Another boring one horse race

Maluco

Last Man Standing 3 champion 2019/20
Joined
Jan 4, 2014
Messages
5,904
I don’t think you made it clear so I’m gonna double check, is he an Arsenal fan?

Hes right anyway. We’ve bought very poorly Bruno aside & entrusted a manager who is clearly nowhere near the required level needed to challenge Pep & City.
He very well might be yes :D

I’m just really surprised to hear it from that source. Their last 15 years have been defined by doing what’s right for the club and building/paying for their stadium. It was basically the life’s work of their legendary manager.

I think what City have been allowed to do detracts from that sort of work massively.

There is nothing special about a team with 6 £50 million defenders in the squad. It’s nothing to marvel at no matter how attractive their passing triangles are.
 

united_99

Takes pleasure in other people's pain
Joined
Jul 4, 2012
Messages
9,568
So, as an Arsenal fan, all those years of Wenger scouting and signing young talents from abroad on a budget, dominating the league, becoming United’s biggest rivals on merit wasn’t infinitely more satisfying?

All that time Wenger invested and the price he paid (to his legacy) in balancing the books and easing a club he loved into a new stadium on a tight budget were for nothing?

I am really surprised to hear this from an Arsenal fan considering the clubs recent history and how much of it had been focused on managing a club the right way.

Wenger himself has enough to say about the subject and took great pride in his work.
Most Arsenal fans are incredibly bitter towards United. After all we won 4 league titles against them, whereas they only won 1 against us (1998, when we came 2nd behind them).
 

ray24

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 14, 2014
Messages
178
Supports
Arsenal
The same shit coach who finished third last season (his first full season) and is currently second in the table now? Agreed with some of the thing you mentioned but it's a bit rude calling United manager shit on united forum, especially coming from a rival fan. You will be a newbie for sometime yet.
A coach in charge of a club with the second highest spending power after Man City. When you guys can afford to throw 80 million pounds on an average CB, can afford to throw over a 100 million for a player without having your finance stretched to the limit, that's a lot easier to reach the top 3.

There is a chance I would sleep with Adriana Lima. And Jose won trophies with United, no one remembers him fondly. Only trophies that really matter are PL/CL. I would bet Ole has a greater chance of winning one of those before Arteta does.
Ole will come closer to the top teams than Arteta, but Ole has a big financial advantage that Arteta doesn't have.
 

cyberman

Full Member
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
37,331
Eh ? I posted in the pre season prediction thread predicting us to be 2nd or close 3rd. I have said a lot during this season we're ready for a title challenge and should be in it.

It's quite disappointing we led the league by 3 points then threw it completely 3 weeks later and now +10 points away from first spot and that's not because we flopped in a big game but because we lost 5 fecking points to the two teams at the bottom of the league.

2nd or 3rd will be a good campaign but if it ended with no title challenge and +10 points gap to the first like our 2nd spot from few years ago it'll be nothing to gloat about.

I don't know when United fans will start believing we're actually a big team and it's time the expectations every season will be a a title challenge ?
Youre an exception to the rule though. After our window the vast, vast majority werent tipping us to challenge City to any extent thats suddenly being expected here.
1 defeat in 19, top scorers, undefeated away in over a year etc.
Keep this improvement up and we will be serious challengers next year. Hell even this is premature since win our next 3 and we are 7 points behind City. Theres a lot of definitive statements being made here when there's 13 games to go. We dont know how close or far from City we will be in May.
I had this same argument last year on here when fans were claiming our post January run wasnt good enough despite the promise it showed. Ill say now what i said then. If that run was the end point then it wasnt good enough for Man Utd but the exciting thing about it was the promise and improvement it showed. That goes for this season as well. If we stand still next year then questions need to be asked bit we are a side on the up.
 

Ludens the Red

Full Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
17,468
Location
London
Wait what? Are you forgetting the close battle between Liverpool and Man City just 2 season ago? There's tons of drama, just not drama involving Man Utd. There's drama watching teams trying to win a quadruple, trying to win 100 points, trying to match Arsenal's invincibles and etc.

The only fans who are annoyed by such thing are Man Utd fans because you guys are always away from the drama in some form or another.



You guys spend so much time complaining about City's money, but you are forgetting the fact that you have more money to spend than almost all the other clubs in the PL.

Liverpool won the title despite spending less money than you guys because they spent it a lot better. They got the right players in when they needed reinforcements.

Arsenal mis-spent a lot of our money in recent years, and that's why we are where we are today. But if we have the spending power of you guys, we can easily climb into the top 4.

Other clubs like Leicester are massively better than you guys in terms of scouting and building a team.

The big reason you guys are misspending all the money Ferguson left for you guys is because you have a shitty scouting team. You kept throwing money at established players that don't even if your team structure, or wasting them on players who lack the attributes to make it in a title winning team.
Hmm, not sure why you’ve quoted me and gone on a tirade about uniteds bad spending when I spent most of the post you quoted saying exactly that.

And also talking big about Arteta takes some balls. Your football is ugly to watch. You’re 11th in the league behind Leeds, West Ham and Villa.
Maybe leave Arteta out of any conversation. He’s performing a lot worse than Ole is.
 

Brightonian

Full Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2012
Messages
14,098
Location
Juanderlust
I don't think a team winning by a good margin is boring provided it's a different team every season. The concern for me is that City look like they have the staying power to keep doing it, and no-one else does.

In terms of this season, we only have ourselves to blame. The draw against Everton was utterly preventable. The dropped points against Sheffield and West Brom were a shambles. That's seven points we have absolutely no excuse for dropping. The only reason City are not still in a dogfight with us is we dropped the ball.
 

Eire Red United

New Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2016
Messages
2,723
Location
Ireland
City aren’t that far ahead. We should be right up there- ridiculous points dropped vs West Brom, Sheffield and Everton where we should have won, plus our horrendous start to the season.
 

The Brown Bull

It's Coming Home.
Joined
Jan 24, 2014
Messages
4,301
Location
Dublin.
City aren’t that far ahead. We should be right up there- ridiculous points dropped vs West Brom, Sheffield and Everton where we should have won, plus our horrendous start to the season.
We would. The point is though that we did drop those points. We also conceded very late V Leicester and lost and drew with the worst Arsenal team in a generation.
 

Karel Podolsky

Full Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Messages
1,420
Location
Borneo Jungle
Supports
Ex Laziale
Wait what? Are you forgetting the close battle between Liverpool and Man City just 2 season ago? There's tons of drama, just not drama involving Man Utd. There's drama watching teams trying to win a quadruple, trying to win 100 points, trying to match Arsenal's invincibles and etc.

The only fans who are annoyed by such thing are Man Utd fans because you guys are always away from the drama in some form or another.



You guys spend so much time complaining about City's money, but you are forgetting the fact that you have more money to spend than almost all the other clubs in the PL.

Liverpool won the title despite spending less money than you guys because they spent it a lot better. They got the right players in when they needed reinforcements.

Arsenal mis-spent a lot of our money in recent years, and that's why we are where we are today. But if we have the spending power of you guys, we can easily climb into the top 4.

Other clubs like Leicester are massively better than you guys in terms of scouting and building a team.

The big reason you guys are misspending all the money Ferguson left for you guys is because you have a shitty scouting team. You kept throwing money at established players that don't even if your team structure, or wasting them on players who lack the attributes to make it in a title winning team.
The best 'drama' in the last decade: 2012, 2014, 2019. All Manchester City wins.
 

el3mel

Full Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
43,735
Location
Egypt
Youre an exception to the rule though. After our window the vast, vast majority werent tipping us to challenge City to any extent thats suddenly being expected here.
1 defeat in 19, top scorers, undefeated away in over a year etc.
Keep this improvement up and we will be serious challengers next year. Hell even this is premature since win our next 3 and we are 7 points behind City. Theres a lot of definitive statements being made here when there's 13 games to go. We dont know how close or far from City we will be in May.
I had this same argument last year on here when fans were claiming our post January run wasnt good enough despite the promise it showed. Ill say now what i said then. If that run was the end point then it wasnt good enough for Man Utd but the exciting thing about it was the promise and improvement it showed. That goes for this season as well. If we stand still next year then questions need to be asked bit we are a side on the up.
Even 7 points isn't a small gap. It requires them to lose 3 more games or 2 games and 2-3 draws or something while us winning every single game in the same period (considering that they have much higher goal difference).

United is expected to challenge for the league, period. United fans seem to have forgotten that we are actually a big club with ton of quality and this is the normal expectation. Too many trying to control expectations and lower it down imo, just to avoid getting disappointed. With the quality we have in the squad it's pretty normal that we should be a title challenger. We were doing tha up till we led the league with 3 points then just threw it completely away and against trash teams like WBA and Sheffield who are going to get relegated. It is honestly a big disappointment. This was a golden chance for us and we threw it away.

Failing to challenge for the league and finishing distant 2nd or 3rd is not a sackable offense for a United manager, I'm not saying that and it will still be a decent/good campaign but it's definitely below the expectations for a club with the size of United and it can't be considered a great season by any stretch. This is the difference in standards between United and say Leicester.
 

VanHaal'sRedArmy

Full Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2015
Messages
2,623
No one to blame except ourselves for the poor run of form. Our inability to put away mid-to-lower tier teams starting with Sheffield put us in bad shape.
 

rollingstoned1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
1,787
Agreed, as soon as title talk started around boxing day our hopes started evaporating.:mad: We have to try and get excited about trying to finish within single digits of City now if not securing a top 4 place.

I don't think moaning about oil money at this stage will really get us anywhere, we can still match them or do better given enough time and patience. Throwing money only gets you that far as we ourselves have learnt the hard way.
 

Needham

Full Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2013
Messages
11,754
Honestly I think they'll screw it up. Question is will it be us or Spurs who take advantage.
 

Bearded One

Full Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2017
Messages
1,245
Honestly I think they'll screw it up. Question is will it be us or Spurs who take advantage.
I must commend you for having so much faith. I was once positive that we’ll catch them but not so much now. Let’s keep our heads down and finish second and come back stronger next season by getting real quality and not missing out on obvious targets and then coming to the caf decrying our inability to compete.
 

Mr Smith

Full Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2015
Messages
4,020
Location
Australia
I think we have to accept that City running away with it this year is due to their financial power and squad depth but also other teams failing to mount a serious challenge, not one or the other. City's depth means they an be missing 4 or 5 first team players and not have a huge drop in quality, and that can't be ignored, especially when you consider what happened to Liverpool this season.

On the other hand, you can't ignore what others have pointed out, which is that we should be closer to them and putting pressure on them. We're not alone either, Liverpool shouldn't have dropped as far as they have regardless of Van Dijk's injury, and I firmly believe Spurs are being made to look way worse than they should be, and that a competent manager would have them part of the conversation this season.

Ultimately, City's financial power, but also their smoothness at the organisational level, will always mean they are at an advantage during seasons where other clubs drop a level. But that doesn't excuse the failure of other clubs who aren't exactly financial minows themselves to stay competitive.
 

Nash27

Full Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
351
City aren’t that far ahead. We should be right up there- ridiculous points dropped vs West Brom, Sheffield and Everton where we should have won, plus our horrendous start to the season.
7 points dropped from those 3 games. If we had won all 3, could have been easily just 3 points behind city.
 

Olecurls99

Full Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2021
Messages
2,168
The only people that seems fed up with a one horse race is Man Utd fans. In all honesty, I would rather enjoy watching a team playing good passing/attacking football dominate and win the league than to watch two defensive/reactive team 1-nil their way to the title.

I don't think you guys are in any position to complain about a boring one-horse race is because you guys have the resources to challenge Man City. Yes, they have limitless money, but they have not really outspend you guys massively. You guys have an endless supply of sponsorships that allows you to throw $100 million at players in an period when even the La Liga giants are becoming bankrupt.

You guys have money to spend. We end up with a one-horse race because the only other club that can match Man City in terms of spending decides to waste all their money on a shit coach and average players that lacks elite level technical ability to dominate the game.
A bit unfair on Ole. The gap between the 2 clubs was bigger when he took over in terms of points, squad quality and performance but yes we have rivaled City for spending these past 5 years. They were starting from a better point there as well though and their resources are unlimited whereas ours are fixed somewhat.
Arsenal fans have the most to feel aggrieved about when it comes to the petrodollar clubs. It started just when you were at your peak. I don't see an end in sight when it comes to City dominance now. If they win the Champions league they'll attract the Mbappes and that'll be that for European football too.
 

Jonno

Full Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2010
Messages
8,375
Location
Preston, Lancashire
Some people blaming United for a one horse race, I'm sorry... but - isn't this the City/Liverpool Klopp/Pep era?

We've done well to be the 2nd best side for most of the season.

City have been utterly brilliant and it's 5-6 years in the making. Every credit to them. Liverpool should be competing, I've noticed the players now come out moaning about injuries, its rubbing off from their manager.
 

Olecurls99

Full Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2021
Messages
2,168
Truth hurts but that’s the bottom line. ‘Shit coach’ is very harsh though. Ole is a decent coach but decent isn’t anywhere near the level required to usurp city and Liverpool.

The fundemental facts are that city can outspend anyone bar us with ease and even us. We have made far more catastrophic transfer mistakes than they have which is why we have the squad we have and they have the squad they have.
On top of that they have one of the best managers of all time.

The only way you stop a team like that winning a title every year is by either outspending them and world classing up
your squad or by getting a manager in who is at the level or better than theirs.
The only one of these things that has happened since Pep arrived is the latter and what happened? That team won the league last season at a canter.

I’m being blunt here and it’s been said a few times. We will never win a league title with our current squad or manager again so long as Guardiola and Klopp are around.
The idea that Ole and a weaker squad will surpass Guardiola and city is actual fantasy.

We can sit here and complain but the club isn’t doing all it can to prevent city winning league titles unchallenged.
Our recruitment is extremely Questionable , our contract renewals are borderline sabotage. We’re hiring a manager and a coaching team significantly weaker than that of our peers. The end results will be that every single season we’ll be finishing miles behind Man City. That’s what’s happened and that’s what’s going to happen this year.
What do you propose?
 

SER19

Full Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
12,646
No I’m talking about a low table side being able to begin to compete at the top end of the league favorably in the long term. It’s a very tough ask. What happened to Leicester the season after they won the league? They were in the relegation conversation.
Yeah you're right it's incredibly tough. But that is the nature of sport. Somebody has to be but teams will still go through peaks and troughs. My argument is that city have bypassed other professional teams on that journey, stole the opportunity to win cups from teams that might otherwise have. Think of all the years moyes was rebuilding Everton. Most other times they'd have won an fa cup. Likewise Stoke. Think a Wigan fan would swap the fa cup win that day for winning a league cup the way City do? I very much doubt it. They're operating in a way that is delivering the exact results you'd expect. It's robotic, financial and soulless
 

ray24

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 14, 2014
Messages
178
Supports
Arsenal
Hmm, not sure why you’ve quoted me and gone on a tirade about uniteds bad spending when I spent most of the post you quoted saying exactly that.

And also talking big about Arteta takes some balls. Your football is ugly to watch. You’re 11th in the league behind Leeds, West Ham and Villa.
Maybe leave Arteta out of any conversation. He’s performing a lot worse than Ole is.
I was quoting the other posters. I've misquoted you by mistake, sorry. As for Arteta... He has only managed to get the team he wanted in the middle of the season, with EMR and Saka coming into their own and we finally have a proper CAM in Odergard. Prior to that the Arsenal team is utterly devoid of any real attacking threat.

The best 'drama' in the last decade: 2012, 2014, 2019. All Manchester City wins.
And it's drama for all the non-United fans.

A bit unfair on Ole. The gap between the 2 clubs was bigger when he took over in terms of points, squad quality and performance but yes we have rivaled City for spending these past 5 years. They were starting from a better point there as well though and their resources are unlimited whereas ours are fixed somewhat.
Arsenal fans have the most to feel aggrieved about when it comes to the petrodollar clubs. It started just when you were at your peak. I don't see an end in sight when it comes to City dominance now. If they win the Champions league they'll attract the Mbappes and that'll be that for European football too.
Ole took over a squad that had one of the most expensive midfielders of all time in Pobga and plenty of expensive talents. Talents that you can afford to sell at a cost and still have money to spend on expensive players. But you guys wasted a lot of time and money chasing the wrong players as well.

You guys spent all summer chasing Sancho only to end up with no new RW. You spent decent money on VDB when there's no intention to play him at all.

You guys should have no effort going head to head against Man City every season. But the way you mismanaged recruitment is what is holding you guys back. And having a coach that relies on counter-attacking football is unlikely to win the title. It's not the mid 2000s anymore when Chelsea can 1-nil their victory to a title. Now any title winning team needs to be good at positional-attacking football to break down defense. When you guys finally have a coach that can implement good pressing football, then you might have a real chance of winning.
 

rron10

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 5, 2020
Messages
405
Supports
Sir Alex
You guys spent all summer chasing Sancho only to end up with no new RW. You spent decent money on VDB when there's no intention to play him at all.

You guys should have no effort going head to head against Man City every season. But the way you mismanaged recruitment is what is holding you guys back. And having a coach that relies on counter-attacking football is unlikely to win the title. It's not the mid 2000s anymore when Chelsea can 1-nil their victory to a title. Now any title winning team needs to be good at positional-attacking football to break down defense. When you guys finally have a coach that can implement good pressing football, then you might have a real chance of winning.
Well I can certainly agree to that.
 

tomaldinho1

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2015
Messages
17,722
I think this thread is really just sour grapes, if we hadn't dropped the stupid points we did, and City not improved, we would be the ones threatening to run away with it, and I doubt this thread gets created.

In any event, even if one team keeps running away with it, at least it's not the same team. We've had four different winners in about 7 years. To me that's not boring.
Yh agreed. Add in that City aren’t actually that good this year - compared to their monster team of 2/3 years ago - and it’s more about the drop off from other teams for me. Football across the globe seems to have suffered from covid, this season is about who is the least shit.

Liverpool’s plight is a freak occurrence but Chelsea went with a rookie manager and it seems like it definitely cost them now you see them with Tuchel. Let’s see how they play today. United have just been a mediocre team that spend a lot money for ages now. Our poor management, planning and recruiting makes City look like an unstoppable force when they’re really not. United should be fighting for league titles when you look at spending, the fact we’re not is on us.
 

Josep Dowling

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
7,654
Hate to say it but you have to give credit to Guardiola. He has caused the huge gap in quality over the rest. Klopp also last season but they have fallen off as they can’t invest in their squad like City can. Just proves if you get the best managers in the world, with a dynamic attacking style, you have a better chance of winning trophies. More so than just buying in expensive players. Maybe our club should learn a few lessons from that.
 

Adisa

likes to take afvanadva wothowi doubt
Joined
Nov 28, 2014
Messages
50,370
Location
Birmingham
City aren’t that far ahead. We should be right up there- ridiculous points dropped vs West Brom, Sheffield and Everton where we should have won, plus our horrendous start to the season.
Apart from Everton we didn't deserve to win any of those games. Our performances were poor in majority of them so I am not sure they count.
 

Wayne's World

Full Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2010
Messages
9,291
Location
Ireland
Pep has turned the Premier League into the SPL pre Rangers getting good again and as long as he's around, he'll continue to make a mockery of the league
 

Paddy B

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 19, 2020
Messages
114
Supports
Manchester City
Hate to say it but you have to give credit to Guardiola. He has caused the huge gap in quality over the rest. Klopp also last season but they have fallen off as they can’t invest in their squad like City can. Just proves if you get the best managers in the world, with a dynamic attacking style, you have a better chance of winning trophies. More so than just buying in expensive players. Maybe our club should learn a few lessons from that.
You make some good points. I wonder where United would be now and what their style of play would be like if Pep had been their manager for the last few years.
 

cyberman

Full Member
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
37,331
Hate to say it but you have to give credit to Guardiola. He has caused the huge gap in quality over the rest. Klopp also last season but they have fallen off as they can’t invest in their squad like City can. Just proves if you get the best managers in the world, with a dynamic attacking style, you have a better chance of winning trophies. More so than just buying in expensive players. Maybe our club should learn a few lessons from that.
Utd have scored more goals than City this season. They arent clear because of dynamic attacking but changing to a pragmatic style. They will win this based on their defence which is nothing but buying in expensive players.
Its like our fans have a meme bingo sheet that is rolled out regardless of how out of date they are.
 

dinostar77

Full Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2014
Messages
7,253
Then its up to the other clubs to raise to the challenge. Not city's fault the others are incapable of raising a challenge. Mediocrity from the other so called big clubs. On paper its simple enough, dont lose more than 3 games all season and dont draw more than half a dozen games. Then you got a good chance of being in the race for the totle. But even with Aguero out for most of the season, no-one has done anything of note.

We are a work in progress, and not ready for a title challenge. I'd be alot more pessimistic about the PL if City do sign Messi this summer. Then for sure we are looking at a few seasons of unrivalled dominance.
 

Hansi Fick

New Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
5,057
Supports
FC Bayern
Utd have scored more goals than City this season. They arent clear because of dynamic attacking but changing to a pragmatic style. They will win this based on their defence which is nothing but buying in expensive players.
Its like our fans have a meme bingo sheet that is rolled out regardless of how out of date they are.
Guardiola didn't need to change his style to be defensively solid.
His style always had that element, the ball possession has easily just as much a defensive function as an attacking.
His Barca team conceded far less goals than Mourinho's Real, for example. It's a misconception that Pep is an "attacking" coach at the expense of defense. He is just as much a defensive coach.
He is just quite simply a extraordinarily capable and successful league coach, and if he's in charge of one of the best squads in the league it will be hard, almost impossible, to get past him, no matter how well you do.
 

DomesticTadpole

Doom-monger obsessed with Herrera & the M.E.N.
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
101,083
Location
Barrow In Furness
Utd have scored more goals than City this season. They arent clear because of dynamic attacking but changing to a pragmatic style. They will win this based on their defence which is nothing but buying in expensive players.
Its like our fans have a meme bingo sheet that is rolled out regardless of how out of date they are.
If we could sort that defence out we will be a lot better. We could have scored even more goals if we could also fathom out how to score against teams intent on defending. The defence has been the main culprits though. Lack of concentration and sloppiness. Ole has to be ruthless. If he needs to drop DDG, then drop him. If we need another CB, make sure you chose the right one. We need to able to change our game, not just look lost when surprise, surprise some teams do not want to attack against us.
 

cyberman

Full Member
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
37,331
Guardiola didn't need to change his style to be defensively solid.
His style always had that element, the ball possession has easily just as much a defensive function as an attacking.
His Barca team conceded far less goals than Mourinho's Real, for example. It's a misconception that Pep is an "attacking" coach at the expense of defense. He is just as much a defensive coach.
He is just quite simply a extraordinarily capable and successful league coach, and if he's in charge of one of the best squads in the league it will be hard, almost impossible, to get past him, no matter how well you do.
He doesnt play with a striker now, play isnt controlled with midfield and instead of dictating play they have Gundogan making runs beyond the forwards. Even their FBs arent the interverted midfielders they were before. Theyre a lot more rigid in their movements now to lessen the impact when they lose the ball
This season is the furthest Pep has gone from his philosophy we have seen yet imo.
 

Borys

Statistics Wizard
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
9,086
Location
Bielsko Biala, Poland
Guardiola didn't need to change his style to be defensively solid.
His style always had that element, the ball possession has easily just as much a defensive function as an attacking.
His Barca team conceded far less goals than Mourinho's Real, for example. It's a misconception that Pep is an "attacking" coach at the expense of defense. He is just as much a defensive coach.
He is just quite simply a extraordinarily capable and successful league coach, and if he's in charge of one of the best squads in the league it will be hard, almost impossible, to get past him, no matter how well you do.
I agree. The popular opinion is he buys the best players, which is not the reason City are so dominant. Because of the system they play (excellent, organized pressing) their defense is never under pressure.

I believe the way they work off the ball as a team makes them an excellent side. Their front players lose the ball a lot. But whenever opposition intercepts it, a split second and City players are all over them. That's how they create openings, break opponents shape etc.

Like you mentioned, I don't think Pep is an attacking coach. He wants his team to dominate on the pitch, which works almost every time.

They lost de Bruyne and still kept winning. This team is not about individuals.
 

Hansi Fick

New Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
5,057
Supports
FC Bayern
He doesnt play with a striker now, play isnt controlled with midfield and instead of dictating play they have Gundogan making runs beyond the forwards. Even their FBs arent the interverted midfielders they were before. Theyre a lot more rigid in their movements now to lessen the impact when they lose the ball
This season is the furthest Pep has gone from his philosophy we have seen yet imo.
That may be true (I don't really watch City that much this season), but he hasn't got more points than in his previous title winning seasons with it, and also not less goals conceded.
Whatever he's doing now, my point would be that he always was a defensive-minded coach too, in his own way. In CL ties, often even too much for his own good.
So probably I'm more reaffirming your general point rather than disagreeing with it.
 

Sarni

nice guy, unassuming, objective United fan.
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
57,661
Location
Krakow
Wait what? Are you forgetting the close battle between Liverpool and Man City just 2 season ago? There's tons of drama, just not drama involving Man Utd. There's drama watching teams trying to win a quadruple, trying to win 100 points, trying to match Arsenal's invincibles and etc.

The only fans who are annoyed by such thing are Man Utd fans because you guys are always away from the drama in some form or another..
Well that’s why I said ‘almost all’. That’s the only genuine title race of the last 7 season. All other seasons it was done 3-4 weeks before the end, usually even sooner.
 

Guy Incognito

Full Member
Joined
May 21, 2011
Messages
17,771
Location
Somewhere
Some people blaming United for a one horse race, I'm sorry... but - isn't this the City/Liverpool Klopp/Pep era?

We've done well to be the 2nd best side for most of the season.

City have been utterly brilliant and it's 5-6 years in the making. Every credit to them. Liverpool should be competing, I've noticed the players now come out moaning about injuries, its rubbing off from their manager.
The thing is I could see Klopp squeezing one last title out of his team next season. They are basically where City were last season, off the pace.

City's owners are very target orientated, so I wonder if they hope Pep will be around to overtake Everton's league title record.
 

ray24

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 14, 2014
Messages
178
Supports
Arsenal
Well that’s why I said ‘almost all’. That’s the only genuine title race of the last 7 season. All other seasons it was done 3-4 weeks before the end, usually even sooner.
Isn't that the case for most PL seasons? You either get a close title race to the end of the season, or the season is already well wrapped up a few months before the end of the season. I mean there's always teams like Liverpool and Arsenal (Emirates era) that LOOKED like title contenders, but will always drop off from actually winning the title.

The idea that there is a close title race before Man City joined is not really evident. Jose's 2000s Chelsea also dominated the league at their peak.

The only reason why it might seem like this season is a boring one horse race is because Man Utd fans are viewing everything through your perspective. You guys have won so many titles over the past two decades, and you end up seeing competitors to your title run when we all know those title challengers will always fall behind.
 

Sarni

nice guy, unassuming, objective United fan.
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
57,661
Location
Krakow
Isn't that the case for most PL seasons? You either get a close title race to the end of the season, or the season is already well wrapped up a few months before the end of the season. I mean there's always teams like Liverpool and Arsenal (Emirates era) that LOOKED like title contenders, but will always drop off from actually winning the title.

The idea that there is a close title race before Man City joined is not really evident. Jose's 2000s Chelsea also dominated the league at their peak.

The only reason why it might seem like this season is a boring one horse race is because Man Utd fans are viewing everything through your perspective. You guys have won so many titles over the past two decades, and you end up seeing competitors to your title run when we all know those title challengers will always fall behind.
Even if we aren’t in title race for another 50 years I would still much rather see a league with close title races until final weeks rather than what we have largely witnessed in the last decade. It was super boring when we were winning the league easily too, 2012-13 for instance was a season with almost no excitement from Feb onwards and it was boring as well.

Honestly I don’t see how anyone would enjoy a top team being 15-20 points clear in March, regardless of who they support.