Man Utd 2:1 Aston Villa
Horrific cameo performance. Bad decision making at all times.
21
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 26
- Goals
- 5
- Assists
- 2
- Yellow cards
- 3
- Status
Where was his pace?!
On that breakaway, apart from the horrendous decision making, the Villa defenders were closing on him so quickly. That's fine and all but I thought James was meant to be exceptionally fast?
On that breakaway, apart from the horrendous decision making, the Villa defenders were closing on him so quickly. That's fine and all but I thought James was meant to be exceptionally fast?
Yeah, I hate to pile on, but was just thinking this after he turned into the crowd of players and lost it near the end.
3-4 times in such a short cameo where his decisions give them ball back and invite pressure at such an important time in the game.
I don’t think he is even good enough to come on as a sub, and it could have been the undoing today.
He is bloody awful 
I feel sorry for him.
I feel sorry for him.He is terrible. Diallo should replace him as the fourth choice winger and James needs to be sold.
Ehh, I thought this was a very good cameo. Did the job asked from him in these 5 minutes pretty well imo. No complaints from me.
He's a busy little brainless bee and that's it.
It's such a shame he doesn't have the talent to utilise that searing pace.
It's such a shame he doesn't have the talent to utilise that searing pace.
Ah, someone will be here soon to remind us about his one month scoring purple patch.
Think he’s lost a yard. He no longer has insane pace.
I feel for him. He just isn't a good enough footballer.
Still think he has a lot to offer/a lot of progression protentional, but that was awful. Worst bit is on a break 3 on 3 you could tell Marcus was hesitant to play him the ball...
Que? Almost every touch was a dispossession
He doesn't. On that breakaway those Villa defenders were catching up to him with relative ease.
The famous United bulking up program?
Like a kid who got a chance to play 5 minutes with older guys.
How he still gets minutes i don't understand. We all (more or less) dislike (in football terms) Lingard. But with Lingard you don't have a feeling that he is out of depth. You see that he is not good enough for Man Utd but not out of depth. James on the other hand....holly feck.
How he still gets minutes i don't understand. We all (more or less) dislike (in football terms) Lingard. But with Lingard you don't have a feeling that he is out of depth. You see that he is not good enough for Man Utd but not out of depth. James on the other hand....holly feck.
Somehow with an incredibly simple job given to him (harass and just provide an outlet wide), he still managed to look like garbage again.
Don't think he ever did. He has very good acceleration over the first 10m but that's it
If Ole gets some form of twisted pleasure from playing him up front running around like a headless chicken then that's one thing, bit how on earth is he defending a corner on the front post in the dying minutes of the match? A competition winner who seemingly gets to play for a professional football team on a regular basis. Why is Ole willingly persisting with him?
He had about two chances on the goal in the last 5 minutes and kept us stretched enough and gave Villa something to worry about if they leave open spaces. There was nothing more to ask him to do in the last 5 minutes. He did the job asked for him, in my own opinion.Que? Almost every touch was a dispossession
Luckily he was only on for 5 minutes because in that 5 minutes he was diabolical.
The way he stands over the ball facing the defender trying to get a shot off is hilarious. There's no technique.
I really want to him to be good for us. He could be such an important player for us, even if it's just to come off the bench but he's sadly not good enough. He tries his best and you can see the drive to succeed here but he just lacks the talent needed at this level.
He needs to become a team player instead of cutting in and shoot, he has potential to develop into a useful player but he's way too selfish and predictable.
Downright awful. Runs with his head down and could have played two passes that would put us in goalscoring positions.
He's frankly not good enough and is letting down the entire team.
He's frankly not good enough and is letting down the entire team.
He's out of his depth at this level, if we're being brutally honest. I think he could end up a decent player one day, just not for us, his decision making is by far his biggest weakness.
Sunday league speed merchant that has somehow struck make a wish playing for United. Deer in headlights look on his face anytime he’s on the field. Comical technique for a premier league player. Do you see the way he stands awkwardly every time he has to dribble or fake a shot?
I wish you were exaggerating, sadly you are not. The technical gap between James and his teammates is huge. The same may also be true of premier league players in general. Ole might see him as Park Ji Sung type of player.... sadly he is just not very good.
Why does he try to cut inside in counters. He was in full run, he can easily outsprint defenders but he goes in the middle?
That was disaster decision
That was disaster decision
Been a long time since I’ve seen a player so far off the level required.
I’ll say again, I cannot believe we turned down the opportunity to cash in during the summer.
I’ll say again, I cannot believe we turned down the opportunity to cash in during the summer.
Ole gave him a chance in circumstances that suit his strengths but he failed to capitalize.
Never dreamt that I'm gonna say this. But I'd play Lingard over James.
Lingard is a midtable player. James is honestly probably League One or Two level. The difference in quality between them is enormous & Lingard himself is not good enough.
I get the theory behind bringing him on, but the actuality was pretty bad.
I don't really know how or why Mata has fallen behind him in the pecking order.
I don't really know how or why Mata has fallen behind him in the pecking order.
He isn't very bright.
Lay off the criticism. He was brought on to run behind a high defense as Villa were trying to equalize and he did his job well. Obviously his decision making and ball control isn't anywhere near the level of the PL.
He did cause some concerns and we did have two wonderful opportunities to make it 3-1 which we missed. No one is expecting him to be a regular starter for the club so most of this criticism is invalid. Once we have better options, I am pretty sure that he will swiftly go down the pecking order.
He did cause some concerns and we did have two wonderful opportunities to make it 3-1 which we missed. No one is expecting him to be a regular starter for the club so most of this criticism is invalid. Once we have better options, I am pretty sure that he will swiftly go down the pecking order.
I don't think even Lingard would be guaranteed a starter at mid-table teams like Leeds, Wolves, or Arsenal.
I thought we got Overmars Mk II. But so far, it's more like Obertan Mk II
Unfortunately I do not think he has the qualities at this level to play regularly for United. The qualities required are excellent technical ability and footballing intelligence (which is position-specific). He has some of each but definitely not above the threshold required. The decision that needs to be made is whether he is happy to just be a sub or if he needs to play regular first team football, then he needs to go.
TBH I'd rather use Obertan instead of James.
Needs to bulk up
- Status