Could they void the PL due to the Coronavirus? | No | Resuming June 17th

OutlawGER

Full Member
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
3,848
Location
Cologne
Supports
Bayern München, 1. FC Köln
if something like this is happening, at least it can overshadow or even deny Liverpools first championship in ages, right?

Stay positive!
 

Ekkie Thump

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2013
Messages
3,892
Supports
Leeds United
I thought I understood but I've got questions again.

61,000 deaths from 4,500,000 cases is 1.36%. (Regular flu from couple of years ago United States).
29 deaths from 987 cases is 2.94%. (Coronavirus now United States).

So if there was 4,500,000 cases of Coronavirus in US and 2.94% of those died, then there would be 132,300 expected deaths.

Are you saying that the number of cases is expected to be much higher than 4,500,000 or that the 2.94% is going to increase? Or both?

I'm not American, I'm just using US numbers because that's what I happen to find. That CDC chart in my initial post.
No worries, you're just missing a zero in your calculations. As per your graph it's not 4,500,000 cases, it's 45,000,000 cases.

Just the other day Merkel came out and said that up to 70% of the German population could contract covid-19 in the next 2 years, so while it sounds and is extraordinary 45,000,000 cases in the US remains within the upper bounds of possibility if we just let this fecker spread. If something like that truly happened then a 2.94% mortality rate could well increase because there simply wouldn't be the medical resources or personnel to cope with demand. There would also be a knock-on effect to other forms of death. Since everywhere would be maxed out dealing with covid-19 patients there'd be nothing left to expend on any other types of illness, including flu.
 

lolok

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Mar 1, 2018
Messages
92
They have to (temporarily) suspend the season. Watford plays Leicester next, right? If I'm a Watford player, I say no way in heck am I going out on that pitch. Leceister has 3 players in isolation, and who know how many more on that team are infected that aren't showing symptoms just yet. It doesn't seem right to potentially put Watford players @ risk of catching this virus from Leicester players.
 

ManchesterYoda

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2016
Messages
747
From that live source US numbers are right now at the present time 38 deaths from 1380 cases. So the death rate right now is not increasing, it's actually dropped slightly. Italy is unusually higher. Germany is really low. I would have thought China's death rate would be higher due to it being the source and being very densely populated. Also, why is the number of new cases in China only 18?
 

padr81

Full Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
11,933
Supports
Man City
This is getting out of hand now, only football seems intent on continuing. Our next two games are postponed, Arsenal in the prem and Real in the CL, where do the organisations think they are going to fit those games in with so little of the season remaining. They are going to have to put football on hold for at least a month.
 

ManchesterYoda

Full Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2016
Messages
747
No worries, you're just missing a zero in your calculations. As per your graph it's not 4,500,000 cases, it's 45,000,000 cases.

Just the other day Merkel came out and said that up to 70% of the German population could contract covid-19 in the next 2 years, so while it sounds and is extraordinary 45,000,000 cases in the US remains within the upper bounds of possibility if we just let this fecker spread. If something like that truly happened then a 2.94% mortality rate could well increase because there simply wouldn't be the medical resources or personnel to cope with demand. There would also be a knock-on effect to other forms of death. Since everywhere would be maxed out dealing with covid-19 patients there'd be nothing left to expend on any other types of illness, including flu.
That's it. I'm going blind. I was checking and double checking but I didn't think of checking whether I put the right bloody number down!
 

padr81

Full Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
11,933
Supports
Man City
From that live source US numbers are right now at the present time 38 deaths from 1380 cases. So the death rate right now is not increasing, it's actually dropped slightly. Italy is unusually higher. Germany is really low. I would have thought China's death rate would be higher due to it being the source and being very densely populated. Also, why is the number of new cases in China only 18?
Because China have completely shut down and are preventing it from spreading, Italy will eventually start to drop too. The issue in China is so many people were carrying it before anyone knew it existed and in Italy it spread like wildfire because of people not taking precautions. Italy will see dwindling numbers soon as well but it may have to suffer a China like couple of weeks in getting to that point.
 

TMDaines

Fun sponge.
Joined
Sep 1, 2014
Messages
13,985
The Athletic link someone posted is probably the best estimate. Either take the snapshot of the league now and call it the final standings (clubs can't complain about Liverpool being Champions but would complain about top 4/relegation standings) Or, have play-offs to decide.

My punt is a blend of the two. Liverpool won't need a play off and will be crowned as Champions whilst those within an x band of top 4 will have a play-off of some sort. Same with those in relegation zones. I can't really think of any other way?
I don't see any rational to crowning the winners of a league, prior to the league being either completed or the standings being mathematically certain. Even in the latter case, part of the terms of the compeition is being able to fulfil your fixtures and you can't just not play once you are mathematically champions.

The whole point of a league is equal competition for all the participants. That's why winning it is so valued. You can't just do 2/3rds of it and shrug that the outcomes are likely enough.
 

FootballHQ

Full Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2017
Messages
18,255
Supports
Aston Villa
I just don't understand why it hasn't been suspended.

It's not going away, players have it and fans have it. It will be suspended after this round of fixtures at any rate, or after the next one. It's just delaying for no reason and risking exposing more people to it and spreading it more widely. I'm honestly baffled.
My only thinking is less fixtures to play when eventually everything restarts e.g. you get 1-2 rounds in and also the FA cup and so you're left with 7-8 premier league games and semi finals and final of FA cup. Could fit that all in just over a month if you had an xmas type schedule.

Serie A still has over 10 rounds to play I think.

Ultimately the events are just taking over now so really PL has to be cancelled now with teams starting to get infections.
 

Gasolin

Full Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2007
Messages
6,106
Location
NYC
From that live source US numbers are right now at the present time 38 deaths from 1380 cases. So the death rate right now is not increasing, it's actually dropped slightly. Italy is unusually higher. Germany is really low. I would have thought China's death rate would be higher due to it being the source and being very densely populated. Also, why is the number of new cases in China only 18?
The US are just lagging. CDC and epidemic experts are already bracing for the number to go very high because they believe underlying complications are a risk and the US has a lot more obese people, which will in turn be a problem. Overall it's a volume issue. But let's hope for the best indeed.
 

FootballHQ

Full Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2017
Messages
18,255
Supports
Aston Villa
They have to (temporarily) suspend the season. Watford plays Leicester next, right? If I'm a Watford player, I say no way in heck am I going out on that pitch. Leceister has 3 players in isolation, and who know how many more on that team are infected that aren't showing symptoms just yet. It doesn't seem right to potentially put Watford players @ risk of catching this virus from Leicester players.
Yep same for Brighton v Arsenal and potentially Chelsea playing us given we played Leicester on monday night.

No way prem can go ahead even behind closed doors imo this weekend. I think all games to be cancelled this weekend and beyond will be announced tomorrow (not sure why it hasn't been announced after the COBRA meeting ended).
 

passing-wind

Full Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2013
Messages
3,041
Doesn't really matter what our love for the game is when it comes to this virus being transmitted which is a 100% risk to the well-being of players rightfully so the league should be suspended. I think writing off the season is a terrible idea, I can't stand Liverpool but on the premise of this season they deserve the league title. We are lucky to be in 5th right now with City's ban imposed that should be a champions league qualification. I would take the league finishing right now with the current points tally if it gets us into next season UCL. Also makes it hard to sack Ole so it's beneficial for the club imo.
 

TMDaines

Fun sponge.
Joined
Sep 1, 2014
Messages
13,985
Amongst all this bad news, I have some potentially happy news for you!
According to a poster in another thread, UEFA use a ranking system when a season is cancelled. In which case Real would be crowned winners of the Champions League and we would be crowned winners of the Europa League due to our team ranking. If the PL is cancelled Liverpool won't win the league and we would still play in Champions League next season for being crowned champions of the Europa League due to ranking.
Our dreams come true!
So the Premier League handbook states:
C.11. The Club which is at the top of the table at the end of the Season shall be the League Champions.
'Season' is defined as:
“Season” means the period commencing on the date of the first League Match on the fixture list of the League’s first team competition and ending on the date of the last;
That's about the entirety of the relevant material remarkably. Section L: Fixtures makes no allowance for fixtures simply not to be played at the discretion of the league or anything like that. Section X : Arbitration could handle any dispute over it, I guess.
 

matt10000

Full Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2018
Messages
1,330
Location
Salford UK
Doesn't really matter what our love for the game is when it comes to this virus being transmitted which is a 100% risk to the well-being of players rightfully so the league should be suspended. I think writing off the season is a terrible idea, I can't stand Liverpool but on the premise of this season they deserve the league title. We are lucky to be in 5th right now with City's ban imposed that should be a champions league qualification. I would take the league finishing right now with the current points tally if it gets us into next season UCL. Also makes it hard to sack Ole so it's beneficial for the club imo.
Exactly, even though indications are healthy fit people get mild flu, no one knows for sure if it leaves the lungs a bit less than they were before, this could be big impact on professional sportsman???

Not enough known really
 

Nou_Camp99

what would Souness do?
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Messages
10,274
Maybe Pep has been a genius afterall.......the Carabao cup is likely going to be the only competition completed this season. Hahahaha
 

Lynty

Full Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2014
Messages
3,094
Just been told that hospitals will soon stop testing for COVID-19 and anyone displaying symptoms will be told to self isolate.

Very worrying if true, as it looks like the
 

El Zoido

Full Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
12,338
Location
UK
Doesn't really matter what our love for the game is when it comes to this virus being transmitted which is a 100% risk to the well-being of players rightfully so the league should be suspended. I think writing off the season is a terrible idea, I can't stand Liverpool but on the premise of this season they deserve the league title. We are lucky to be in 5th right now with City's ban imposed that should be a champions league qualification. I would take the league finishing right now with the current points tally if it gets us into next season UCL. Also makes it hard to sack Ole so it's beneficial for the club imo.
This seems horribly unfair on all teams that are challenging for top five and would miss out, and also for relegated teams. Really the only sensible way to do it is to write it off and start again next season.
 

giorno

boob novice
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
26,580
Supports
Real Madrid
Because China have completely shut down and are preventing it from spreading, Italy will eventually start to drop too. The issue in China is so many people were carrying it before anyone knew it existed and in Italy it spread like wildfire because of people not taking precautions. Italy will see dwindling numbers soon as well but it may have to suffer a China like couple of weeks in getting to that point.
No, the virus spread like wildfire because that's what it does, everywhere. The only difference between italy and spain, france, germany, uk, etc is that we're a week or more ahead
 

NecssryEvil

Full Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
531
From that live source US numbers are right now at the present time 38 deaths from 1380 cases. So the death rate right now is not increasing, it's actually dropped slightly. Italy is unusually higher. Germany is really low. I would have thought China's death rate would be higher due to it being the source and being very densely populated. Also, why is the number of new cases in China only 18?
China is about the most open and honest country there is, I see no reason to doubt their word...
 

GodShaveTheQueen

We mean it man, we love our queen!
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
6,434
Italy is about to overtake China in total active cases in a day or two. How is Europe not worried all over the place, god knows.

Spain, France and Germany catching up too.

Country,
Other
Total
Cases
New
Cases
Total
Deaths
New
Deaths
Total
Recovered
Active
Cases
Serious,
Critical
Tot Cases/
1M pop
China80,796+183,169+1162,82614,8014,25756.1
Italy15,113+2,6511,016+1891,25812,8391,153250.0
Iran10,075+1,075429+753,2766,370120.0
S. Korea7,869+11466+63337,47054153.5
Spain3,059+78286+311892,78412665.4
Germany2,502+5365+2252,472929.9
France2,28148122,22110534.9
USA1,396+9539+1151,342104.2
 

horsechoker

The Caf's Roy Keane.
Joined
Apr 16, 2015
Messages
52,222
Location
The stable
Italy is about to overtake China in total active cases in a day or two. How is Europe not worried all over the place, god knows.

Spain, France and Germany catching up too.

Country,
Other
Total
Cases
New
Cases
Total
Deaths
New
Deaths
Total
Recovered
Active
Cases
Serious,
Critical
Tot Cases/
1M pop
China80,796+183,169+1162,82614,8014,25756.1
Italy15,113+2,6511,016+1891,25812,8391,153250.0
Iran10,075+1,075429+753,2766,370120.0
S. Korea7,869+11466+63337,47054153.5
Spain3,059+78286+311892,78412665.4
Germany2,502+5365+2252,472929.9
France2,28148122,22110534.9
USA1,396+9539+1151,342104.2
It's worrying but China is also further ahead, their measure have greatly reduced the numbers of new cases to a point where there's not many new cases. Italy should follow suit if the measure they've taken are effective. Essentially, it demonstrates that social distancing is the way to fight the spread.
 

AlwaysRed66

Full Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2016
Messages
1,897
So it looks like the PL will go ahead BCD’s.
Not if teams refuse to play saying it is detrimental to their health. What are PL going to do dock them points & fine them. I am sure Everton players are not feeling well at this time.
 

edcunited1878

Full Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2014
Messages
8,935
Location
San Diego, CA
Boris has decided not to ban mass gatherings so I assume that includes football.
But that doesn't mean the PL cannot do the more responsible thing and allow for football to be played behind closed doors. But then I don't totally believe in the PL to be responsible or have high standards of integrity.
 

edcunited1878

Full Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2014
Messages
8,935
Location
San Diego, CA
He is listening to advice from the scientists and doctors who have knowledge in this area. This isn't a decision he is making just on a whim...
Yeah but when every other major league around the world has cancelled or supports behind closed doors (i.e. no fans), you can see that there's precedence. Sometimes you have the opportunity to make bold decisions as a leader no matter what other people say because you're gathering input from others to make the call and it's your call, it's your head.