criticalanalysis
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2015
- Messages
- 8,381
Didn't watch the game, how comes he wasn't in the first 5 penalty takers?
Subbed off around the 80th minDidn't watch the game, how comes he wasn't in the first 5 penalty takers?
Subbed off around the 80th min
Ronaldo was already better than a veteran Figo by 2006 and probably Portugal’s best player at that World Cup. They could’ve even taken France to extra time in the semis if Figo had scored that open header sitter created by none other than Ronaldo.I'll leave this for the Portuguese people to debate, but you've left out a lot of context. Obviously his presence has helped them greatly, but it's far from being all about him, like you are trying to paint it. Portugal's best finish at a World Cup still remains the 1966 edition. And their second best finish at a World Cup was in 2006, when Figo was the captain and leader of the team.
It's really funny to watch the tactico meltdown on Twitter. They don't really rate Ronaldo, Martinez, Bruno and co and Lamine Yamal is basically their love child.
Happy for Ronnie .. he'll play the WC right?
Old man injured, cramped up and subbed off.Didn't watch the game, how comes he wasn't in the first 5 penalty takers?
Figo was the best Portuguese player in that tournament, one & only who made it to the official 11. Ronaldo was nothing special, no need to rewrite history.Ronaldo was already better than a veteran Figo by 2006 and probably Portugal’s best player at that World Cup. They could’ve even taken France to extra time in the semis if Figo had scored that open header sitter created by none other than Ronaldo.
Ronaldo was also again key in Euro 04. He wasn’t just a passenger in those teams but a very big reason why they were good.
Italy and France before expansion to 16 teams starting in 1996 only qualified for 3 out of 8 Euros.Portugal before Ronaldo:
Only qualified for 3 World Cups
Only qualified for 3 Euros
No major trophies or a final
Portugal since Ronaldo's debut:
5 World Cup Qualifications (4th place in 2006 World Cup)
2 Euro Finals (2004 and 2016 title)
2 Nations League Titles in 2019 and 2025
Old man injured, cramped up and subbed off.
Really happy for him, Bruno, Dalot and Portugal! Can't believe we missed out on Nuno Mendes my word .
Ronaldo's achievements spanning up to the age of 40 are absolutely incredible. The amount of work and focus needed to maintain yourself beyond 35 is hard. I genuinely can't believe how he has done it.
And then to be such a sharp goal scorer still to make an impact in an international tournament like this is the stuff of legend.
It's funny talking about how Portugal finding an alternative. You look at what a decent striker like Morata does to Spain (miss crucial chances and lose them games and tournaments) and you begin to understand why a team like Portugal would still consider Ronaldo in their lineup right now. Goals win games. Ronaldo still scores goals.
You clearly didn’t watch that tournament and only projecting your agenda.Figo was the best Portuguese player in that tournament, one & only who made it to the official 11. Ronaldo was nothing special, no need to rewrite history.
In 2004, it was the team of Figo-Rui Costa-Deco etc..
You clearly didn’t watch that tournament and only projecting your agenda.
Ronaldo literally was chosen in XI of the tournament. No Figo. Rui Costa started the first game but then replaced by Deco. The core of Mourinho Porto 2004 replacing old guard of Couto, Rui Costa.Carvalho and Maniche were also in XI of the tournament.
But this version of him has had no impact, except negative, in real international tournaments though.And then to be such a sharp goal scorer still to make an impact in an international tournament like this is the stuff of legend.
It's funny talking about how Portugal finding an alternative. You look at what a decent striker like Morata does to Spain (miss crucial chances and lose them games and tournaments) and you begin to understand why a team like Portugal would still consider Ronaldo in their lineup right now. Goals win games. Ronaldo still scores goals.
Ronaldo literally was chosen in XI of the tournament. No Figo.
I don't recall Cristiano being in the official 11, nor the 23 squad for the 2006 WC, are you sure about that? I recall Figo, Zidane, Cannavaro, Pirlo, for sure, I might be wrong thought
I thought he was talking about Euro 2004 when he mentioned Rui Costa (who was not there in 2006).I don't recall Cristiano being in the official 11, nor the 23 squad for the 2006 WC, are you sure about that? I recall Figo, Zidane, Cannavaro, Pirlo, for sure, I might be wrong thought
So before and after still no major trophies.Portugal before Ronaldo:
Only qualified for 3 World Cups
Only qualified for 3 Euros
No major trophies or a final
Portugal since Ronaldo's debut:
5 World Cup Qualifications (4th place in 2006 World Cup)
2 Euro Finals (2004 and 2016 title)
2 Nations League Titles in 2019 and 2025
Well Dalot was his part time Uber driver so...He seems to be close with Dalot
Euro 2016So before and after still no major trophies.
When did EURO stop being a major trophy?So before and after still no major trophies.
If you want to use it context of someone being the greatest, then the World Cup is the pinnacle.When did EURO stop being a major trophy?
I think they are 3rd best team after Argentina and France. It is close between Spain and Portugal. England are just after all the above.Probably but I don't think he will have the legs to do long games probably 60 minutes.
Portugal have a world class team though, they won't be favourites but they can definitely win it
Then Pele is indisputable GOAT?If you want to use it context of someone being the greatest, then the World Cup is the pinnacle.
Euro and Copa America below that, Nations league…well that’s just an end of season international friendly community shield.
What official 11? UEFA didn't have that in 2004, just a team of the tournament with 23 names, same as FIFA in 2006. Ronaldo was in it in 2004, he wasn't in 2006.
The Euros and the Copa America are not equivalents imo; the former is much harder to win. If you play for Brazil, Argentina or Uruguay then statistically you should win at least one Copa America during your career. The other teams are mostly makeweights - plus, until recently they held it every two years.If you want to use it context of someone being the greatest, then the World Cup is the pinnacle.
Euro and Copa America below that, Nations league…well that’s just an end of season international friendly community shield.
100% Honestly with the way the alternatives are playing I think he will still start. Can't believe how there are so many options all over the pitch except Striker.It's really funny to watch the tactico meltdown on Twitter. They don't really rate Ronaldo, Martinez, Bruno and co and Lamine Yamal is basically their love child.
Happy for Ronnie .. he'll play the WC right?
Yet WCs tend to kill in the pata more than a candidate.I think they are 3rd best team after Argentina and France. It is close between Spain and Portugal. England are just after all the above.
Italy and France before expansion to 16 teams starting in 1996 only qualified for 3 out of 8 Euros.
Since then they qualified for 8 out of 8 Euros.
Swiss and Turkey qualified for 6 out of 8 after expansion when they had none before. I wonder how they would do trying to qualify for a 4-team or 8-team Euros.
Portugal with their Golden Generation already played semis in 2000 Euros and qualified for the WC in 2002. They had Deco, Figo, Rui Costa, Carvalho etc. Ronaldo joined after the beginning of this upward trajectory.
So what's your solution then, Argentina to play in the Euros?The Euros and the Copa America are not equivalents imo; the former is much harder to win. If you play for Brazil, Argentina or Uruguay then statistically you should win at least one Copa America during your career. The other teams are mostly makeweights - plus, until recently they held it every two years.
Whereas in Europe you have to overcome France, Spain, Germany, Italy, Portugal, England, Holland, Belgium, Croatia, Denmark etc... And most players will only get a maximum of three attempts in their career. The odds are against them winning it, even if they are on the best team.
Then Pele is indisputable GOAT?
100% Honestly with the way the alternatives are playing I think he will still start. Can't believe how there are so many options all over the pitch except Striker.
Yeah, that's the main problem. Ideally you would have someone who gets at least 70-75% of his input and then CR7 can be used as an impact sub when needed. But two problems, 1.) No one who even comes close to the impact he makes for goalscoring. 2.) No manager with balls to drop him.When Goncalo Ramos scored that hat trick at the WC, it looked like the end for Ronaldo. Since then Ramos has 5 international goals in 10 appearances. Ronaldo has scored 20 in 23 games.
I think we can all understand that he doesn't offer a lot outside of being an out and out poacher. But, even at this level he's still so good at it. Don't think at this stage he should be a starter, but he's not humble enough to accept a supporting role and nobody has the balls to drop him. If he didn't get injured last night, Martinez wasn't taking him off.
They probably need to develop during the qualification rounds for playing without him going into the WC. But, it's unlikely that will actually happen.
The way you defined when Ronaldo joined Portugal NT, then it’s very much the same time Carvalho, Deco “joined”. It took that defeat against Greece in opening game in EURO, for Scolari to started Carvalho over Couto, Deco over Rui Costa, and Ronaldo replacing Simao. Spain was in that group. Portugal was the host nation, so they didn’t play qualifier. They were not tested and got the shock against Greece and had to embrace the change from new generation. Deco, Carvalho had little to do with Rui Costa, Couto generation. They were literally the latter successors in the team.Italy and France before expansion to 16 teams starting in 1996 only qualified for 3 out of 8 Euros.
Since then they qualified for 8 out of 8 Euros.
Swiss and Turkey qualified for 6 out of 8 after expansion when they had none before. I wonder how they would do trying to qualify for a 4-team or 8-team Euros.
Portugal with their Golden Generation already played semis in 2000 Euros and qualified for the WC in 2002. They had Deco, Figo, Rui Costa, Carvalho etc. Ronaldo joined after the beginning of this upward trajectory.
Ronaldo was already better than a veteran Figo by 2006 and probably Portugal’s best player at that World Cup. They could’ve even taken France to extra time in the semis if Figo had scored that open header sitter created by none other than Ronaldo.
Ronaldo was also again key in Euro 04. He wasn’t just a passenger in those teams but a very big reason why they were good.
They can make a run, but they won't win it. Not with an even older Ronaldo starting every game and Roberto Martinez as their manager. He is simply not a World Cup winning manager.Portugal have been a relatively strong team over the last 20 years, not all the performances have been good at tournaments but player for player they have always been up there to challenge.
They have a serious chance to win the WC next year because they know how to get over the line and have quality throughout the side.
I won't be surprised if they make a deep run.
It doesn't refute any of my points. They were similar to the likes of Hungary, Bulgaria or Turkey. All of them had one good generation and were average for the majority of their history.Italy and France before expansion to 16 teams starting in 1996 only qualified for 3 out of 8 Euros.
Since then they qualified for 8 out of 8 Euros.
Swiss and Turkey qualified for 6 out of 8 after expansion when they had none before. I wonder how they would do trying to qualify for a 4-team or 8-team Euros.
Portugal with their Golden Generation already played semis in 2000 Euros and qualified for the WC in 2002. They had Deco, Figo, Rui Costa, Carvalho etc. Ronaldo joined after the beginning of this upward trajectory.
Ronaldo was arguably their best player in the Euros 2004 and he did make the best XI of the tournament. He scored 2 goals and provided 2 assists.Ì didn't say he was a passenger, but he didn't even make the team of the tournament in 2006. Figo did, along with Carvalho, Ricardo and Maniche.