Centre Back... Who do we go for?

SadlerMUFC

Thinks for himself
Joined
Dec 7, 2017
Messages
5,746
Location
Niagara Falls, Canada
You need some help with learning to understand English then if calling someone a fast Lindelof is the same as calling him as fast as Lindelof.
Nope...just need help with my eyes. I was reading that as "calling someone AS fast as Lindelof" is that same as calling him as fast as Lindelof." :lol: :lol: :lol:
 

The Red Thinker

Full Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
4,149
Location
Knowhere
You haven't watched him play if you think he's just as fast as Lindelof. I picked Ake because his attributes compliment Maguire. The main one being his speed. And he doesn't need to be great at headers (not sure if he is or isn't to be fair) because Maguire is. It's about complimenting each other. Rio and Vidic were great because their attributes were different. Vidic and Terry are probably two of the greatest defeders ever to play in the EPL but they probably wouldn't make good defensive partners because their attributes were too similar and didn't compliment each other...
I submit that you think Lindelof is too slow. I don't believe that as I feel Lindelof is pretty quick in my book, but not as powerful as Ake. That being said, I did say that Ake is a "fast Lindelof". Meaning he is quicker than Lindelof.

Now the main point. Heading. You mentioned Rio and Vidic as a pairing. Yes, both had different attributes. Rio the passing Rolls Royce and Vida the destructive tank alongside him. Rio was quick as hell and Vida was slower. BUT, both were brilliant headers of the ball. Both were well over 6ft tall.

This is my point. Ake is only as good as Lindelof in the heading department. Every other department he may have an edge as you say, but that is not enough of an upgrade to work with Maguire.

You need speed, aerial prowess and ball playing ability. This way, Maguire doesn't have to worry about ALWAYS having to win EVERY header coming into the box. He can delegate to his partner for headers and concentrate on positioning and leading the defence.

One statistic above all is key for defenders who are aerially dominant - "Aerial Duels" or "Aerial Battles". Per Premier League stats, Ake is better at most defensive duties on the ground. Better interception, better tackling, better clearances. He even has more aerial clearances (But this is because Ake doesn't have a Maguire next to him). But when it comes to Aerial Duels Lindelof is FAR better. This is a more individual stat and so works as a comparison.

Nathan AkeVictor Lindelof
Matches2730
Aerial Battles Won6082

Source: www.premierleague.com

This statistic is worrying to me, and automatically disqualifies him as a potential long term partner to Maguire.
 
Last edited:

SadlerMUFC

Thinks for himself
Joined
Dec 7, 2017
Messages
5,746
Location
Niagara Falls, Canada
I submit that you think Lindelof is too slow. I don't believe that as I feel Lindelof is pretty quick in my book, but not as powerful as Ake. That being said, I did say that Ake is a "fast Lindelof". Meaning he is quicker than Lindelof.

Now the main point. Heading. You mentioned Rio and Vidic as a pairing. Yes, both had different attributes. Rio the passing Rolls Royce and Vida the destructive tank alongside him. Rio was quick as hell and Vida was slower. BUT, both were brilliant headers of the ball. Both were well over 6ft tall.

This is my point. Ake is only as good as Lindelof in the heading department. Every other department he may have an edge as you say, but that is not enough of an upgrade to work with Maguire.

You need speed, aerial prowess and ball playing ability. This way, Maguire doesn't have to worry about ALWAYS having to win EVERY header coming into the box. He can delegate to his partner for headers and concentrate on positioning and leading the defence.

One statistic above all is key for defenders who are aerially dominant - "Aerial Duels" or "Aerial Battles". Per Premier League stats, Ake is better at most defensive duties on the ground. Better interception, better tackling, better clearances. He even has more aerial clearances (But this is because Ake doesn't have a Maguire next to him). But when it comes to Aerial Duels Lindelof is FAR better. This is a more individual stat and so works as a comparison.

Nathan AkeVictor Lindelof
Matches2730
Aerial Battles Won6082

Source: www.premierleague.com

This statistic is worrying to me, and automatically disqualifies him as a potential long term partner to Maguire.
Yet Ake is 8th in the league in headed clearances...(and yes, I misread you "a fast Lindeloff" quote and read "as fast as Lindeloff". My bad)

https://www.premierleague.com/stats/top/players/head_clearance
 

Isotope

Ten Years a Cafite
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
23,554
Someone needs to send this strategy to United management.

1. United put a serious bid for Soyuncu.
2. See who Leicester scouting for his replacement.
3. United go and buy that player instead.
4. Profit.
 

The Red Thinker

Full Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
4,149
Location
Knowhere
Yet Ake is 8th in the league in headed clearances...(and yes, I misread you "a fast Lindeloff" quote and read "as fast as Lindeloff". My bad)

https://www.premierleague.com/stats/top/players/head_clearance
And van Dijk is 9th. What does that infer? As I said, Headed clearances is not a good enough metric. Let's look at last season, when VVD was a Balon D'Or contender.

2018/19 SEASON
Nathan AkeVirgil van Dijk
PL Appearances3838
Aerial Battles Won88181
Headed Clearances127112

Does this mean Ake was better in the air than Van Dijk last year? Not at all. It just means that Bournemouth faced more aerial balls than Liverpool. Hence more headed clearances.

This is why Headed Clearances is not a good enough stat and that Aerial duels is far better in understanding the aerial prowess of a defender. One can be influenced by team stats, the other cannot.
 
Last edited:

Fracture90

Full Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2016
Messages
10,360
Location
Serbia
In the light of our upcoming clash with the 'claret and blue', how's our friendly, neighborhood head stomper Mings doing?
 

BenitoSTARR

One Minute Man
Scout
Joined
Sep 1, 2015
Messages
12,525
Surely for aerial battles won to be fairly compared you need to know the total number of aerial battles.

The % won is a much better metric if you’re comparing two players for the same spot.
 

Ali Dia

Full Member
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
14,137
Location
Souness's Super Sub/George Weahs Talented Cousin
Upemecano. The fact we were in for him in the past surely means the club still like him and he’s obviously improved since then. He’s not a huge price and he could easily become a starting CB for France. Bet city or Chelsea go for him this summer.
 

Tel074

New Member
Joined
May 8, 2019
Messages
1,531
I choose Declan Rice because he can play three diffrent def, mid def and mid

I can play 3 positions as well doesn't mean I'm right for United . Rice is a decent midfielder and never good enough for what we need at CB
 

Houdini

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 20, 2017
Messages
2,163
Jérôme Boateng will be out of his contract. He is 31. Good option for free. Better than what we have esp. as second choice.
 

Baneofthegame

Full Member
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
2,995
And van Dijk is 9th. What does that infer? As I said, Headed clearances is not a good enough metric. Let's look at last season, when VVD was a Balon D'Or contender.

2018/19 SEASON
Nathan AkeVirgil van Dijk
PL Appearances3838
Aerial Battles Won88181
Headed Clearances127112

Does this mean Ake was better in the air than Van Dijk last year? Not at all. It just means that Bournemouth faced more aerial balls than Liverpool. Hence more headed clearances.

This is why Headed Clearances is not a good enough stat and that Aerial duels is far better in understanding the aerial prowess of a defender. One can be influenced by team stats, the other cannot.
Surely style of play and what team are in effect these stats.

Not that I feel Ake is as good as VVD
 

jderbyshire

Has anybody seen my fleshlight?
Joined
May 2, 2007
Messages
4,175
Someone needs to send this strategy to United management.

1. United put a serious bid for Soyuncu.
2. See who Leicester scouting for his replacement.
3. United go and buy that player instead.
4. Profit.
Haha can't argue with this.
 

E-mal

Full Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2017
Messages
3,022
Upemecano. The fact we were in for him in the past surely means the club still like him and he’s obviously improved since then. He’s not a huge price and he could easily become a starting CB for France. Bet city or Chelsea go for him this summer.
I just hope we go for him. He fits the bill perfectly. Press resistant and has pace.
Then next season we go for Rice or Saul if they have improved.
 

Craig Ward

Full Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2016
Messages
2,117
Someone needs to send this strategy to United management.

1. United put a serious bid for Soyuncu.
2. See who Leicester scouting for his replacement.
3. United go and buy that player instead.
4. Profit.
Genius. Simple yet genius
 

Craig Ward

Full Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2016
Messages
2,117
Upemecano. The fact we were in for him in the past surely means the club still like him and he’s obviously improved since then. He’s not a huge price and he could easily become a starting CB for France. Bet city or Chelsea go for him this summer.
He's the best option for me.

Cheaper than Koulibaby, and arguably better. Certainly has more potential.

Rice is a bit over rated and plays all his games in midfield, where he manages at best to look half decent. He's not a realistic CB option.

Ake is interesting, i dont think he's streets ahead of Lindelof so struggling to see the value.

Boateng/Silva - both have had they're best years and wouldnt improve us long term or fit the transfer strategy we now have.

Mings - Simply not good enough and never will be

Salisu - another interesting one. He;s young and looks raw. If we signed him, he's basically in the same bracket as Tuanzebe.

For me, CB isn't really that pressing. If we sign one, then i'd like to think we signed a definite starter to replace Lindelof. So the criteria has to be specific, a lot of the names we are linked with can almost instantly be dismissed:
Koulibaby, Silva, Boateng, Mings, Rice (If we were interested it would be for Midfield not CB)

Ake would be a maybe and i guess so is Salisu.

Whether we doing anything here depends on whether we sell 3 CB's in one window - Jones/Smalling/Rojo. If we dont sell all three, with limited funds i'd look at investing in a different position.

Tuanzebe's injury has been a real shame this year, hoping his luck changes
 

Schmeichel's Cartwheel

Correctly predicted Italy to win Euro 2020
Joined
Dec 21, 2014
Messages
11,420
Location
Manchester
Ole - "we've got 7 centre backs we're fine"

Maguire - Yes
Lindelof - Yes
Bailly - never fit
Tuanzebe - never fit
Jones - never fit
Smalling - away on loan
Rojo - away on loan

So yes, technically we have 7 first team centre backs, but when you look at it we really aren't as "stacked" as we sound. We have 2 reliable centre backs and we do need more cover in my opinion.
 

RDCR07

Not a bad guy (Whale Killer)
Joined
Aug 14, 2009
Messages
30,410
Location
Transfer Forum
Jérôme Boateng will be out of his contract. He is 31. Good option for free. Better than what we have esp. as second choice.
He is slower than my grandmother. Don’t need. We already have enough problems with pace at the back.
 

Craig Ward

Full Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2016
Messages
2,117
Ole - "we've got 7 centre backs we're fine"

Maguire - Yes
Lindelof - Yes
Bailly - never fit
Tuanzebe - never fit
Jones - never fit
Smalling - away on loan
Rojo - away on loan

So yes, technically we have 7 first team centre backs, but when you look at it we really aren't as "stacked" as we sound. We have 2 reliable centre backs and we do need more cover in my opinion.
If the 2 on loan arent sold permanently and we dont sell 1 of the others, we cant really sign a new one.

Money will be tight and we have other areas of the squad.

CB isnt that pressing unless we have 3 sold permanently.
 

Craig Ward

Full Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2016
Messages
2,117
What about Matic and Maguire combo?
Matic the central midfield player?
Matic the only natural DM we have?
Matic who isnt a CB and has never played there before?

Lets keep midfielders in midfield and defenders in defence for a start is it

Matic has been performing so well, allowing Pogba and Fernandes to get forward and create. Lets not change the balance for no reason with silly suggestions
 

ShinjiNinja26

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2013
Messages
11,027
Location
Location, Location
If the 2 on loan arent sold permanently and we dont sell 1 of the others, we cant really sign a new one.

Money will be tight and we have other areas of the squad.

CB isnt that pressing unless we have 3 sold permanently.
I think Smalling and Rojo are definitely gone this summer. Ideally Phil Jones will get sold also but finding a buyer will be more difficult, hopefully the rumours of Moyeseh helping us out are true but based on West Ham avoiding relegation. That leaves us with 4 CB’s, promote Mengi and sign someone else and we’re sorted.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,337
I think Smalling and Rojo are definitely gone this summer. Ideally Phil Jones will get sold also but finding a buyer will be more difficult, hopefully the rumours of Moyeseh helping us out are true but based on West Ham avoiding relegation. That leaves us with 4 CB’s, promote Mengi and sign someone else and we’re sorted.
Yeah I am not worried at all by what Ole said about the CB situation,he is hardly going to say we need to sign one when we still have games to play.
 

Hanky panky

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Feb 21, 2016
Messages
740
I still can't imagine a toptop team with Lindelöf as their starting CB. He would never be a regular starter in Real, Barca, Juve or Bayern. Codename "Jaap Stam" needed.
 

Eire Red United

New Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2016
Messages
2,723
Location
Ireland
I don’t necessarily disagree but I’d say 2 things.

If the defence is solid it allows the front men even more freedom to attack

smalling is gone, rojo is gone, Jones and tuanzabe are injury prone. It leaves us fecked for cover
Will never get why we loaned Smalling and kept Jones on a big contract. An injury or suspension to Maguire and we’re in trouble for the run in.
 

syrian_scholes

Honorary Straw Hat
Joined
Jan 10, 2011
Messages
13,979
Location
Houston
Ole - "we've got 7 centre backs we're fine"

Maguire - Yes
Lindelof - Yes
Bailly - never fit
Tuanzebe - never fit
Jones - never fit
Smalling - away on loan
Rojo - away on loan

So yes, technically we have 7 first team centre backs, but when you look at it we really aren't as "stacked" as we sound. We have 2 reliable centre backs and we do need more cover in my opinion.
It's just a nothing answer from Ole, no need to destabilize the team atm.
 

A-man

Full Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2017
Messages
6,314
I still can't imagine a toptop team with Lindelöf as their starting CB. He would never be a regular starter in Real, Barca, Juve or Bayern. Codename "Jaap Stam" needed.
If we talk United players, I could only imagine Pogba or Bruno to start any of those teams.
 

Infra-red

Full Member
Joined
May 4, 2010
Messages
13,387
Location
left wing
This is why Headed Clearances is not a good enough stat and that Aerial duels is far better in understanding the aerial prowess of a defender. One can be influenced by team stats, the other cannot.
Surely for aerial battles won to be fairly compared you need to know the total number of aerial battles.

The % won is a much better metric if you’re comparing two players for the same spot.
Here's a selection, mix of prominent CBs and some we've been linked with. The ones in bold are left footed.

% Aerial Duels Won
Ibrahima Konaté79%
Dan-Axel Zagadou77%
Jordan Torunarigha76%
Virgil van Dijk75%
Harry Maguire74%
Chris Smalling70%
Ozan Kabak67%
Jonathan Tah66%
Dayot Upamecano66%
Alessandro Bastoni65%
Matthijs de Ligt65%
Benoit Badiashile64%
Gabriel Magalhaes62%
Alessio Romagnoli60%
Mohammed Salisu60%
Kalidou Koulibaly59%
Eric Bailly55%
Nathan Aké51%
 
Last edited:

BenitoSTARR

One Minute Man
Scout
Joined
Sep 1, 2015
Messages
12,525
Here's a selection, mix of prominent CBs and some we've been linked with. The ones in bold are left footed.

% Aerial Duels Won
Ibrahima Konaté79%
Dan-Axel Zagadou77%
Jordan Torunarigha76%
Virgil van Dijk75%
Harry Maguire74%
Chris Smalling70%
Ozan Kabak67%
Jonathan Tah66%
Dayot Upamecano66%
Alessandro Bastoni65%
Matthijs de Ligt65%
Benoit Badiashile64%
Gabriel Magalhaes62%
Alessio Romagnoli60%
Mohammed Salisu60%
Kalidou Koulibaly59%
Eric Bailly55%
Nathan Aké51%
Great work!
 

Canuckred64

Full Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2007
Messages
3,629
Location
Canada
Jordan Torunarigha's dream is to play for United one day. He's big, strong, left footed and good in the air. Could be a cheaper option if we could convince Hertha Berlin to sell.
 

Adnan

Talent Spotter
Joined
Oct 5, 2013
Messages
29,865
Location
England
Here's a selection, mix of prominent CBs and some we've been linked with. The ones in bold are left footed.

% Aerial Duels Won
Ibrahima Konaté79%
Dan-Axel Zagadou77%
Jordan Torunarigha76%
Virgil van Dijk75%
Harry Maguire74%
Chris Smalling70%
Ozan Kabak67%
Jonathan Tah66%
Dayot Upamecano66%
Alessandro Bastoni65%
Matthijs de Ligt65%
Benoit Badiashile64%
Gabriel Magalhaes62%
Alessio Romagnoli60%
Mohammed Salisu60%
Kalidou Koulibaly59%
Eric Bailly55%
Nathan Aké51%
Interesting and i'm not surprised Konate is top.
 

andersj

Nick Powell Expert
Joined
Aug 7, 2004
Messages
4,275
Location
Copenhagen
Here's a selection, mix of prominent CBs and some we've been linked with. The ones in bold are left footed.

% Aerial Duels Won
Ibrahima Konaté79%
Dan-Axel Zagadou77%
Jordan Torunarigha76%
Virgil van Dijk75%
Harry Maguire74%
Chris Smalling70%
Ozan Kabak67%
Jonathan Tah66%
Dayot Upamecano66%
Alessandro Bastoni65%
Matthijs de Ligt65%
Benoit Badiashile64%
Gabriel Magalhaes62%
Alessio Romagnoli60%
Mohammed Salisu60%
Kalidou Koulibaly59%
Eric Bailly55%
Nathan Aké51%
Nice! I like Lisandro Martinez too. He can play left back, left CB and DM.