The MMA thread

sullydnl

Ross Kemp's caf ID
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
34,063
Hes not taking into consideration how tribal the region is, and a snub from Khabib could be perceived as a slight to his close friend Zubaira Tukhugov, or any other chechen. These people are very sensitive to these things, and the guy who's writing the article, whilst making decent points, should thrust himself into that region and really understand how they operate. There is a lot of Chechen and Dagestani refugees that relocated to the part of the country that I'm originally from and honestly, I didn't even feel comfortable talking to them and still dont because I feel like anything I say could potentially set them off. They tend to overreact in the extreme so when he says Kadyrov wouldn't kill Russias top athlete, I wouldn't be so sure.
Tbf the author has written extensively on Khabib, Kadyrov and Dagestan in the past (more so than any other journalist I'm aware of), so I'm sure he's at least somewhat aware of the context.

You can see a list of his articles covering Kadyrov here.
 

Paxi

Dagestani MMA Boiled Egg Expert
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
27,678
Tbf the author has written extensively on Khabib, Kadyrov and Dagestan in the past (more so than any other journalist I'm aware of), so I'm sure he's at least somewhat aware of the context.

You can see a list of his articles covering Kadyrov here.
So why does he then not take into consideration the potential repercussions Khabib could face by snubbing Kadyrov. It could cause tension between Chechens and Avars too.
 

Paxi

Dagestani MMA Boiled Egg Expert
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
27,678
This is Khabib’s issue not that of people in the normal western world where Khabib earns his living and where homophobia is widely rejected. He had the option of fighting in Russian or Chechen MMA leagues but instead opted for the UFC, which was the right decision, but was never guaranteed to be absent of criticism for his political affiliations with dictators.
Fair point.
 

Paxi

Dagestani MMA Boiled Egg Expert
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
27,678
There is some truth to this. One my my closest friends is from that part of the world and says whilst he doesn't share the political beliefs or views of those leaders, he also said if they came to his house, he would let them in with open arms due to fear of safety if he refuses.


He won't come back for McGregor. If he wanted that, he could have had that by now. He seems intent of legacy and I think a GSP fight could draw him back in. It wouldn't have a messy build up, a true hero in the sport is GSP and it would be something that Khabib may feel will enhance his legacy.
I think most in Russia, regardless of their political beliefs would let someone very very powerful into their homes out of fear. Being rich and famous doesn't change that.

I just don't see it with GSP. I mean how old is GSP? What would Khabib gain by beating past it, retired fighter?
 

Paxi

Dagestani MMA Boiled Egg Expert
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
27,678
@sullydnl I looked through that journalists articles and one thing is clear to me, is how powerful Kadyrov is, how much he uses sport to sportsmanship his image. Nothing i didn't know but Khabib snubbing him would be a major issue for Kadyrov. I don't blame Khabib not wanting to look over his shoulder for an absolute psycho for a president.

Regarding homophobia, if Khabib has nothing good to say than he should keep his mouth closed at the very least. Though, like I said, he is a byproduct of social conditioning to hate gays. I don't mean name calling. I mean execution. So do you blame the society that he grew up in or the individual. Again, I'm not condoning homophobia or Khabib but he's been brought up in hate. I'm lucky I moved from Russia when I was 10 and I'm very tolerant and Liberal id say but if I haven't, the chances are I'd be the same.
 

Dirty Schwein

Has a 'Best of Britney Spears' album
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
31,678
Location
Miracle World
Supports
Luton Town
I think most in Russia, regardless of their political beliefs would let someone very very powerful into their homes out of fear. Being rich and famous doesn't change that.

I just don't see it with GSP. I mean how old is GSP? What would Khabib gain by beating past it, retired fighter?
I agree with you which is why I said Khabib may think this as he's mentioned GSP many times.
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
The problem being he's the one in the spotlight and the one who is being discussed with a legacy. I don't think random Dagestani or Russian blokes are on the same level as Khabib in terms of fame. Rightfully he will be criticised and scrutinised cos of who he is. There is counter arguments that is the culture over there but that doesn't mean he has to share them views. The confusion of this thread with Khabib fans is you literally can't criticise the guy without being accused of hating him or like I said previously people imply you're racist cos you don't agree with his views.





Re not Putin's buddy, I mean Khabib's biggest fan in these 2 posts implies they're pretty close to each other? People need to make their mind up on that one.

I just honestly don't get how people can't criticise his views without it coming back on them. We've not heard from since Saturday how much of an honourable man he is cos he promised his mum something (which he is now going back on) surely we can discuss the other side of the argument?
What’s coming back on me? I don’t care a jot what you think or say in the matter so all this is a waste of time on your part :lol:
 
Last edited:

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
What’s coming back on me? I don’t care a jot what you think or say in the matter so all this is a waste of time on your part :lol:
What? Nothing is coming back on you, I meant Khabib, unless you share the same mum which would explain your odd love for him.

It wasn't really a waste of time, took about 15 seconds.

Judging by your short reply and lack of replying to anyone who made valid points re Khabib's views you've not really got a valid response to any of it and will just pretend none of it exists or dismiss it all as his cultural views again.
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
What? Nothing is coming back on you, I meant Khabib, unless you share the same mum which would explain your odd love for him.

It wasn't really a waste of time, took about 15 seconds.

Judging by your short reply and lack of replying to anyone who made valid points re Khabib's views you've not really got a valid response to any of it and will just pretend none of it exists or dismiss it all as his cultural views again.
What’s new about any of it? I know about the incidents and I’d expect most people on his situation to act the same.
Is everyone who voted for Blair or took a photo with him a war criminal too?
 

Raoul

Admin
Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 1999
Messages
129,967
Location
Hollywood CA

I think that's a fair response to that line of argument.

In general though I get that the context of Khabib's background matters when criticising him for the various bad things he's done. But if people are praising him and (in some cases) holding him up as an admirable figure then those bad things also have to be part of the context for that too.
I don't know about the Kadyrov wouldn't harm him bit when he only recently went after Fedor's teenage daughter.
 

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
What’s new about any of it? I know about the incidents and I’d expect most people on his situation to act the same.
Is everyone who voted for Blair or took a photo with him a war criminal too?
Jesus, talk about scraping a barrel.

You literally would defend Khabib on anything :lol: I don't think anyone called Khabib a war criminal....just criticised him for being pally with one which seems a fair enough criticism.

It's only fair that after the praise he's got people can also say he's a dodgy character, there's balance to everything.
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
Jesus, talk about scraping a barrel.

You literally would defend Khabib on anything :lol: I don't think anyone called Khabib a war criminal....just criticised him for being pally with one which seems a fair enough criticism.

It's only fair that after the praise he's got people can also say he's a dodgy character, there's balance to everything.
And I’ve already written a response to that. The article is flawed and extremely biased as it looks at Khabibs decisions from a solely a western view. Not sure what else I can add if this is what I believe?
 

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
And I’ve already written a response to that. The article is flawed and extremely biased as it looks at Khabibs decisions from a solely a western view. Not sure what else I can add if this is what I believe?
Surely you can concede it's fair people will judge him on his sketchy background and the stuff he does? Can't just dismiss everything as a view from the western world.

You spent all weekend telling us how great he is as a person, a fighter, slating other fighters for their traits and yet when people criticise Khabib it's the western worlds problem.

People can look at it from the Western view, then use your argument that maybe he thinks differently and still come to the same argument that "actually the guy is clearly a bit of a cnut"
 

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
feck sake. The decision between keeping Maupay Vs getting Antonio in is doing my l nut!
Antonio has a better ground game but Maupay is a good all round fighter. Although he has got history of being a choker ala Cerrone on the big stage (see the 98th minute penalty vs. United.)
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
Surely you can concede it's fair people will judge him on his sketchy background and the stuff he does? Can't just dismiss everything as a view from the western world.

You spent all weekend telling us how great he is as a person, a fighter, slating other fighters for their traits and yet when people criticise Khabib it's the western worlds problem.

People can look at it from the Western view, then use your argument that maybe he thinks differently and still come to the same argument that "actually the guy is clearly a bit of a cnut"
When did I say others couldn't draw their own conclusions. You can do as you like.
 

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
When did I say others couldn't draw their own conclusions. You can do as you like.
Each to their own. I just find it really weird when people get ultra defensive about people they don't even know getting criticised. Especially to just brush off someone's ridiculous views as people from the western world being ignorant to it...at the same time you criticise other fighters at any give opportunity
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
Each to their own. I just find it really weird when people get ultra defensive about people they don't even know getting criticised. Especially to just brush off someone's ridiculous views as people from the western world being ignorant to it...at the same time you criticise other fighters at any give opportunity
I have grown up and live in the same western world that McGregor did. So there is no bias or lack of empathy when I criticise him or hold him accountable against the standards of his culture. Not sure what is so hard to understand on this front.
 

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
I have grown up and live in the same western world that McGregor did. So there is no bias or lack of empathy when I criticise him or hold him accountable against the standards of his culture. Not sure what is so hard to understand on this front.
Surely people can criticise others if they're not from the same culture though? If there's valid criticisms about Khabib surely he can he criticised. By your logic do you disagree with Khabib criticisng McGregor? Different cultures after all.
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
Surely people can criticise others if they're not from the same culture though? If there's valid criticisms about Khabib surely he can he criticised. By your logic do you disagree with Khabib criticisng McGregor? Different cultures after all.
There seem to be two conversations going on here.

1. The Report
Sure you can, but be empathetic to the person you are criticising. A journalists personal views are worthless. It's their job to live in the views of their subject and tell the story from this perspective. They may then objectively apply other judgment criteria. Its called a 'report' for this reason. But the report posted which initiated this conversation was absurdly biased, and was basically an OpEd.

2. Our personal views
Khabib has no right to criticise McGregor for adhering to western cultural norms, but then I don't think he ever has? Any allegation Khabib has made against McGregor has support across the western world. As for criticising people from other cultures, it's Khabib's risk not to conform if he wants to pocket all the $$$ from another culture, but that's about it.
I don't think that Western culture is superior than others. It's simply an opinion on how life should be lived, and there are many such opinions around the world. As a Westerner, you are most welcome to criticise him, but why are you so surprised that others will find your criticism naive or unsophisticated?
 
Last edited:

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
There seem to be two conversations going on here.

1. The Report
Sure you can, but be empathetic to the person you are criticising. A journalists personal views are worthless. It's their job to live in the views of their subject and tell the story from this perspective. They may then objectively apply other judgment criteria. Its called a 'report' for this reason. But the report spited which initiated this conversation was absurdly biased, it barely even qualifies an an OpEd.

2. Our personal views
Khabib has no right to criticise McGregor for adhering to western cultural norms, but then I don't think he ever has? Any allegation Khabib has made against McGregor has majority support across the western world. As for criticising people from other cultures, it's Khabib's risk not to conform if he wants to pocket all the $$$ from another culture, but that's about it.
I don't think that Western culture is superior than others. It's simply an opinion on how life should be lived, and there are many such opinions around the world. As a Westerner, you are most welcome to criticise him, but why are you so surprised that others will find your criticism naive or unsophisticated?
It's not particularly his personal views though in fairness. I'd say by definition of journalism it hits the criteria pretty well, especially for MMA standards. I think it's perfectly fair for people to hear both sides of the story. We've heard all week what a great athlete Khabib is (and he is.) But then with anyone it's only fair to hear the flaws of the person as well, especially after some of the stuff with Khabib was putting him as this angel outside of the sport when the reality is far more complex than that. Course we've not lived under that lifestyle Khabib has but for me that doesn't mean we can't criticise him for certain things.

I don't think Khabib is adhering to "norms" though particularly. I don't think the "norm" is hanging around with dictators for example and some of the stuff he says leaves a lot to be desired. Equally with Khabib it's not like he's lived stuck in Dagestan forever, he trains out of AKA with plenty of people who are not from that culture and therefore he should be slightly more educated than the stuff he says. I think even being generous with him and saying some stuff is out of his hands in regards of what he has to say in front of dictators, he's said plenty of stuff on his own free will which can be described as ignorant at best (homophobic and sexist is probably more appropriate.)

Regarding McGregor he did criticise certain western norms, he criticised him for lifestyle choices regarding acohol/drugs which are a culturual thing and are impacted by the society you are brought up in. He accused him of being a rapist which obviously isn't normal but equally there's no charges of it and it's a pretty strong alegation to throw at someone.

I don't particularly think it's unsophisticated to criticise it and I'm intrigued as to why you think that is the case? If you read up on something and form an opinion that's the complete opposite of being unsophisticated. If anything I'd say if people can't see the other side of the debate or argument and are blinded by their views and beliefs then they are ignorant themselves (not talking about you there by the way more of a general comment.)
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
It's not particularly his personal views though in fairness. I'd say by definition of journalism it hits the criteria pretty well, especially for MMA standards. I think it's perfectly fair for people to hear both sides of the story. We've heard all week what a great athlete Khabib is (and he is.) But then with anyone it's only fair to hear the flaws of the person as well, especially after some of the stuff with Khabib was putting him as this angel outside of the sport when the reality is far more complex than that. Course we've not lived under that lifestyle Khabib has but for me that doesn't mean we can't criticise him for certain things.

I don't think Khabib is adhering to "norms" though particularly. I don't think the "norm" is hanging around with dictators for example and some of the stuff he says leaves a lot to be desired. Equally with Khabib it's not like he's lived stuck in Dagestan forever, he trains out of AKA with plenty of people who are not from that culture and therefore he should be slightly more educated than the stuff he says. I think even being generous with him and saying some stuff is out of his hands in regards of what he has to say in front of dictators, he's said plenty of stuff on his own free will which can be described as ignorant at best (homophobic and sexist is probably more appropriate.)

Regarding McGregor he did criticise certain western norms, he criticised him for lifestyle choices regarding acohol/drugs which are a culturual thing and are impacted by the society you are brought up in. He accused him of being a rapist which obviously isn't normal but equally there's no charges of it and it's a pretty strong alegation to throw at someone.

I don't particularly think it's unsophisticated to criticise it and I'm intrigued as to why you think that is the case? If you read up on something and form an opinion that's the complete opposite of being unsophisticated. If anything I'd say if people can't see the other side of the debate or argument and are blinded by their views and beliefs then they are ignorant themselves (not talking about you there by the way more of a general comment.)
Nothing wrong in this post from my POV but all we have established is there are several ways to view things. But then we all know this.
IMO, the journalist should have established this and failed in that regard.
My thanks for a good and robust discussion.
 

Raoul

Admin
Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 1999
Messages
129,967
Location
Hollywood CA
Good HBO piece on the intersection of MMA and the Chechen dictatorship. Also interviews Karim Zidan at one point.

 

Oggmonster

Full Member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
4,932
Location
Manchester
Nothing wrong in this post from my POV but all we have established is there are several ways to view things. But then we all know this.
IMO, the journalist should have established this and failed in that regard.
My thanks for a good and robust discussion.


Same to you! :) Always good to see and hear different views.

Good HBO piece on the intersection of MMA and the Chechen dictatorship. Also interviews Karim Zidan at one point.

Region blocked unfortunately, does anyone know if it's available elsewhere? Wouldn't mind watching that later.
 

Raoul

Admin
Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 1999
Messages
129,967
Location
Hollywood CA
Same to you! :) Always good to see and hear different views.



Region blocked unfortunately, does anyone know if it's available elsewhere? Wouldn't mind watching that later.
There may be a third party version floating around on Youtube. Just type in kadyrov hbo interview.
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
Great video showing GSP training at Tiger Muay Thai, where I have also trained MMA for 10 weeks! Covid has temporarily destroyed what was becoming the fight training mecca in the world, a road called Soi TaiEd in Phuket.

Once its up and running again, I'd seriously recommend any of you who want to get better at MMA, or fancy a fitness, beach and healthy eating holiday, you must go to Soi TaiEd in Phuket! Many other top MMA fighters have also trained in this area, especially just before they hit the big time, so it's highly likely you will see people while you are there that became famous within a year to two later.

This guy gives great and fair reviews for all gyms on the street (go back to Feb 2020, as he cant review since covid19 lockdown)



 
Last edited:

2cents

Historiographer, and obtainer of rare antiquities
Scout
Joined
Mar 19, 2008
Messages
16,174
Where do Matt Hughes and BJ Penn enter the GOAT discussion? Hughes especially I never see mentioned, but looking at his record, he has some very impressive wins and runs.
 

Raoul

Admin
Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 1999
Messages
129,967
Location
Hollywood CA
Where do Matt Hughes and BJ Penn enter the GOAT discussion? Hughes especially I never see mentioned, but looking at his record, he has some very impressive wins and runs.
Hughes lost quite a few fights later in his career. Penn barely has a winning record.
 

Maluco

Last Man Standing 3 champion 2019/20
Joined
Jan 4, 2014
Messages
5,765
Jon Jones is insufferable.

Just let the man have his moment. Let your own career speak for itself and have some class. When you do that, people will speak up for you and put your name forward.

Khabib just put on a flawless performance against a fighter on an absolute tear. He is 29-0 and has won almost every round in his career.

Let him have his deserved moment and praise and wait for the next of the many, many moments you have already been allowed to savor.

Completely classless, insecure and egotistical, and that’s before you even mention USADA and his self-sabotage.
 

Raoul

Admin
Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 1999
Messages
129,967
Location
Hollywood CA
Hope not. He’d absolutely smash a 39-yr old GSP who’s only fought once in the last 7 years. Last time he stepped into the cage was 3 years ago.
Its not like Khabib would be fighting an over the hill version of Cowboy Cerrone, Dan Henderson, Bisping, or BJ Penn. This is GSP and he's in great shape still.
 

Man of Leisure

Threatened by women who like sex.
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
13,858
Location
One Big Holiday
Jon Jones is insufferable.

Just let the man have his moment. Let your own career speak for itself and have some class. When you do that, people will speak up for you and put your name forward.

Khabib just put on a flawless performance against a fighter on an absolute tear. He is 29-0 and has won almost every round in his career.

Let him have his deserved moment and praise and wait for the next of the many, many moments you have already been allowed to savor.

Completely classless, insecure and egotistical, and that’s before you even mention USADA and his self-sabotage.
Umm, what did you expect when P4P goat talk comes up? These guys are fighters and self-promoters ffs. And there’s not much wrong with what Jones has said. It’s not like Khabib’s died.