rules are the rules and they are the same for everyone.
Anyways, the rules are the rules and they are the same for everyone.
bit shit though that
Haha, we're so freakishly lucky. Conspiracy theories bound to begin. VAR is so silly.
Was at least clear on VAR, even if tight. I fecking hate the ones where you can barely tell.
Right, no doubt. Because you saw all the decisions given for all the teams this year...
I'd be annoyed if that went against us.
it's good for us but it's shit that the only use of VAR is to be a complete killjoy, taking away goals for such pedantic reasons.Really unlucky for Palace. That would be a goal any other year.
If he's offside, he's offside. Dem da rulez