- Joined
- Sep 8, 2025
- Messages
- 184
He does good donkey work. I hope he retains that part of it whilst he plays himself back into form.
Not sure about that even at the moment, genuinely a waste of space in this current form.
If that. Awful performance bailed out by others being even worse.You think he was a 3/10?
He's probably more of a wide forward than a winger. A bit similar to Memphis Depay in a way.Forget this performance and current form, how do people see best version of him at the position he plays for United?
He's not a winger at all. You know he's going to cut inside but even then he does it in slow motion. Maybe he's double guessing himself and if our play is a bit quicker he'll be effective, but I don't see it. He was good in Amorim system when he was the guy getting the chances and had composure and skills to finish them off. Not the case anymore.
Been saying it for a while I think he's just competition for Sesko while being solid depth for the front 3 in general. He's out of form obviously but his level is good enough for a depth role, I don't see him as a key player even at his best form for any of the front 3 positions though. Still, you need versatile depth who is capable of playing to a high level so it's not the worst case.Forget this performance and current form, how do people see best version of him at the position he plays for United?
He's not a winger at all. You know he's going to cut inside but even then he does it in slow motion. Maybe he's double guessing himself and if our play is a bit quicker he'll be effective, but I don't see it. He was good in Amorim system when he was the guy getting the chances and had composure and skills to finish them off. Not the case anymore.
Depay still is a dangerous player, cut inside and shoot type of wingers are fine, but Mbuemo doesn't pose any threat. He cuts inside and passes back, slows the game down.He's probably more of a wide forward than a winger. A bit similar to Memphis Depay in a way.
They start from wide but are best in central positions close around the goal. They were never meant to beat full backs and get to the byline.
He's perfectly fine in a slightly loopsided 4-2-3-1 as a right-sided wide forward. When he's in form that is.Forget this performance and current form, how do people see best version of him at the position he plays for United?
He's not a winger at all. You know he's going to cut inside but even then he does it in slow motion. Maybe he's double guessing himself and if our play is a bit quicker he'll be effective, but I don't see it. He was good in Amorim system when he was the guy getting the chances and had composure and skills to finish them off. Not the case anymore.
At least Amad still has time on his side. Mbeumo hasn’t even looked fit to me this season.He’s lucky Amad is diverting stick away from him. He’s been shocking.
He looks like he has a belly. Plus he can't even trap a ball.He’s lost a yard of pace since AFCON and he still looks like he’s carrying too much timber.
He has always been a bit chunky but he looks heavy now.He looks like he has a belly. Plus he can't even trap a ball.
Agree he just looks heavyHe has always been a bit chunky but he looks heavy now.
Not mobile/nimble and not quick.
Maybe lay off the weights a bit?
The problem is at the moment he can't even take advantage of situations that are tailor made for him. Him going through clean on goal when put in behind tonight being a perfect example.He looks to me like a player better suited to a mid to lower table team who get way more space in behind than we do.
To be fair, if ever you need a pass into your stride it was there. Form could have turned on that moment.Slight concern is turning into full blown worry now. He looks awful and completely ineffective. The best thing he did all game was the decoy run for the goal.
Yes, I like this about him....Not great today but we know he has all the qualities needed, he's just woefully out of form at the mo. He never stops running though - gives his all.
Hey, he aint heavy, he's Mbeumo.Agree he just looks heavy
Sounds like a tasty strikerAFCON always fecks players up. It happened even to AFCON goats lime Drogba
He’s a lot worse as an actual footballer than I had imagined. Has his uses, but play has to be streamlined and specific for him to prosper. Left to his own devices, and having to beat men whilst being dynamic and clever and he doesn’t look a United winger.
If we ever get back to being Manchester United again, he’ll be benched and eventually moved on. Proper bridge player.
I meant to quote you two a while ago. I'm actually surprised you thought his first touch had "disintegrated", Welbz, as you're usually good at judging technical quality.The first touch has disintegrated. I think you can carry a player being weak at the basics of general play if they’re a killer with the fundamentals (first touch, final ball, shooting technique). For a very short while, it looked like Mbeumo had that. Our own mini-Salah with far less quality.
The bottom level of his performances kind of make it so that he has to be getting 25+ G/A a season at a minimum for the juice to be worth the squeeze.
I still don't get where this idea that he's a tidy player comes from. He's been sloppy since he arrived.
I actually looked at his stats from last season and, out of the whole premier league, he was 3rd in inaccurate short passes with 257. Only Bruno and Salah were above him. He was also 3rd in unsuccessful touches with Salah and Villa's Morgan Rogers above him.
Even on the opening day against Arsenal. Everyone loved that performance but I just had a look and only Dorgu gave the ball away more than him when you combine "unsuccessful touches" and "dispossessed". That's including the Arsenal players who struggled to string passes together that game.