Just finished with the pilot on this thing. Must say it's quite different than most shows that pop up today with good actors even. Netflix really is the gift that keeps on giving.
Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency - Netflix series
- Thread starter Art
- Start date
Its a BBC America series. Netflix added it after S1 was over.
was discussed here... a bit.
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/dirk-gentlys-holistic-television-series.306956/
was discussed here... a bit.
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/dirk-gentlys-holistic-television-series.306956/
Annoyed me. I've no idea who the main character is playing, but it's not Dirk Gently. More Sheldon Cooper by way of Dr Who mixed with an American idea of a "Camp quirky Englishman" dialled up to "super annoying"
If Max Landis wanted to do his own holistic detective thing, he should've done. This current obsession with tenuously anchoring everything new to an already existing property does neither the new or the old any favours, and is yet more brand recognition nostalgia bait at worst.
It's not hateful or anything, but it's trying to do way too many things, and didn't need an "American remimagining" only a few years after the BBC proper did one. Especially since it's no interest in being anything like the source material anyway. Most egregiously, by not being funny.
If Max Landis wanted to do his own holistic detective thing, he should've done. This current obsession with tenuously anchoring everything new to an already existing property does neither the new or the old any favours, and is yet more brand recognition nostalgia bait at worst.
It's not hateful or anything, but it's trying to do way too many things, and didn't need an "American remimagining" only a few years after the BBC proper did one. Especially since it's no interest in being anything like the source material anyway. Most egregiously, by not being funny.
Last edited:
To be fair i think most people can enioy a series for what it is without letting the fact it deviates widely from the original portrayal.
Seems a very pointless and petty thing to get so hung up on.
Tbf, I hated the main character, regardless of who he was playing. A jumbled mix of fey 'TV' affectations that was ill-fitted and (for the most part) completely irrelevant to the rest of the show.
But you're right that things can work on their own merits. I just can't get my head around the motivation for making a largely straight drama out of a Douglas Adams conceit. It's like putting a barely recognisable version of Zaphod Beeblebrox into an episode of Star Trek and going "Yep, that sorta works. Lets call it Hitchhikers!"
Last edited:
It doesn't have a whole lot to do with Douglas Adams' novels, but it was fun watching those 8 episodes for the largest parts.
Ugh. Will avoid.
I don't think it's petty to want a show called Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency to at least somewhat resemble Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency. And even beyond issues of being faithful to the material, it's just not a great show. It's not nearly as cute or as witty as it thinks it is, and the "quirky" humour he's going for falls very flat for me. As someone who actually doesn't mind Max Landis, even I see all his worst qualities in this show.
Gave up after the pilot, before someone convinced me that it gets better. Watched episode 2 and gave up again.
Yeah it took me a couple of episodes to get my head into the strangeness of things, but i really ended up enjoying it!
With the exception of the main character, he's just bloody annoying
With the exception of the main character, he's just bloody annoying
I started watching it but where's the humour? The best thing about Douglas Adams is how he incorporates the humour into the imagination. I guess you don't have to stick too much to the source material but at least stick to the idea/theme of the source material. Otherwise why even bother basing it on the source material? It feels kind of like a token effort in that respect. Like someone just looked up Dirk Gently on Wikipedia and decided to make a TV series.
Not interesting enough in it's own right to hold my attention in spite of this. Just feels like a bit of a waste.
Not interesting enough in it's own right to hold my attention in spite of this. Just feels like a bit of a waste.
feck max landis
It is awful.
Properly bad.
Which is not usual for a Netflix series, but this is proper dogshit TV.
Properly bad.
Which is not usual for a Netflix series, but this is proper dogshit TV.
I just watched the first episode. No idea what the hell is going on and Dirk is pretty annoying. Would've been better with someone more quirky than camp (although I've no idea what the original Dirk is like). Can't decide whether to stick with it after reading everyone else's thoughts on it.
I have it downloaded but haven't got around to watching it yet.
The advice I've been given is forget it has anything to do with the books and you'll enjoy it. Even people who don't usually like Max Landis' work seem to like it.
The advice I've been given is forget it has anything to do with the books and you'll enjoy it. Even people who don't usually like Max Landis' work seem to like it.
Takes id say 4 episodes for it to start to settle. Me and the missus liked both seasons as easy tv, it's not amazing but its decent enough to fill the easy tv slot.
I find the caf tends to class tv programs as either amazing or shite though
Just started watching season 2. Its weird alright.. But I'm in. Its not dirk gently from the books, so dont go in expecting that.
I really like there title theme
I really like there title theme
So...I started this on Netflix
And I love it. It's quirky so that's maybe why I like it. Already gone though season 1 and I'm liking where s2 is going
Edit: I didn't realise how old this is and when it initially came out. I thought this was a 2018 show
Edit 2: just realised there's no s3 so hopefully s2 has a nice ending and just ends there
And I love it. It's quirky so that's maybe why I like it. Already gone though season 1 and I'm liking where s2 is going
Edit: I didn't realise how old this is and when it initially came out. I thought this was a 2018 show
Edit 2: just realised there's no s3 so hopefully s2 has a nice ending and just ends there
I think it was cut after S2 finished so I have a feeling it might not have a very satisfying ending.
I never watched it as I loved the book and liked the sequal, and didn't mind the UK TV version but an American version didn't appeal.
I never watched it as I loved the book and liked the sequal, and didn't mind the UK TV version but an American version didn't appeal.
It's nothing like the book at all (it shares a title and that's about it) but really great. I expected to hate it but loved it.
Thanks. Might try it then.
I enjoyed both seasons and as i remember the ending was fine.
Its light hearted and not particularly bingeable
Its light hearted and not particularly bingeable
Yeah, apart from some general conceptual link, the series got nothing to do with the books. The humor is rather different also. I liked it though!
Each season is kinda standalone, so no worries of getting an incomplete series. Season 2 does build on season 1, but the series could have been ended after season 1 and it would've been fine - just as the season 2 ending is fine for the series as a whole. (I still would've liked another season though!)
Each season is kinda standalone, so no worries of getting an incomplete series. Season 2 does build on season 1, but the series could have been ended after season 1 and it would've been fine - just as the season 2 ending is fine for the series as a whole. (I still would've liked another season though!)
Yeah ending was fine. Think s3 would have ventured with Ken pretty much changing sides but overall s2 ended as a good finale so satisfied unlike with something like Scorpion
Just started on this. Both Dirk and Todd come across as super annoying earlier. But the plot and overall bizarreness kept me watching and started picking up after 3 or 4 episodes. Liking it so far.
Probably that I haven't read the books or know the character helps going previous comments.
Still one of more bingeable fun series out there.
Probably that I haven't read the books or know the character helps going previous comments.
Still one of more bingeable fun series out there.