- Jan 1, 2014
Definitely not a flop, he had a good spell here. He underwhelmed in his first year but he did score important goals against Boro at home and Bolton away that year, it’s just that stupid penalty he tried in the fa cup.I feel the same. I find the praise he gets nowadays for his United career to be quite OTT. Not a flop by any means but struggled a fair amount in his debut season, wasn't great in his second season either, much better 3rd season but replaced by Hernandez towards the end of that campaign and I don't really remember that much about him from then on. Again, a very good player but to be honest he wasn't a fantastic signing.