Dansk
Full Member
- Joined
- May 7, 2017
- Messages
- 1,391
I consider that a form of mismanagement, and a big blemish on a manager's credentials. It's like when you see those players who are clearly extremely talented and show world class performances at times, but have big faults off the pitch that interfere with their careers and keep them from being considered one of the very best. If Klopp's managerial style is to push his teams so hard that they break after three years of overperforming, and then spend much longer than that trying to put the pieces back together and claw their way back to competitiveness, I have a hard time calling him one of the greats. At best he's good at motivating players and getting them to break themselves for him, which is certainly an effective means of getting short-term results, but not a healthy one for the club. He hasn't shown himself to be a tactical mastermind, and he won the CL against what must surely be called the easiest final opponent anyone has had in like twenty years. If Liverpool go through the same utter implosion that Dortmund did, he'll be a deeply flawed manager in my eyes.Klopp’s teams have history of burn out.
We’ve seen it happen before.
His Dortmund team had three consecutive seasons of being the hardest working team in Bundesliga in much similar fashion to how Liverpool have been the hardest working (both on and off the ball) in the Premier League since 2017/18.
In Klopp’s final season, Dortmund were in the relegation zone at Christmas because they just deflated.
Then he left, claiming he, himself, needed a breather. He was wrecked. He looks wrecked now, in truth.
I love Klopp. I think he’s done a stellar job at both clubs. But it seems his football philosophy has a short shelf life for players.
I hate to say this, though I fear it’s true: Liverpool’s balloon (like Dortmund’s) may well have burst so much that Klopp will never be able to blow it back up.
There are so many parallels between Klopp at Dortmund and Klopp at Liverpool.
Either way, he did a great job at both. And is a club legend X 2.
But the football he tasks his teams with playing is just not sustainable to oversee a period of dominance. Jurgen Klopp is no Sir Alex Ferguson.
Last edited: