In Rainbows
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 17, 2014
- Messages
- 6,753
In related news, they just had the best badminton woman playing against the former 120th ranked man (who doesn't really compete at these events much anymore), was given a 8 pt handicap per game, and still lost. She trains with men too.That we have a problem in society with generalising groups far too much and easily (which I am also guilty for). Not all women will be able to, just like not all men will be able too (Hello 0.01%) but that does not mean that the option or availablity shouldn't be there if there was or is a female capable of competing at a decent level. There may well be a bunch of women that are able to compete at a decent level but at the moment there are a lot of rules that stop that possibility.
It is possible for womens football to grow while having the option for women to compete if they wish and are capable.
Nobody really knows what level that is because the only evidence we have so far is female vs male games or examples of girls playing in mixed teams at youth level. There is obviously a very different training schedule and environment for a woman who plays in a mixed team throughout her whole career compared to a woman who plays mixed until the age of 12 and then changes to an all womens team.
You're underestimating the physical difference.
In the case of this club, there is a big difference from going to the u18s to the first team level even if you're a man. The physical difference will only get larger at first team level. It's hard enough for youngsters to make the step up even if they are talented within the setup relative to the club's level.
In football, it's not just strength that someone like Silva has an advantage. It's easier for him to compete with stamina. Easier to be more precise (requires physical action) at the top level which matters when faster people are rushing you to get the ball. It's not as simple as you're making it out like it's just skill that can make the difference. That's only when the playing field is level (men vs men). Context matters.
Even Gomes, for as small as he is, relies on his phsyical ability to give himself just enough space to do what he wants whether that be dribbling at a speed, being able to ride tackles, being able to fake a certain direction, putting himself in position to receive a pass at a certain time, etc... All the little things that you're taking for granted.