Club ownership | Senior management team talk

Just heard about Neville's dinner idea with Maguire and Fernandes.

They should get Declan Rice there too. Then they'd have Fernandes, Maguire and Rice for dinner.
 
Here's an idea that Ratcliffe can have for free if he's struggling.

If we don't win the Europa (and therefore don't qualify for Europe next season) we should start a new competition. Invite 15 other teams that have also not qualified for Europe (including maybe AC Milan).

Every team plays 4 home and 4 away (similar to current Champions and Europa League) and then quarter final, semi final and final.

Play the final in the states at the end of the season.

Make up some of the lost revenue from missed opportunity and then make a shit load from the final if we don't feck up.

Easy.
 
Is anyone else fed up with the pile on on the squad? From Ratcliffe, Amorim and all our ex players. What's the help in continually saying the players aren't good enough. We get it. Rashford aside, hard to accuse anyone of lacking effort, just ability. And then we seem to wonder why players who looked half useful like Höjlund suddenly have zero confidence, or why we start games so timidly.
 
Is anyone else fed up with the pile on on the squad? From Ratcliffe, Amorim and all our ex players. What's the help in continually saying the players aren't good enough. We get it. Rashford aside, hard to accuse anyone of lacking effort, just ability. And then we seem to wonder why players who looked half useful like Höjlund suddenly have zero confidence, or why we start games so timidly.
It's easy for these people to pile on the players and sic the fans on them as well as it deflects from their own shortcomings. Why would they stop?
 
Here's an idea that Ratcliffe can have for free if he's struggling.

If we don't win the Europa (and therefore don't qualify for Europe next season) we should start a new competition. Invite 15 other teams that have also not qualified for Europe (including maybe AC Milan).

Every team plays 4 home and 4 away (similar to current Champions and Europa League) and then quarter final, semi final and final.

Play the final in the states at the end of the season.

Make up some of the lost revenue from missed opportunity and then make a shit load from the final if we don't feck up.

Easy.
Whats the prize and where's it coming from? Who's going to sponsor this competition for losers.
 
Here's an idea that Ratcliffe can have for free if he's struggling.

If we don't win the Europa (and therefore don't qualify for Europe next season) we should start a new competition. Invite 15 other teams that have also not qualified for Europe (including maybe AC Milan).

Every team plays 4 home and 4 away (similar to current Champions and Europa League) and then quarter final, semi final and final.

Play the final in the states at the end of the season.

Make up some of the lost revenue from missed opportunity and then make a shit load from the final if we don't feck up.

Easy.
So the European Losers League?
 
Here's an idea that Ratcliffe can have for free if he's struggling.

If we don't win the Europa (and therefore don't qualify for Europe next season) we should start a new competition. Invite 15 other teams that have also not qualified for Europe (including maybe AC Milan).

Every team plays 4 home and 4 away (similar to current Champions and Europa League) and then quarter final, semi final and final.

Play the final in the states at the end of the season.

Make up some of the lost revenue from missed opportunity and then make a shit load from the final if we don't feck up.

Easy.
Maybe Jimbo can charge £66 a ticket, because we all know how important an unrecognised competition is to the fans.

Especially when the final is thousands of miles away.
 
Ratcliffe's recent media comments get taken apart. A lot of criticism of ratcliffe in this.

 
Is anyone else fed up with the pile on on the squad? From Ratcliffe, Amorim and all our ex players. What's the help in continually saying the players aren't good enough. We get it. Rashford aside, hard to accuse anyone of lacking effort, just ability. And then we seem to wonder why players who looked half useful like Höjlund suddenly have zero confidence, or why we start games so timidly.
You need to be ruthless to compete at the top. We always were when we were successful, now you have people wanting players to be given chances after clearly not being at the required standard
 
Pleasantly surprised that they aren’t trying to convince United fans that we need to get behind the super league money grab
 
This is your interpretation of the quote... not the fact. Go listen to it again... he says the club would have run out of cash, he didn't say bankrupt.

There is a massive difference between going into administration and running out of cash.
You know that. I know that. But running out of cash potentially causes that. And I interpreted it as that we could have gone bust not bankrupt. Bust is a more generic term that ranges from being financially ruined or failing to actually being wound up. The narrative has been we were going bust going down the path we are going. And when that was put to Berrada he didn't gainsay that.
But you are missing the point through the semantics. Which was that this is scaremongering to justify cuts and ticket price rises.
And I would add. For all the so-called financial woes, next day we announced a £2bn new stadium. With not a clue how it will be financed [Berrada admits]. And all that alongside not apparently having enough dough to bring in new players. Most fans, I'm sure would want investment in players FIRST, not the infrastructure which is about revenue generation and profits.
 
You know that. I know that. But running out of cash potentially causes that. And I interpreted it as that we could have gone bust not bankrupt. Bust is a more generic term that ranges from being financially ruined or failing to actually being wound up. The narrative has been we were going bust going down the path we are going. And when that was put to Berrada he didn't gainsay that.
But you are missing the point through the semantics. Which was that this is scaremongering to justify cuts and ticket price rises.
And I would add. For all the so-called financial woes, next day we announced a £2bn new stadium. With not a clue how it will be financed [Berrada admits]. And all that alongside not apparently having enough dough to bring in new players. Most fans, I'm sure would want investment in players FIRST, not the infrastructure which is about revenue generation and profits.

You do realise losing 100m a year, close to breaching FFP is not Scaremongering....
Do you think Berrada will tell everyone how they are financing it straight away?
Do you actually think they have no clue how to finance this? I mean, you must detest INEOS alot if thats what you think.

Finally, we have spent over £1bn in the recent past on players with nothing to show for it, alot of the fans were complaining about us spending too much money and nothing was done on infrastructure.

Now that INEOS want to improve the infrastructure, you are here moaning about it.

Do you think spending 50m on Carrington is to generate revenue and profit?

The stadium is falling apart... what bit of that dont you get?
 
Feel like one of United’s cultural problems is players talking after a good result. We’ve had two seasons of terrible league performances. Yet any time we string a couple of results together people who should know better (eg Bruno, Martinez, Rashford) are hitting back at ‘the critics’ after a couple of decent performances. The standard is not micro cycles. It’s about putting a run together for a long period.

I want the lads to just get to work and get results over a longer term.

Bruno has been mega and im not criticising his efforts but he is a leader of the team. SJR shouldn’t have criticised players but at the same time he is hardly wrong and it’s fine to call out lads who are perennially underperforming.
It’s up to all the players to get to work and shut any critics up. Bruno is leading by example but he is one person in a generally underperforming team.
 
Sure, I get that. But unfortunately, we have increased the net player trading position in the current year due to the heavy expenditure in q1 2025. Our committed net spend from this year alone is around 200m.
I am not having a go at the quality of the transfer business, I am merely stating that out net player trading position (which doesn't include salaries) is brutal and that needs to change. We are on course for another P&l loss of 100m plus in the current year.
Your point about refinancing is well made. I wouldn't dare dismiss it. Indeed, I have mentioned that back at the time of the first refinancing post takeover (around 2006) the glazers went on a cost cutting binge to polish the books in advance of that refinancing in order to get better terms through having better EBITDA coverage. The terms in any refinancing is more about your capacity to repay the interest. Less capacity (less coverage) then the greater the interest. I am pretty sure though that this reason for the heavy cost cutting (refinancing the legacy LBO debt) isn't one that JR is going to mention publicly. As you are aware, the finance costs are one of the major reasons why we are making such big losses.
100%, Nice when to adults can offer different perspectives and still agree.
 
He's not making the football decisions though, is he
At least in the beginning he did. Which is why the summer was messed up regarding the overall strategy which results in the current season.

Brailsford did throw away the season if reports are true that he wanted to keep EtH
 
Funny he’s digging out Arnold for being a Rugby man yet Ratcliffe’s own right hand man and go to guy for all things sport Dave Brailsford is famously a cycling guy, what the feck does he know about football?
What about Vivell, Wilcox and Berrada, you know..... the people who run the football side of the club.

Come on man, whether you like the ownership or not be genuine with your criticisms.
 
At least in the beginning he did. Which is why the summer was messed up regarding the overall strategy which results in the current season.

Brailsford did throw away the season if reports are true that he wanted to keep EtH

He has Jean-Claude Blanc reporting into him so there was a football hand on the tiller.
 
Funny he’s digging out Arnold for being a Rugby man yet Ratcliffe’s own right hand man and go to guy for all things sport Dave Brailsford is famously a cycling guy, what the feck does he know about football?
The CEO (ie. Arnolds replacement) is omar Berrada.
 
At least in the beginning he did. Which is why the summer was messed up regarding the overall strategy which results in the current season.

Brailsford did throw away the season if reports are true that he wanted to keep EtH
That is nonsense and you know it. And btw, he has installed good football people, better than what the club had in the past 12 years for gods sake
 
For how wealthy Jim is, he's pretty shite at media and PR at least from a football club perspective. I think a lot of people understand and can sympathize with some of the decisions he's had to make even if they aren't popular. His problem is he overshares and gives answers on certain issues that lead to a bigger than necessary story.

For any other chairman, after a bit of press like he's done recently, the two stand out bits should be the club's financial struggles and the new stadium. He's diluted the impact of this by talking about the playing squad, ETH and others.

Berarda should have been the one to do these interviews and maybe Jim could have spoken about the stadium only. I have no doubt Omar would have kept it targeted to financials and the journey of rebuilding the club under his watch supported by INEOS.

Jim's problem is his ego, he wants to be heard and seen as the man who saved United.
 
He's not making the football decisions though, is he

What about Vivell, Wilcox and Berrada, you know..... the people who run the football side of the club.

Come on man, whether you like the ownership or not be genuine with your criticisms.

He has Jean-Claude Blanc reporting into him so there was a football hand on the tiller.

The CEO (ie. Arnolds replacement) is omar Berrada.

I’m not saying there isn’t any football people making decisions, there obviously is and that’s a good thing but there’s no denying that Brailsford had a lot of influence early on. He’s also been involved with Nice and Lausanne, I’m not hating on Ratcliffe I just find it interesting he thought Arnold wasn’t qualified because he was a Rugby man yet he seems to really value the opinion of Brailsford even on football matters despite him being a cycling man who has nothing to do with football either.
 
I’m not saying there isn’t any football people making decisions, there obviously is and that’s a good thing but there’s no denying that Brailsford had a lot of influence early on. He’s also been involved with Nice and Lausanne, I’m not hating on Ratcliffe I just find it interesting he thought Arnold wasn’t qualified because he was a Rugby man yet he seems to really value the opinion of Brailsford even on football matters despite him being a cycling man who has nothing to do with football either.
Arnold wasn't qualified to be a CEO, that's probably the same reason Brailsford isn't CEO.
 
He’s a complete whopper. You’d almost admire that he doesn’t try to hide it. Almost.
 
He’s a complete whopper. You’d almost admire that he doesn’t try to hide it. Almost.
Obviously there's no admiration here for Ratcliffe, but to me the radio silence from Glazers was orders of magnitude more frustrating.
 
You do realise losing 100m a year, close to breaching FFP is not Scaremongering....
Do you think Berrada will tell everyone how they are financing it straight away?
Do you actually think they have no clue how to finance this? I mean, you must detest INEOS alot if thats what you think.

Finally, we have spent over £1bn in the recent past on players with nothing to show for it, alot of the fans were complaining about us spending too much money and nothing was done on infrastructure.

Now that INEOS want to improve the infrastructure, you are here moaning about it.

Do you think spending 50m on Carrington is to generate revenue and profit?

The stadium is falling apart... what bit of that dont you get?
I think Ineos have done a good job of providing a smoke screen for the Glazers. They're error after error (all admitted) doesn't fill me with much confidence in their competence. There was another road to go down which would have wiped out crippling debt. But Chelsea season ticket holder Sir Jim Ratcliffe and Co gave the Glazers an easy out. So, yeah, I'm angry over what Ineos have done. Not grateful. Nor, IMHO should any Man Utd fan with a brain
 
That is nonsense and you know it. And btw, he has installed good football people, better than what the club had in the past 12 years for gods sake
Which bit is nonsense?

It was reported that Brailsford wasthe one who wanted to keep ETH.

Better football people is yet to be determined.
 
Funny he’s digging out Arnold for being a Rugby man yet Ratcliffe’s own right hand man and go to guy for all things sport Dave Brailsford is famously a cycling guy, what the feck does he know about football?
He also ordered 22 pedals instead of boots dont forget
 
Fair enough.

I think Ratcliffe is the last person we should be aiming our guns on, no matter the mistakes he makes.
The guy has put his own millions to the club. Something we have not seen in decades.
For that alone, he can mistakes. Because he has proven that when it matters he is there to help the club, so his misstep is not from point on not caring.
Glazers are the worst, till now they haven't said a word about the new stadium. Imagine.
Ratcliffe is even dreaming of a new stadium. He is not perfect but he has earned his flowers for now.

I think our biggest concern now, is how we main team plays.
Said this on Tuesday,

Athletic have also taken note of it.. it is shocking the 'majority owner' has not said a word about new stadium to date

 
Funny he’s digging out Arnold for being a Rugby man yet Ratcliffe’s own right hand man and go to guy for all things sport Dave Brailsford is famously a cycling guy, what the feck does he know about football?
Nope, he wasn't hired for a football club. Someone helping for a brief amount of time until we hire someone is one thing. But hiring a non-football person to run football things is something else.

No comparison at all.