All Time 11 In Your Lifetime - No Two Players Can Have Played For The Same Country or Club.

NotoriousISSY

$10mil and I fecked it up!
Joined
Mar 20, 2012
Messages
16,287
Location
up north
Lev Yashin (Soviet Union/Russia as per Fifa) [Dynamo Moscow]

Wim Suurbier (Netherlands) [Ajax, Schalke, Metz, LA Aztecs, San Jose, Golden Bay, Tampa Bay]
Franco Baresi (Italy) [Milan]
Vincent Kompany (Belgium) [Anderlecht, HSV, Man City]
Junior (Brazil) [Flamengo, Torino, Pescara]

Jean Tigana (France) [Toulon, Lyon, Bordeaux, Marseille]
Gerrard (England) [Liverpool, LA Galaxy]

Freddie Ljungberg (Sweden) [cba listing all because he was my last pick and I couldn't think of anyone else who doesn't clash]
Cristiano Ronaldo (Portugal) [Sporting, Man Utd, Real Madrid, Juve]
Gerd Muller (Germany) [Bayern, Nordlingen, Fort Lauderdale]
Lionel Messi (Argentina) [Barca]
 

paulscholes18

Full Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
20,174
Yashin
Lauren Baresi Moore Capdevila
Matthaus
KDB Socrates
Mbappe Messi Ronaldo

Fullbacks are a bit shit, but can’t think of anyone better
 
Last edited:

Cornish

Full Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2012
Messages
169
Think this works:

-------------------------Oblak-----------------------
Maldini--Kompany--Koulibaly--Lahm
----------------Scholes--Moutinho-----------
------------------------Zidane----------------------
-----Bergkamp--------------------Messi------
-----------------------Drogba----------------------
 

ClaytonBlackmoorLeftPeg

Full Member
Joined
May 22, 2017
Messages
13,122
nokillingmoths said:
Its much more fun ruining everyone else's than doing my own :lol:
Click to expand...
GK Petr Cech (Czech) / Oblak (Slovenia)
RB Ramos (Spain)
LB Lahm (Germany)
CB Vincent Kompany (Belgium)
CB Koulibaly (Senegal)
CM Zico (Brazil)
CM Platini (Italy)
LW George Best (N. Ireland)
RW Messi (Argentina)
CF Van Basten (Holland)
CF Shearer (England)

what about this?

Although also thinking of swapping Van Basten for Dagliesh, and then swapping Koulibaly for Maldini.
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,723
Location
Inside right
ClaytonBlackmoorLeftPeg said:
GK Petr Cech (Czech) / Oblak (Slovenia)
RB Ramos (Spain)
LB Lahm (Germany)
CB Vincent Kompany (Belgium)
CB Koulibaly (Senegal)
CM Zico (Brazil)
CM Platini (Italy)
LW George Best (N. Ireland)
RW Messi (Argentina)
CF Van Basten (Holland)
CF Shearer (England)

what about this?

Although also thinking of swapping Van Basten for Dagliesh, and then swapping Koulibaly for Maldini.
Click to expand...
You have a 4-4-2 with Zico and Platini in central midfield! What kind of revolutionary system is this you're debuting in here!? :D
 

hmchan

Full Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
1,429
Location
Hong Kong
This is rather easy. I'd only pick players who are currently playing to make it more difficult.

GK - Oblak (Slovenia/Benfica, Atletico)
RB - Pereira (Portugal/Porto, Leicester)
RCB - Marquinhos (Brazil/Corinthians, Roma, PSG)
LCB - Skriniar (Slovakia/Sampdoria, Inter)
LB - Hakimi (Morocco/Madrid, Dortmund)
CDM - Alaba (Austria/Bayern, Hoffenheim)
RCM - de Bruyne (Belgium/Genk, Chelsea, Bremen, Wolfsburg, City)
LCM - Pogba (France/Juventus, United)
RW - Messi (Argentina/Barcelona)
LW - Mane (Senegal/Salzburg, Southampton, Liverpool)
ST - Werner (Germany/Stuttgart, Leipzig)

One difficulty is that I find many players started their career at Genk, which makes me leave out the likes of Ndidi and Koulibaly. Nonetheless, I like de Bruyne so much that I pick him despite he has played for several big clubs. I also favor Hakimi so much that I have to drop a number of Madrid players such as Modric. Another difficulty is that many potential attackers have played for Dortmund, and there aren't many quality defenders besides van Dijk.
 
Last edited:

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,723
Location
Inside right
hmchan said:
This is rather easy. I'd only pick players who are currently playing to make it more difficult.

GK - Oblak (Slovenia/Benfica, Atletico)
RB - Pereira (Portugal/Porto, Leicester)
RCB - Marquinhos (Brazil/Corinthians, Roma, PSG)
LCB - Skriniar (Slovakia/Sampdoria, Inter)
LB - Hakimi (Morocco/Madrid, Dortmund)
CDM - Alaba (Austria/Bayern, Hoffenheim)
RCM - de Bruyne (Belgium/Genk, Chelsea, Bremen, Wolfsburg, City)
LCM - Pogba (France/Juventus, United)
RW - Messi (Argentina/Barcelona)
LW - Mane (Senegal/Salzburg, Southampton, Liverpool)
ST - Werner (Germany/Stuttgart, Leipzig)

One difficulty is that I find many players started their career at Genk, which makes me leave out the likes of Ndidi and Koulibaly. Nonetheless, I like de Bruyne so much that I pick him despite he has played for several big clubs. I also favor Hakimi so much that I have to drop a number of Madrid players such as Modric. Another difficulty is that many potential attackers have played for Dortmund, and there aren't many quality defenders besides van Dijk.
Click to expand...
Quite strange to say that and then produce a middling team, in relative terms. In relation to the brief, is this the best team you can roll out? is the question.
 

paraguayo

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 24, 2019
Messages
1,339
Supports
neutral
Rozay said:
—————————Kahn————————
—Petrescu—T.Silva—Koulibaily—Harte—
———————-——Ndidi——————————
——-——Nedved————De Rossi--——
—Messi———Shearer——Aubameyang—-—​
Click to expand...
Auba and Silva = Milan 2x
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,328
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
Southall
Amoros - Figueroa - Baresi - Krol
Beckenbauer - Souness
Zico
Messi - C. Ronaldo - Blokhin​
 

Scriblerus

Full Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
494
Location
Surrey (in exile)
Gio said:
The Kaiser and Pele both played for New York Cosmos.
Click to expand...
Damn…..missed that one. Well done……I was going to have Vieira for Tigana, until I realised that Vieira started at Cannes, which is where Krol ended up….. Obviously you would have to keep Pele. So I'll pull Tigana back to DM and slip Gunter Netzer into the midfield, I think.

………..Best……………Pele………..Eusebio……….

……………….Messi…………..Netzer………….

………………………..Tigana……………………….

Krol…….Maldini……..Godin………McGrain…...

………………………..Banks……………………………….
 

pacifictheme

Full Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2013
Messages
7,714
hmchan said:
This is rather easy. I'd only pick players who are currently playing to make it more difficult.

GK - Oblak (Slovenia/Benfica, Atletico)
RB - Pereira (Portugal/Porto, Leicester)
RCB - Marquinhos (Brazil/Corinthians, Roma, PSG)
LCB - Skriniar (Slovakia/Sampdoria, Inter)
LB - Hakimi (Morocco/Madrid, Dortmund)
CDM - Alaba (Austria/Bayern, Hoffenheim)
RCM - de Bruyne (Belgium/Genk, Chelsea, Bremen, Wolfsburg, City)
LCM - Pogba (France/Juventus, United)
RW - Messi (Argentina/Barcelona)
LW - Mane (Senegal/Salzburg, Southampton, Liverpool)
ST - Werner (Germany/Stuttgart, Leipzig)

One difficulty is that I find many players started their career at Genk, which makes me leave out the likes of Ndidi and Koulibaly. Nonetheless, I like de Bruyne so much that I pick him despite he has played for several big clubs. I also favor Hakimi so much that I have to drop a number of Madrid players such as Modric. Another difficulty is that many potential attackers have played for Dortmund, and there aren't many quality defenders besides van Dijk.
Click to expand...
Like the other poster said, it doesn't exactly wow does it?
 

NoPace

Full Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2014
Messages
9,398
Only considered players who peaked post 2001 because that's when I started watching closely enough to trust my opinions:

Starting with Messi and Cristiano because not only are they the best 2 players but they also fit beautifully with Messi's through balls from right to left being so good and Cristiano the best target possible.

Wanted a false 9 who is mobile to be the guy who works to help Messi and Cristiano, more like a Firmino or Benzema than a stable 9. Reus seemed like the best option and allowed me to take Alaba at LB since Bayern is still good. But ideally you'd want someone better in the penalty area against packed defences maybe? Not even a big target man, but even a poacher like Aubameyang. I could have taken him and found a different keeper but prime Cech was amazing and I'm not sure Aubameyang would do better as the 3rd man in this attack than a more versatile player like Reus.

Needed an overlapping right back to be the Alves for Messi and got Cafu.

Midfield was the hardest with all the Madrid, Barcelona and also guys like Schweinsteiger, Scholes, Nedved, De Bruyne and Lampard gone, but I like the balance of having a passer and a tough DM and then Silva linking play and getting the ball to the front 3. Almost considered the wildly underrated Bruno Soriano at DM because his 10 caps would have been 60 for Spain without Busquets but wanted Godin at CB and they're both Villareal.

Is my midfield too small? Probably.

Cristiano---Reus------Messi
--------------David Silva-------
--------Verratti----Kante--------
Alaba--VanDijk-Campbell--Cafu
----------------Oblak------------------
 
Last edited:

BlackShark_80

Full Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
1,169
NoPace said:
Only considered players who peaked post 2001 because that's when I started watching closely enough to trust my opinions:

Starting with Messi and Cristiano because not only are they the best 2 players but they also fit beautifully with Messi's through balls from right to left being so good and Cristiano the best target possible.

Wanted a false 9 who is mobile to be the guy who works to help Messi and Cristiano, more like a Firmino or Benzema than a stable 9. Reus seemed like the best option and allowed me to take Alaba at LB since Bayern is still good. But ideally you'd want someone better in the penalty area against packed defences maybe? Not even a big target man, but even a poacher like Aubameyang. I could have taken him and found a different keeper but prime Cech was amazing and I'm not sure Aubameyang would do better as the 3rd man in this attack than a more versatile player like Reus.

Needed an overlapping right back to be the Alves for Messi and got Cafu.

Midfield was the hardest with all the Madrid, Barcelona and also guys like Schweinsteiger, Scholes, Nedved, De Bruyne and Lampard gone, but I like the balance of having a passer and a tough DM and then Silva linking play and getting the ball to the front 3. Almost considered the wildly underrated Bruno Soriano at DM because his 10 caps would have been 60 for Spain without Busquets but wanted Godin at CB and they're both Villareal.

Cristiano---Reus------Messi
--------------David Silva-------
--------Verratti---DeRossi---------
Alaba--VanDijk-Godin--Cafu
----------------Cech------------------
Click to expand...
Verratti and De Rossi are from same country.
 

hmchan

Full Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
1,429
Location
Hong Kong
Fortitude said:
Quite strange to say that and then produce a middling team, in relative terms. In relation to the brief, is this the best team you can roll out? is the question.
Click to expand...
I said it's easy if we don't add restrictions to the rules. There's over a century of football we are talking about and there're plenty of candidates to discuss. Football has also evolved over the years and it's virtually impossible to compare players born in different eras playing in different systems. That's why I limit my choices down to current players only and I'm truly welcome if you name a better 11 than me.

Of course it's a middling team as compared to those real legends in football such as Pele mentioned above. But considering recent form and those limitations, I don't think my 11 is really that awful. Oblak, Alaba, de Bruyne, Pogba, Messi and Mane are one of the best players in their respective positions nowadays, if not the best anyway. Pereira and Hakimi aren't as well-known as Arnold and Robertson, but statistically they have been excellent. I admit the CB positions look vulnerable but as I've said, there aren't many quality defenders out there. You may argue I should include van Dijk and Ronaldo at all costs but I personally don't agree.
 

Halds

New Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2016
Messages
737
Location
Denmark
Supports
Liverpool FC
Bwuk said:
Oblak
Lahm - Nesta - Carvalho - Robertson
Fernandinho
Keane - Modric
Messi - Shearer - Mbappe​

Quite hard and probably missed some obvious choices.
Click to expand...
Carvalho and Modric played for Real Madrid.
 

Tel074

New Member
Joined
May 8, 2019
Messages
1,531
Oblak

Hansen Baresi. Lahm

Zidane Dunga Keane Bergkamp

Maradona Shearer Drogba
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,723
Location
Inside right
hmchan said:
I said it's easy if we don't add restrictions to the rules. There's over a century of football we are talking about and there're plenty of candidates to discuss. Football has also evolved over the years and it's virtually impossible to compare players born in different eras playing in different systems. That's why I limit my choices down to current players only and I'm truly welcome if you name a better 11 than me.

Of course it's a middling team as compared to those real legends in football such as Pele mentioned above. But considering recent form and those limitations, I don't think my 11 is really that awful. Oblak, Alaba, de Bruyne, Pogba, Messi and Mane are one of the best players in their respective positions nowadays, if not the best anyway. Pereira and Hakimi aren't as well-known as Arnold and Robertson, but statistically they have been excellent. I admit the CB positions look vulnerable but as I've said, there aren't many quality defenders out there. You may argue I should include van Dijk and Ronaldo at all costs but I personally don't agree.
Click to expand...
Only if you're a 100 years old!

The brief states 'in your lifetime,' so your birth year onwards.

Apart from Oblak, Messi and C.Ronaldo, I think the teams being listed are rather diverse. As it's also a partially subjective exercise (some are not universally agreed upon as gods of the game relative to others) it is producing a broad range of players.

If you want to challenge yourself, come up with more than one team with no overlap from one to the other. Further still, as another challenge, reduce an xi to half a decade segments (say, 2015-2020, for example), and the 'fun' really begins.
 

NoPace

Full Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2014
Messages
9,398
hmchan said:
This is rather easy. I'd only pick players who are currently playing to make it more difficult.

GK - Oblak (Slovenia/Benfica, Atletico)
RB - Pereira (Portugal/Porto, Leicester)
RCB - Marquinhos (Brazil/Corinthians, Roma, PSG)
LCB - Skriniar (Slovakia/Sampdoria, Inter)
LB - Hakimi (Morocco/Madrid, Dortmund)
CDM - Alaba (Austria/Bayern, Hoffenheim)
RCM - de Bruyne (Belgium/Genk, Chelsea, Bremen, Wolfsburg, City)
LCM - Pogba (France/Juventus, United)
RW - Messi (Argentina/Barcelona)
LW - Mane (Senegal/Salzburg, Southampton, Liverpool)
ST - Werner (Germany/Stuttgart, Leipzig)

One difficulty is that I find many players started their career at Genk, which makes me leave out the likes of Ndidi and Koulibaly. Nonetheless, I like de Bruyne so much that I pick him despite he has played for several big clubs. I also favor Hakimi so much that I have to drop a number of Madrid players such as Modric. Another difficulty is that many potential attackers have played for Dortmund, and there aren't many quality defenders besides van Dijk.
Click to expand...
Hakimi is not this good a left back in a 4 man setup, I think you gotta throw Alaba back at LB and find a DM with more experience running a midfield anyways since Pogba and De Bruyne aren't exactly Modric and Kroos in terms of responsiblity and defending and conducting play.
 

NoPace

Full Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2014
Messages
9,398
A friend's submission:

Cristiano Ronaldo-----Drogba---------Messi----
----Nainggolan---Gilberto Silva---David Silva-
Maldini-------------King--------VanDijk--------Lahm
--------------------------------Oblak--------------------------
 

VP

Full Member
Joined
May 19, 2006
Messages
11,556
This was interesting:

------------K. Schmeichel------------
Lahm----Godin----De Ligt-----Maldini
------KDB-------Keane------Modric-----
Messi-------Shearer---------Mane

I think that's quite nicely balanced without any glaring weaknesses (unless of course I've missed some overlap)

Edit: just realised both Shearer and Mane played for Southampton, ffs
 
Last edited:

Tony Banta

Last Man Standing champion 2023/24
Joined
Sep 2, 2017
Messages
269
VP said:
This was interesting:

------------K. Schmeichel------------
Lahm----Godin----De Ligt-----Maldini
------KDB-------Keane------Modric-----
Messi-------Shearer---------Mane

I think that's quite nicely balanced without any glaring weaknesses (unless of course I've missed some overlap)
Click to expand...
You have an overlap...
 

Gentleman Jim

It's absolutely amazing! Perfect even.
Joined
Jun 14, 2015
Messages
3,152
Location
Salford
Supports
city
VP said:
This was interesting:

------------K. Schmeichel------------
Lahm----Godin----De Ligt-----Maldini
------KDB-------Keane------Modric-----
Messi-------Shearer---------Mane

I think that's quite nicely balanced without any glaring weaknesses (unless of course I've missed some overlap)

Edit: just realised both Shearer and Mane played for Southampton, ffs
Click to expand...
Kasper and KDB too.
 

Redcy

Full Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2014
Messages
2,614
—————————Southall————————
——Maldini—Godín—koulibaly—Suurbier
—————————Keane——————————
————Zidane—————Zico——
—Messi———Shearer——B Laudrup
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,328
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
Redcy said:
—————————Southall————————
——Maldini—Godín—koulibaly—Suurbier
—————————Keane——————————
————Zidane—————Zico——
—Messi———Shearer——B Laudrup
Click to expand...
Maldini and God both played at Milan together. He also played at Suurbier's Ajax.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.