We’ve got the yips in front of goal and have had them for some time. Amad is one of the few we have that has a bit about him, must play.
16
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 20
- Goals
- 2
- Assists
- 2
- Yellow cards
- 1
Good job we don't have a left footer at full back then I suppose. Quibbling about nothing here. Being shit isn't because of which foot our RWB prefers.
You’re just being obtuse now. And I never said that was the reason we were shit. Good job arguing a point that is a figment of your imagination. You’re good at the internet.
He hasn’t been good this season to be honest. However, I think he is a talented player and I hope his form improves.
We’ve got the yips in front of goal and have had them for some time. Amad is one of the few we have that has a bit about him, must play.
He's certainly not a 'must play'. He's shown less than garnacho to date.
A level above Garnacho, Amad atleast has something about him. However he’s not hitting the level what was expected from him when signed.
Still a good player but we need the end product.
What happened to him this season? Seems a shadow of himself compared to last season.
Could Amorim not deploy Amad in Dorgu's position?
Yes but
1) He's used to playing on the right. Possibly one of Dorgu's issues going forward as hes used to playing right wing in attacking areas too
2) Then we are weaker at right wingback because Amad is our best pick there
So yes but I'm not sure what it achieves
Yeah, I don't think Amad is used to playing on the right but I'd be much more confident that he could provide better crossing and decision making in that final third. I'd be willing to have Mazraoui at rwb.
Something about him? I struggle to see what amad has shown that gives any higher hopes. I'm glad Garnacho went in the end btw, just wish we'd got more for him and wouldn't have to watch his smug face at the bridge
Seems similar to having Dorgu on the left
Comments like this make sense when it's Bruno, but Amad has given us a handful of good games and that's it.
Maybe he has reverted to his norm now, and the good games are just an exception.
We won't know until he gets some consistency in his game.
He's not a scapegoat, he's just not playing well.
I agree Amad deserves criticism, but he had many good games last season, and was our best player when not injured.
Is it a 1 season wonder? Who knows.
He counts as pure profit (or will from this summer?) and when this manager inevitably gets sacked we only have space for Mbeumo on the right. I wouldn’t put it past INEOS to get rid of him
I think there's a good chance whoever the next manager is brings him infield. The closest comparison in terms of style to me is Bernardo Silva.
You guys don't half-step when it comes to creating villains. fecking hell
Ah I see people are writing off another young player, questioning what talent they have because the worst manager we've ever had uses a system that doesn't use winger and uses a 2 in midfield. Questioning attitude because the winger isn't a good wing back, regardless of the fact he gets his head down and works his ass off in it (but is just a bit shit at it).
Playing him at CAM in a 4-2-3-1 could work, but the club and the next manager would need the stones to move on from Bruno.
Or they could play him in what is now his best position, deeper.
Play him RWB against Chelsea.
The villian creaters were proven right from time to time??
People like you would crucify whoever questioned Rashford's attitude in 2022 or Garnacho's attitude 1 year ago
people like you contribute to the miserable state we are at right now
Making up more nonsense after being told you’re making up nonsense is a choice that you don’t have to make
you can only resort to this gibberish when you fail to formulate meaningful arguments
There's nothing wrong with his attitude, he's just not playing very well at the moment. Even when he's not playing well, he created that big chance the Mbuemo fluffed. It's early in the season, I have faith over the course of the season he'll be impactful, but we all need a win right now.
yes, because your posts are meaningful, bountiful in substance, well formulated arguments. It’s not like the premise is literally “feels and vibes”. This is the opening to your post - verbatim:
“Anyone feel there is a huge sharp drop in his attitude, it is just like Rashford 2 years ago?”
‘kin hell
Don’t tell me what to feel!
Now that Rasmus and Garna are gone, Amad and Kobbie are next in the young player chopping block
Amad felt really off in the Grimsby game but otherwise he's been putting in a shift. Not gelling well with Mbeumo yet.
Amad felt really off in the Grimsby game but otherwise he's been putting in a shift. Not gelling well with Mbeumo yet.
So what's brought you to that conclusion? Maybe the club refusing to allow Mainoo to leave on a loan? Not seen a shred of evidence to support your post, so where you getting this from?
As it was extremely easy to see who the club wanted out in the summer (bomb squad).
Not from the club's perspective, but the fans'. I'm being half facetious seeing negativity against Amad already in this thread. Poor Mainoo's not even getting a chance to play, and I just hope if he does the fans don't get an excuse to make him a scapegoat too.
I think he’s given more leeway than some other of our younger players for some reason. His decision making has become more selfish I think this season and he needs to get back to being a team player.
I think that’s the last thing they’ll do. The next manager will almost certainly drop this wing back bullshit and then we’ll need more wingers.
Its ridiculous and all stems from a desire to protect and absolve the managers of any accountability or blame for performances.
Seen the swift turn on Bruno, Garnacho, Mainoo and now Amad.
Yep- he’s up there with the very best players Utd have, in terms of touch and technique. He’s absolutely the last person Utd should should be questioning.
Despite his wrong decisions, poor passing choices, constant giving the ball away, poor recovery runs and lackluster challenges,
I reckon as a player that supposedly is the best United have we should definitely be questioning him as to why he isn't matching these lofty targets.....
Yeah I think we’re seeing different things in him. His choices need to be better, but his ability is first class.
The issue will then be hes not proven himself as a winger. He played well last season as a wingback and okay as an AM. Hes our one player who has done better in this formation
He hasn't been as good this season as he was last season but he still looks like he can do something if he has the ball in advanced areas. Its too much to expect him to run past 4-5 players from deep every time he has the ball.
He is a victim of this formation too. I think playing as WB at times and then as an inside forward the other times has him confused. Also, being in and out of the team (sometimes due to injuries and other times due to the formation) isn't allowing him to fully develop into the product he can. He needs to consistent playing time in a set position.
Love to see him play the Odegaard role in a 4231/433 whenever Amo leaves.
Love to see him play the Odegaard role in a 4231/433 whenever Amo leaves.