Anthony Elanga | Newcastle

20 games for Newcastle this season. Zero goals. One assist.

Can we stop beating ourselves up about selling him now? Please?
Aye, it was always odd how some moaned about selling Elanga and wanting him back. He was never good enough (long term anyway). I guess the crux of it was that we just ended up spending massive amounts of money on even worse players (Antony, Sancho) - attitude wise and physical traits wise, I’d have rather we kept Elanga over those two in fairness. But that says more about them than it does Elanga.

It was clear that he had the perfect conditions at Forest last season. A fast, physical, direct side who thrived on the counter when he had ample space to run into. Once the space is mitigated, he becomes a fairly average footballer. All that being said, he’d have made a decent wing back for Amorim, wouldn’t he? :lol:
 
20 games for Newcastle this season. Zero goals. One assist.

Can we stop beating ourselves up about selling him now? Please?
The narrative last season was so weird. He was doing well at a smaller club that was overachieving somewhat and suddenly it was another instance of United “wasting a talent” and should never have been sold etc.
 
20 games for Newcastle this season. Zero goals. One assist.

Can we stop beating ourselves up about selling him now? Please?
Considering the add ons didn't we get close to 25m for him in the end?

He deserves credit for doing fairly well but it's incredible business for a really limited footballer who would never have done anything of note here.
 
Form has fallen down a cliff. Just hasn't worked out for him at Newcastle
 
Hasnt found his feet at Newcastle. He's basically a 2025 version of Victor Moses, which could have worked wonders at wingback in our current system.
 
I think people like to beat themselves up about the transfer fees that players end up commanding, as if we could've gotten £55m from Newcastle if we'd only held on to him for another 18 months in our team and setup and he would've showed exactly the same thing that he did at Forest.
 
Guess playing for Nuno's Forest fit him better. You forget about him this season, he's been invisible mostly.
 
Elanga has unbelievable pace and will always perform best in a lower side that sit back and try to hit teams with quick counter attacks. As we saw when he played for a team that dominate possession he struggles technically and doesn’t really have a trick to beat a man. He should really have stayed at Forest
 
Elanga has unbelievable pace and will always perform best in a lower side that sit back and try to hit teams with quick counter attacks. As we saw when he played for a team that dominate possession he struggles technically and doesn’t really have a trick to beat a man. He should really have stayed at Forest
Bah hambug! We wanted our sell on money:D
 
20 games for Newcastle this season. Zero goals. One assist.

Can we stop beating ourselves up about selling him now? Please?
Really poor start to his Newcastle career.

More goal contributions in the league than Wirtz.

Nuno’s counter transitional team suited Elanga to a tee. He would’ve been good as an attacking LWB in Amorim’s flawed system. Much rather have seen him there than Dorgu.
 
He scored as many league goals last season as Garnacho iirc.
Even his performances for Forest were very overrated.
He hit a purple patch for a counter side who had a freak season. He’d be shite if he was still at Forest now: an absolute nothing player who we were 100% correct to sell.
 
Forest played the perfect style for his attributes. He'd do well again at a low block, counter attacking team.
That's exactly it - he isn't a terrible player, he's just terribly limited and if you're not playing to his strengths (with lots of space in front of him to run into), he's ineffective.
 
I think people like to beat themselves up about the transfer fees that players end up commanding, as if we could've gotten £55m from Newcastle if we'd only held on to him for another 18 months in our team and setup and he would've showed exactly the same thing that he did at Forest.
and we'd of had to play him, no thank you
 
Hasnt found his feet at Newcastle. He's basically a 2025 version of Victor Moses, which could have worked wonders at wingback in our current system.
wouldnt of worked wonders because our wingbacks get a lot of the ball and are expected to produce...this is his problem