It’s werid to me how many people seem to be wilfully ignoring how Partridge began as a way of justifying why they think this one “isn’t Partridge”... it’s the absolute perfect modern updating of KMKY, in theory at least. Everyone’s going to have their favourite interpretations, since the character has deliberately straddled many mediums (most of the creators actually dislike I’m Alan Partridge Season 2, and Patrick Marber disliked the very idea of doing a sitcom in the first place) but pretending that the character doesn’t work in this setting, or when he’s in charge, or that it isn’t realistic enough is a bit bonkers. He shot a man dead in the finale of his first TV series, which was presented in much the same way, on both TV and Radio before it.
There are a few little things I’m not feeling about this yet, but it’s very fittingly Partridge. Whatever you may think that means.
The only things that seem a little “off” to me are the way he makes his voice deep and growly at times in a very OTT way that I’m not aware of him doing in the much earlier incarnations.
In fact it’s possible one of the things that’s making it seem a little more low energy than KMKY, could be the lack of a laugh track, which was ever present in early Alan but I don’t think anyone actually wants a return to in this day and age...or maybe just the off camera laugher/chatter of the crew, which you do frequently hear on the actual One Show? It’s all quite eeriely silent, letting the full awkwardness reverberate, which comes from the Mid Morning Matters period more than anything.