I considered her and Justin Timberlake, but as good as they are, I think their stature is built on basically one album.
Music Best Solo Artist in Pop Music History
- Thread starter amolbhatia50k
- Start date
I never thought about that, the only Bob Dylan songs i've heard have been covers
You never heard the original Like a Rolling Stone?
Justin is a fraud. Had one or two half decent songs and built a career out of supposedly looking good, doing shit movies and dating Britney Spears. Plus he was in that abomination that was Nsync, who were basically a shit backstreet boys who themselves were, well, a boyband (at least one that did it well).
Lady Gaga is much better and unique. But of course she doesn't deserve to be anywhere in this discussion.
Bowie and Leonard Cohen probably.
MJ and to a lesser extent Prince were talented but still at the pop fluff end of the spectrum.
MJ and to a lesser extent Prince were talented but still at the pop fluff end of the spectrum.
It's possible I heard it in passing, but I haven't intentionally sought it myself if that makes sense.
She probably heard it and assumed it was being covered by some rubbish vocalist.
There are some great lists of artists posted so far, but I haven't seen anyone mention my favourite, Van Morrison.
Has he done something awful that I have missed and got himself cancelled?
Has he done something awful that I have missed and got himself cancelled?
I think he has always been a huge twat. For the last 3 or 4 or 4 decades also a talentless and increasingly paranoid loan of a twat.
https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2021/may/06/dylan-moran-comedian-dr-cosmos-stream
Third fan right here! She's a marvel.Oh I agree. Newsom is my second my favourite artist and my favourite solo artist of then all. Better than anyone we're discussing here. Her lyrical wizardly and enchanting music is other worldly. It's just that she doesn't qualify for this thread. Otherwise I absolutely adore her and will always champion her genius.
Nice to know she has another fan on the caf
Yet both hugely over rated - great but not that great.
Talented but not in the same universe as many artists mentioned in this thread.
Not at all. You can love Oasis while admitting their unoriginality and debt to the Beatles. The Beatles and Elivis were great but not even close to peak Bowie.
Last edited:
With respect to the Beatles, I respectfully and wholeheartedly disagree!
Great but pop fluff. Wouldn't be as well considered if not pioneering pop.
I mean, that's one reductive way to look at them.
my only guess so far is that in some ways he can remind people of MJ, similar dance moves and a really great voice. So he gets mentioned as a sort of fun spin on being MJ still singing? I dont know thats all I could think of
4th.
Her performance at the Bridgewater Hall in the mid 2000s remains the best solo set I've seen live.
Hendrix is my favourite solo artist, however.
Bowie’s best stuff wasn’t pop though. He had a few hits, but I’d never classify him as a pop musician.
And I think you’re discounting the greatness of the last few Beatles albums.
I'm convinced Robert pioneered rap with songs like 'They're Red Hot' too.
Half serious.
Exactly my point Bowie wasn't pop.
Peak Beatles was pop. Late Beatles was mainly less good, more pretentious pop.
She's pretty far from being a pop star, so isn't even in the conversation. She's a damn sight more talented than some of the artists being brought up though.
Apparently this isn't obvious to many in here.
But I gave up on this definition when Jimi Hendrix was mentioned.
Tbh I think most people who lived through the 80s and 90s can easily name 5 songs.
Not sure about the Bowie not being pop thing.
Aside from the Let's Dance period (where he was very much making pop music), so much of what he did from the Ziggy-era on has directly influenced modern pop to such an extent that he's basically grandfathered in.
I mean if you look at people like Lady Gaga or Madonna for example, most of the pop tropes they have traded on throughout their careers in terms of persona and presentation are derived directly from the Bowie of that time. Ditto hundreds of other pop acts since.
Put it this way: if you were writing a definitive history of modern pop music then that "Starman" appearance on Top of the Pops would be a linchpin moment.
Aside from the Let's Dance period (where he was very much making pop music), so much of what he did from the Ziggy-era on has directly influenced modern pop to such an extent that he's basically grandfathered in.
I mean if you look at people like Lady Gaga or Madonna for example, most of the pop tropes they have traded on throughout their careers in terms of persona and presentation are derived directly from the Bowie of that time. Ditto hundreds of other pop acts since.
Put it this way: if you were writing a definitive history of modern pop music then that "Starman" appearance on Top of the Pops would be a linchpin moment.
He’s not even in the top 10,000 of all time. It’s surely a joke. It must be.
No love for phil Collins? Also Whitney must take the prize for the best female ever. Her voice was amazing.
Amy Winehouse would've been right up there....great jazz vocals with attitude, her own unique style and a song writer...but one great album isn't nearly enough.
Last edited:
Marvin Gaye produced and wrote songs. The man was effortlessly cool and his vocals...well... they weren't bad were they? Amazing singer.
And Bill Withers had probably the best vocals of the lot. Also wrote some classic songs to boot.
MJ is probably the greatest showman.
MJ is probably the greatest showman.
Last edited:
Quite upsetting that The Great Big Beg that is Drake is probably the correct answer if you poll everyone born in the last 30 years.
I was going to mention Ini Kamoze...but I couldn't overlook 'extraordinary, juice like a strawberry...'.
Bet you love Huey Lewis and the News too.
And surely Bob Marley has to be in the mix.
In terms of influence he must be right up there.
In terms of showmanship... we're talking Jacko, Prince and James Brown.
In terms of influence he must be right up there.
In terms of showmanship... we're talking Jacko, Prince and James Brown.