Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
Indeed, not a chance in hell Antony wasn’t a Ten Hag signing. It’s much more likely the board were against it and ETH put pressure on.

£80m is crazy money but that’s football nowadays, plus Ajax had no reason to sell so we needed to give them one.

Whatever you think of Antony if we hadn’t signed for that position we’d be fecked this season. Sancho has been out for months, Pellistri clearly isn’t ready (still not sure if he will make it in the PL despite his obvious talent) and Amad while having a great season now was coming off the back of a disastrous loan with Rangers.

We basically only had Sancho, Rashford, an injury prone Martial (returning from a disastrous loan at Sevilla) and a toxic Ronaldo to work with at the start of the season.
Exactly, its actually frustrating to see when fans complain about transfers either way.

When we spend money on who the manager wants, we are badly run and over pay, if we dont, the club is cheap and not backing the manager.

Antony was a Ten Hag signing, the fee paid was a signal saying, Ten Hag, we back you.

I know he hasn't been in the best form but he does give the team balance on that side, like you say, we could not rely on the players we had, so we had to go and get him.
 

Desert Eagle

Punjabi Dude
Joined
Sep 25, 2006
Messages
16,778
Yes you would have taken it, because you are not the manager.

I thought you wanted us to back Ten Hag? How do you know Ten Hag didn't go to the board and say, I have seen pre season, I have seen the first 3/4 games, I am not convinced about Diallo, Pellestri, Sancho, get me Antony at all costs.

Look, I will not argue about the Glazers, we all know they are shit owners.

What really is frustrating is fans taking this narrative and running with it without knowledge. The footballing structure has been changed since last year, which is why we opted for Ten Hag and not Poch or Conte, which the old structure would have gone for.

So you want the club to buy players and give them to the manager? The plan for the summer was to give the manager his options because we had 4 months prior sacked some scouts and other personnel at the club.

The clubs plan was to have Rangnick, Ten Hag got asked and he refused that option. I suggest you go and watch Ten Hag's first presser where he said, he analyses players himself. Giving Ten Hag the summer is not incompetence, it actually is the reason why he has improved us so much.
You are speculating that ETH was okay with spending that money on Antony and not having money to spend in January. For all we know he could have told there would be money in January only to find out there was 5 million pounds.

Backing the manager does not equate to do everything he wants. Again this problem is solved by having competent football people at the club who can provide input and disagree with ETH.

The GM or director of football along with the manager are in charge of recruitment. It's not that complicated and doesn't mean i want the club to buy players and give them to the manager. It is a collaborative decision made by people who understand the player landscape, the way the team wants to play and the financial situation. It is completely unreasonable and incompetent to put it all on ETH at the start of his tenure which also happened to be the worst starting point of any united manager since Fergie.

ETH refused Rangnick because the players and Rangnick had a broken relationship, it doesn't mean he would have refused Van der Sar or any other competent person in the role. He did not want to be saddled with Ralfs statements about the current squad and wanted a clean non toxic slate.

If you can't see that what I've bolded is a symptom of the incompetence of the club then we aren't going to agree. Hey ETH so we've sacked our entire scouting department and the people left have no clue about football so just pick your targets and we'll spend whatever to get them mate. If ETH wasn't doing a good job that could have been football suicide. Another Maguire/AWB summer this year and we'd be up shits creek.

I want the manager to be supported and I also want the club to be competent. It's not that complicated. We want to be at the top level even after ETH goes so the structures need to be in place. Spending your entire budget in the summer and having nothing left to spend in January is not smart whatever way you slice it. The fact that Manchester united can only afford loan signings in any window is not good financial planning any way you slice it. Hiring ETH is why he's improved us so much not because we allowed him to spunk the whole budget in the summer. Here's a crazy idea, plan your finances so you can spend big in the summer and still have 20-30 million left to spend in January.
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
You are speculating that ETH was okay with spending that money on Antony and not having money to spend in January. For all we know he could have told there would be money in January only to find out there was 5 million pounds.

Backing the manager does not equate to do everything he wants. Again this problem is solved by having competent football people at the club who can provide input and disagree with ETH.

The GM or director of football along with the manager are in charge of recruitment. It's not that complicated and doesn't mean i want the club to buy players and give them to the manager. It is a collaborative decision made by people who understand the player landscape, the way the team wants to play and the financial situation. It is completely unreasonable and incompetent to put it all on ETH at the start of his tenure which also happened to be the worst starting point of any united manager since Fergie.

ETH refused Rangnick because the players and Rangnick had a broken relationship, it doesn't mean he would have refused Van der Sar or any other competent person in the role. He did not want to be saddled with Ralfs statements about the current squad and wanted a clean non toxic slate.

If you can't see that what I've bolded is a symptom of the incompetence of the club then we aren't going to agree. Hey ETH so we've sacked our entire scouting department and the people left have no clue about football so just pick your targets and we'll spend whatever to get them mate. If ETH wasn't doing a good job that could have been football suicide. Another Maguire/AWB summer this year and we'd be up shits creek.

I want the manager to be supported and I also want the club to be competent. It's not that complicated. We want to be at the top level even after ETH goes so the structures need to be in place. Spending your entire budget in the summer and having nothing left to spend in January is not smart whatever way you slice it. The fact that Manchester united can only afford loan signings in any window is not good financial planning any way you slice it. Hiring ETH is why he's improved us so much not because we allowed him to spunk the whole budget in the summer. Here's a crazy idea, plan your finances so you can spend big in the summer and still have 20-30 million left to spend in January.
Right, so I am speculating on things but what you are saying has come from your conversation with Ten Hag right?

All I can do is speculate on the evidence infront of me. In respects to Antony, the information I have seen and taken is as follows. Ten Hag worked with Antony, went to pre season, saw holes in the team. We started the season with Elanga playing, we lost games and Ten Hag realised with Martial injuries, Ronaldo being shit, he needs someone he trusts, a player who he has worked with. The club wont spend that money on a player if the manager does no Okay it. He would have been told that, look we don't have that much money but we could go extra but Jan will have to be a struggle, we dont know.

Who said it was all on the manager? as Ten Hag said, Antony has been on United's list before he came, Casemiro was not a Ten Hag signing, so clearly it was a joint effort by the club. In respects to Licha, Ten Hag wanted a specific player in there so we went for him.

Okay, your comment about Van De Sar shows you don't actually know how Ajax operated. That says it all for me. I will tell you though, It was more Overmars who worked with Ten Hag.

Again, clearly you have no clue what was happening at United, we did not sack the whole scouting network. So you wanted the club to say Ten Hag we have hired you, here are the players we feel work for you because we can read your brain and we know what players you need more than you, so here is the choices.

So you are assuming that all of the summer signings were a Ten Hag signing, its not like United have ever scouted Antony, Casemiro, Eriksen, of which 2 were already on Uniteds list from before.

So it is the same board that you are criticising that hired Ten Hag, you know that right? So clearly the non footballing people know something about football to hire him and not Poch or Conte.

You also do realise football is a changing dynamic, after the window Arnold came out and said we went overboard and dont expect to see that kind of window in the next.

Since then the glazers also want to sell, so ofcourse less money is available. Stop being a spoilt child screaming Daddy I want I want.
 

Desert Eagle

Punjabi Dude
Joined
Sep 25, 2006
Messages
16,778
Right, so I am speculating on things but what you are saying has come from your conversation with Ten Hag right?

All I can do is speculate on the evidence infront of me. In respects to Antony, the information I have seen and taken is as follows. Ten Hag worked with Antony, went to pre season, saw holes in the team. We started the season with Elanga playing, we lost games and Ten Hag realised with Martial injuries, Ronaldo being shit, he needs someone he trusts, a player who he has worked with. The club wont spend that money on a player if the manager does no Okay it. He would have been told that, look we don't have that much money but we could go extra but Jan will have to be a struggle, we dont know.

Who said it was all on the manager? as Ten Hag said, Antony has been on United's list before he came, Casemiro was not a Ten Hag signing, so clearly it was a joint effort by the club. In respects to Licha, Ten Hag wanted a specific player in there so we went for him.

Okay, your comment about Van De Sar shows you don't actually know how Ajax operated. That says it all for me. I will tell you though, It was more Overmars who worked with Ten Hag.

Again, clearly you have no clue what was happening at United, we did not sack the whole scouting network. So you wanted the club to say Ten Hag we have hired you, here are the players we feel work for you because we can read your brain and we know what players you need more than you, so here is the choices.

So you are assuming that all of the summer signings were a Ten Hag signing, its not like United have ever scouted Antony, Casemiro, Eriksen, of which 2 were already on Uniteds list from before.

So it is the same board that you are criticising that hired Ten Hag, you know that right? So clearly the non footballing people know something about football to hire him and not Poch or Conte.

You also do realise football is a changing dynamic, after the window Arnold came out and said we went overboard and dont expect to see that kind of window in the next.

Since then the glazers also want to sell, so ofcourse less money is available. Stop being a spoilt child screaming Daddy I want I want.
Stop being a Glazer bitch and making excuses for their incompetence. FSG want to sell , somehow they can still spend money.

Arnold is the one who went overboard on last minute signings after doing feck all for the first month and a half of the window. Antony and Martinez could have been had cheaper if they were competent. Nobody expects us to spend 200 plus million in January but to have no money is pathetic and embarrassing. The board have done one thing right in the past decade, Woohoo incredible. Anyways we're going around in circles and
P.S I am not into discussion = will not reply back
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
Stop being a Glazer bitch and making excuses for their incompetence. FSG want to sell , somehow they can still spend money.

Arnold is the one who went overboard on last minute signings after doing feck all for the first month and a half of the window. Antony and Martinez could have been had cheaper if they were competent. Nobody expects us to spend 200 plus million in January but to have no money is pathetic and embarrassing. The board have done one thing right in the past decade, Woohoo incredible. Anyways we're going around in circles and
P.S I am not into discussion = will not reply back
Oh yes, saying the truth that fans cant hear = Glazer bitch. FSG want to sell, they spent money, correct. Unfortunately, again you clearly read only what fits your narrative.

FSG are looking like having a part sale, United are looking at a full sale, you dont need to do business to understand what that means.

Liverpool selling spent 137m euros this season.
United shit owners dont spend money spent 240m euros

So you were involved with negotiations to know that Antony and Martinez would be cheaper right? Didnt Arsenal offer Ajax £40m which was rejected? or you didnt see that cause it doesnt fit your narrative?

Go read Fabrizio, who also said, no way Ajax would have sold Antony for £60m. Again stop making things up without evidence.
 

spiriticon

Full Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
7,384
I'm slightly concerned at the lack of rotation, but I think of it this way: If we really want to be challenging on multiple fronts as a top team should, the players need to get used to playing 2 games a week for most of the season anyway.

If we run out of gas this season, no worries, hopefully next season we'll be fitter.
 

tenpoless

Full Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
16,176
Location
Fabinho's forehead
I can see what's he's trying to do. Arsenal is too far ahead and City is still a top side however you wanna look at it. These two will do better than us over the course of a season realistically.
It's better to win a Mickey Mouse treble than putting everything into PL and not winning anything. Maybe that's why he keeps putting strong teams in all comps. He's hungry for those trophies.
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
5,932
Supports
Hannover 96
I can see what's he's trying to do. Arsenal is too far ahead and City is still a top side however you wanna look at it. These two will do better than us over the course of a season realistically.
It's better to win a Mickey Mouse treble than putting everything into PL and not winning anything. Maybe that's why he keeps putting strong teams in all comps. He's hungry for those trophies.
I like seeing this. It's just what I was advocating for and quite often criticised for in this forum.

Winning stuff creates winners, and experience in winning stuff (even if it's the smaller cups) is valuable in future decisive games.

That Real Madrid squad last year would never have won the CL last season if the players had the same quality but didn't have the experince of winning it multiple times before.
 
Joined
Nov 5, 2012
Messages
3,369
Location
Learn me a booke
Right, so I am speculating on things but what you are saying has come from your conversation with Ten Hag right?

All I can do is speculate on the evidence infront of me. In respects to Antony, the information I have seen and taken is as follows. Ten Hag worked with Antony, went to pre season, saw holes in the team. We started the season with Elanga playing, we lost games and Ten Hag realised with Martial injuries, Ronaldo being shit, he needs someone he trusts, a player who he has worked with. The club wont spend that money on a player if the manager does no Okay it. He would have been told that, look we don't have that much money but we could go extra but Jan will have to be a struggle, we dont know.

Who said it was all on the manager? as Ten Hag said, Antony has been on United's list before he came, Casemiro was not a Ten Hag signing, so clearly it was a joint effort by the club. In respects to Licha, Ten Hag wanted a specific player in there so we went for him.

Okay, your comment about Van De Sar shows you don't actually know how Ajax operated. That says it all for me. I will tell you though, It was more Overmars who worked with Ten Hag.

Again, clearly you have no clue what was happening at United, we did not sack the whole scouting network. So you wanted the club to say Ten Hag we have hired you, here are the players we feel work for you because we can read your brain and we know what players you need more than you, so here is the choices.

So you are assuming that all of the summer signings were a Ten Hag signing, its not like United have ever scouted Antony, Casemiro, Eriksen, of which 2 were already on Uniteds list from before.

So it is the same board that you are criticising that hired Ten Hag, you know that right? So clearly the non footballing people know something about football to hire him and not Poch or Conte.

You also do realise football is a changing dynamic, after the window Arnold came out and said we went overboard and dont expect to see that kind of window in the next.

Since then the glazers also want to sell, so ofcourse less money is available. Stop being a spoilt child screaming Daddy I want I want.
Good post, but how do you explain Ten Haags scalp wounds?
 

roseguy64

Full Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2010
Messages
12,172
Location
Jamaica
Indeed, not a chance in hell Antony wasn’t a Ten Hag signing. It’s much more likely the board were against it and ETH put pressure on.

£80m is crazy money but that’s football nowadays, plus Ajax had no reason to sell so we needed to give them one.

Whatever you think of Antony if we hadn’t signed for that position we’d be fecked this season. Sancho has been out for months, Pellistri clearly isn’t ready (still not sure if he will make it in the PL despite his obvious talent) and Amad while having a great season now was coming off the back of a disastrous loan with Rangers.

We basically only had Sancho, Rashford, an injury prone Martial (returning from a disastrous loan at Sevilla) and a toxic Ronaldo to work with at the start of the season.
My only real problem with the Antony signing is that multiple sources have said we could have gotten him for cheaper earlier in the window. Not for a small fee mind you but one that would have left us able to have some wiggle room now.
We balked at the price and then went back in late. We backed him with the other signings but for some reason were hesitant about Antony and paying 50/60m for him and ended up paying 80.
 

roseguy64

Full Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2010
Messages
12,172
Location
Jamaica
Stop being a Glazer bitch and making excuses for their incompetence. FSG want to sell , somehow they can still spend money.

Arnold is the one who went overboard on last minute signings after doing feck all for the first month and a half of the window. Antony and Martinez could have been had cheaper if they were competent. Nobody expects us to spend 200 plus million in January but to have no money is pathetic and embarrassing. The board have done one thing right in the past decade, Woohoo incredible. Anyways we're going around in circles and
P.S I am not into discussion = will not reply back
I agree that Antony could have been bought for cheaper.
Not so for Martinez. We weren't the only club in for him. Arsenal had their similar-priced bids rejected too. Looks like we attempted the similar thing we did what the Malacia signing where another club was in for him then we paid a little bit more and got him. That didn't work for Martinez. We got him at the price he was available for, nothing less would have worked.
 

LordSpud

Full Member
Joined
May 22, 2017
Messages
2,231
Looks like he's going to have to make do with what he's got now until the summer. A parting gift from the Glazers. Maybe he needs to start prioritising the different competitions instead of praying for a miracle and hoping everyone stays fit for the next 4 months?
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
Looks like he's going to have to make do with what he's got now until the summer. A parting gift from the Glazers. Maybe he needs to start prioritising the different competitions instead of praying for a miracle and hoping everyone stays fit for the next 4 months?
There are multiple facets to this. People talk about needing to prioritise in different competitions, is all weird for me.

Well firstly, I dont know how many people fail to understand Ten Hag doesn't like to rotate much. If everyone was fit, he would still play similar teams.

People are crying that McTominay is Casemiro's understudy but what do you expect? A WC DM to sit on the bench hoping for Casemiro to get injured?

We already have a list of injuries to Dalot, Shaw, VDB, Eriksen, Martial and Sancho unavailable. So its clear we have been coping with the injuries, why can we not cope going forward?

People keep saying we need a Bruno replacement but how often did Donny play when he was fit in the first part of the season?

How often has Pellestri played? How many games has Garnacho started?
 

Mr.Hik

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 15, 2022
Messages
161
He would rotate more but he probably watched all our games from last season. People are fast to forget some games with McFred, Lindelof and Maguire combo.
ETH made mistakes and will make more, every manager does, but people need to relax.
Top 4 ruined modern fans. It does my head when I read lets throw FA cup away. I bet my ass that Case would prefer to win oldest competition in the world than finishing top 4.
I wont change peoples minds, some are just misserable cnuts(like my parents) but at least enjoy the ride. We are on something.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,327
I can see what's he's trying to do. Arsenal is too far ahead and City is still a top side however you wanna look at it. These two will do better than us over the course of a season realistically.
It's better to win a Mickey Mouse treble than putting everything into PL and not winning anything. Maybe that's why he keeps putting strong teams in all comps. He's hungry for those trophies.
Oh yeah that's definitely not a bad thing,however find it hard to believe he isn't desperate for midfielder on loan with injuries to Eriksen & Donny. Why on earth aren't they willing to do it when we are threadbare in terms of quality there
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
He would rotate more but he probably watched all our games from last season. People are fast to forget some games with McFred, Lindelof and Maguire combo.
Right, a nice way to select the players you dont like to form a narrative.

So how come you didn't include players like Shaw, Rashford, Bruno, Sancho, Martial in the list, in most games were the combo included in the McFred, Lindelof, Maguire combo?

Why is it that people forget how bad those players were too?
 

maxtrash

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 15, 2014
Messages
39
Looks like he's going to have to make do with what he's got now until the summer. A parting gift from the Glazers. Maybe he needs to start prioritising the different competitions instead of praying for a miracle and hoping everyone stays fit for the next 4 months?
somehow this doesn't add up. So after getting this far in the tournament giving up to get 4th place in the competition? In that case we shouldn't have even started competing in that stupid Carabao cup. By now it's the moment to grab that trophy and reap the benefits from it
 

LordSpud

Full Member
Joined
May 22, 2017
Messages
2,231
somehow this doesn't add up. So after getting this far in the tournament giving up to get 4th place in the competition? In that case we shouldn't have even started competing in that stupid Carabao cup. By now it's the moment to grab that trophy and reap the benefits from it
I'm not stating which ones to prioritise over the other but basically we dont have the squad to do all 4
 

florisW

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 21, 2022
Messages
102
Supports
Ajax
Right, so I am speculating on things but what you are saying has come from your conversation with Ten Hag right?

All I can do is speculate on the evidence infront of me. In respects to Antony, the information I have seen and taken is as follows. Ten Hag worked with Antony, went to pre season, saw holes in the team. We started the season with Elanga playing, we lost games and Ten Hag realised with Martial injuries, Ronaldo being shit, he needs someone he trusts, a player who he has worked with. The club wont spend that money on a player if the manager does no Okay it. He would have been told that, look we don't have that much money but we could go extra but Jan will have to be a struggle, we dont know.

Who said it was all on the manager? as Ten Hag said, Antony has been on United's list before he came, Casemiro was not a Ten Hag signing, so clearly it was a joint effort by the club. In respects to Licha, Ten Hag wanted a specific player in there so we went for him.

Okay, your comment about Van De Sar shows you don't actually know how Ajax operated. That says it all for me. I will tell you though, It was more Overmars who worked with Ten Hag.

Again, clearly you have no clue what was happening at United, we did not sack the whole scouting network. So you wanted the club to say Ten Hag we have hired you, here are the players we feel work for you because we can read your brain and we know what players you need more than you, so here is the choices.

So you are assuming that all of the summer signings were a Ten Hag signing, its not like United have ever scouted Antony, Casemiro, Eriksen, of which 2 were already on Uniteds list from before.

So it is the same board that you are criticising that hired Ten Hag, you know that right? So clearly the non footballing people know something about football to hire him and not Poch or Conte.

You also do realise football is a changing dynamic, after the window Arnold came out and said we went overboard and dont expect to see that kind of window in the next.

Since then the glazers also want to sell, so ofcourse less money is available. Stop being a spoilt child screaming Daddy I want I want.
[/QUOTE
I strongly disagree, licha called ten hag and said , i am leaving ajax, i would rather follow you. Result. He cam. Do you think that Erik analyzed the squad he saw that he need the spirit licha brought? He knows him from own experience. Same with anthony he nnow they are warriors
 

Eli Zee

Full Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2017
Messages
1,057
I fully believe ETH is the right manager for us and that there are less than 5 other managers in the world that would be able to get us the results he will get us this season and in future seasons
 

NLunited

Full Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2015
Messages
3,587
Location
US
The biggest mistakes the club made imo is not hiring the right managers after Van Gaal.

I believe LvG was the right guy initially, who lost the trust of the players and needed replacing for sure after two seasons.

A manager more in the mould of Van Gaal should have been hired, a winner with modern attacking football concepts which we have done six years later by hiring Ten Hag.

In that six years not much has been accomplished to make the team stronger. We were an absolute disgrace last season. No wonder no one was expecting much for this season.

The club now needs to commit to a new identity (which fits the old one imo) and style which should be implemented at all levels.

That includes hiring someone who can take care of transfer business, oversee scouting and the academy and so on, so Ten Hag can focus on winning matches. Of course the manager has a big say in transfer business, but it should not all come from Ten Hag.

It should also mean that the next manager hired after Ten Hag continues the same playing style and culture instead of tearing everything up alla Mourinho.

It is not right to rely on Ten Hag for everything. So, the sooner we make some decisions/changes the better.
 

Suedesi

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2001
Messages
23,866
Location
New York City
Keeps subbing off his own £80m player and never has the balls to do daring subs but instead keeps on taking off attackers for midfielders. I 100% agree we should not be too harsh on him due to it being his first year but at the same time, do not kid yourselves, if Spurs, Chelsea & Liverpool were not so shit this year we would be miles off top 4.

We are only 6 ahead of Contes miserable Spurs.....
And we're only 6 behind Pep's magnificent City
 

Mr.Hik

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 15, 2022
Messages
161
Right, a nice way to select the players you dont like to form a narrative.

So how come you didn't include players like Shaw, Rashford, Bruno, Sancho, Martial in the list, in most games were the combo included in the McFred, Lindelof, Maguire combo?

Why is it that people forget how bad those players were too?
They follow him because he is telling them win win win. Rashford is now hot player, probably 150m.
And what he is doing is with Sancho, he is class.
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
34,327
I fully believe ETH is the right manager for us and that there are less than 5 other managers in the world that would be able to get us the results he will get us this season and in future seasons
Too right and it's frustrating he couldn’t get a couple of loan midfielders so we could provide some restbite to Casa & Bruno/Eriksen
 

Dominos

Full Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
6,959
Location
Manchester
Keeps subbing off his own £80m player and never has the balls to do daring subs but instead keeps on taking off attackers for midfielders. I 100% agree we should not be too harsh on him due to it being his first year but at the same time, do not kid yourselves, if Spurs, Chelsea & Liverpool were not so shit this year we would be miles off top 4.

We are only 6 ahead of Contes miserable Spurs.....
This nonsense seems to be spouted every season for numerous clubs.

We're on course for 74 points at current PPG. 74 points gets you top 4 near enough every season with rare exceptions.

There's certainly never a case where 74 points would be "miles off top 4".
 

Skills

Snitch
Joined
Jan 17, 2012
Messages
42,010
There are multiple facets to this. People talk about needing to prioritise in different competitions, is all weird for me.

Well firstly, I dont know how many people fail to understand Ten Hag doesn't like to rotate much. If everyone was fit, he would still play similar teams.

People are crying that McTominay is Casemiro's understudy but what do you expect? A WC DM to sit on the bench hoping for Casemiro to get injured?

We already have a list of injuries to Dalot, Shaw, VDB, Eriksen, Martial and Sancho unavailable. So its clear we have been coping with the injuries, why can we not cope going forward?

People keep saying we need a Bruno replacement but how often did Donny play when he was fit in the first part of the season?

How often has Pellestri played? How many games has Garnacho started?
Exactly good post. This whole depth thing for the sake of it is stupid.

Very few managers are actually capable of rotating and managing a big squad. The vast majority prefer a smaller group
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
Exactly good post. This whole depth thing for the sake of it is stupid.

Very few managers are actually capable of rotating and managing a big squad. The vast majority prefer a smaller group
People want players for the sake of having players and it is frustrating. If you look, the reason most United fans are getting upset is not because of our squad, its more because of the spending from other teams.

How many teams that are successful go and spend big in Jan?

Liverpool who were in for all competitions last season, didnt have 3 players in each position, their squad was not too dissimilar to ours. When you are winning, you want to play, when a team is doing well, players also seem to get injured less.
 

BlueHaze

New Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
4,453
This nonsense seems to be spouted every season for numerous clubs.

We're on course for 74 points at current PPG. 74 points gets you top 4 near enough every season with rare exceptions.

There's certainly never a case where 74 points would be "miles off top 4".
I can accept that can be viewed as nonsense but so is the bolded part of your own post... "We're on course x amount of points" also gets spouted a lot and we all know things can change very quickly in football. Best to judge at the end of the season.

Post you and the other guy quouted was probably after the palace game where I was pissed about his subs..
 

erikcred

Full Member
Joined
May 6, 2022
Messages
1,396
And we're only 6 behind Pep's magnificent City
This City team are not really what we should be aspiring to be.

City are having a terrible season with players being complacent according to Pep and now they're even falling out with him.

The new benchmark is Arsenal and we showed we can go toe to toe over 90 mins. Now we need to aim to outdo them over the rest of the season.
 

hatchetmac

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
158
This City team are not really what we should be aspiring to be.

City are having a terrible season with players being complacent according to Pep and now they're even falling out with him.

The new benchmark is Arsenal and we showed we can go toe to toe over 90 mins. Now we need to aim to outdo them over the rest of the season.
Not much chance of that with Fred and McT in midfield now Eriksen is out until April.
 

Glorio

Full Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2020
Messages
4,491
There are multiple facets to this. People talk about needing to prioritise in different competitions, is all weird for me.

Well firstly, I dont know how many people fail to understand Ten Hag doesn't like to rotate much. If everyone was fit, he would still play similar teams.

People are crying that McTominay is Casemiro's understudy but what do you expect? A WC DM to sit on the bench hoping for Casemiro to get injured?

We already have a list of injuries to Dalot, Shaw, VDB, Eriksen, Martial and Sancho unavailable. So its clear we have been coping with the injuries, why can we not cope going forward?

People keep saying we need a Bruno replacement but how often did Donny play when he was fit in the first part of the season?

How often has Pellestri played? How many games has Garnacho started?
I don't know how many folks are looking for world class backups. We just need adequate replacements that can come in and compete for a position without the control and performance levels of the team taking a nosedive with square pegs in round holes.

At most positions we actually have these and we've seen many replacements come in and make a case E.g.
DDG/Heaton
Dalot/AWB
Shaw/Malacia
Varane/Lindelof (Maguire)
Martinez/Shaw*
Eriksen/Fred
Antony/Pellistri (Sancho)
Rashford/Garnacho/Sancho
Martial/Weghorst
Bruno/Eriksen*
(* = has a different primary position but understands and plays well in the one in question)

However, intriguingly with the example you mentioned, i.e. Casemiro at DM, we definitely need a backup. Not necessarily quality-wise, but someone who can play the role of a 6 and understands it. We have no one else that can. Perhaps Mainoo steps into that, but will have to wait and see.


Wout is a perfect example of someone who is not top tier, but knows the job they're competing for. I suspect the lack of another CF and DM to replace the starters has been one of the main reasons for the worrying sharp drop in control and performances that seem to really come to the fore once the starting DM and CF leave the field.
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
I don't know how many folks are looking for world class backups. We just need adequate replacements that can come in and compete for a position without the control and performance levels of the team taking a nosedive with square pegs in round holes.

At most positions we actually have these and we've seen many replacements come in and make a case E.g.
DDG/Heaton
Dalot/AWB
Shaw/Malacia
Varane/Lindelof (Maguire)
Martinez/Shaw*
Eriksen/Fred
Antony/Pellistri (Sancho)
Rashford/Garnacho/Sancho
Martial/Weghorst
Bruno/Eriksen*
(* = has a different primary position but understands and plays well in the one in question)

However, intriguingly with the example you mentioned, i.e. Casemiro at DM, we definitely need a backup. Not necessarily quality-wise, but someone who can play the role of a 6 and understands it. We have no one else that can. Perhaps Mainoo steps into that, but will have to wait and see.


Wout is a perfect example of someone who is not top tier, but knows the job they're competing for. I suspect the lack of another CF and DM to replace the starters has been one of the main reasons for the worrying sharp drop in control and performances that seem to really come to the fore once the starting DM and CF leave the field.
That is my point though, people keep saying the drop of in quality but obviously you will have that, Casemiro will play 80% of the games when fit. You cannot sign someone for that instance what if he is injured for 4 months.
 

Glorio

Full Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2020
Messages
4,491
That is my point though, people keep saying the drop of in quality but obviously you will have that, Casemiro will play 80% of the games when fit. You cannot sign someone for that instance what if he is injured for 4 months.
To be honest, I think the drop off in quality is so stark because we simply don't have another 6. Casemiro is world class, but a functional PL level number 6 that knows how to protect his back four with a calm head and can make simple passes to more expressive players will do (basically - not McTominay).

To your point, that player may only start 20% of games, but will probably come on in the 60th minute of many games across the season and keep us ticking over like Fred does for Eriksen.
 

Dominos

Full Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
6,959
Location
Manchester
I can accept that can be viewed as nonsense but so is the bolded part of your own post... "We're on course x amount of points" also gets spouted a lot and we all know things can change very quickly in football. Best to judge at the end of the season.

Post you and the other guy quouted was probably after the palace game where I was pissed about his subs..
Deliberately missing the point here. I'm simply looking at our PPG and whether we'd usually be in the top 4 at this stage, the extrapolation is just to prove my point that we're in a top 4 position at the current stage.

Forget what we finish on this season because it can't be predicted. 39 points after 20 games would never have you miles behind top 4, that was just a complete lie.
 

Rightnr

Wants players fined for winning away.
Joined
Jan 25, 2015
Messages
13,881
Ok, focus on the Carabao and the league. Everything else is low priority or we are in danger of letting a great season drift away from us.
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,554
To be honest, I think the drop off in quality is so stark because we simply don't have another 6. Casemiro is world class, but a functional PL level number 6 that knows how to protect his back four with a calm head and can make simple passes to more expressive players will do (basically - not McTominay).

To your point, that player may only start 20% of games, but will probably come on in the 60th minute of many games across the season and keep us ticking over like Fred does for Eriksen.
I agree, if Ten Hag can get one of the academy lads moulded in that, it would be good to see.

Yeah and Fred at the moment is content with that role, we need to find something like him to play DM. Think we need to go buy 2 CM's and a ST in the summer anyway.
 

bosskeano

Full Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2020
Messages
5,110
I don't know how many folks are looking for world class backups. We just need adequate replacements that can come in and compete for a position without the control and performance levels of the team taking a nosedive with square pegs in round holes.

At most positions we actually have these and we've seen many replacements come in and make a case E.g.
DDG/Heaton
Dalot/AWB
Shaw/Malacia
Varane/Lindelof (Maguire)
Martinez/Shaw*
Eriksen/Fred
Antony/Pellistri (Sancho)
Rashford/Garnacho/Sancho
Martial/Weghorst
Bruno/Eriksen*
(* = has a different primary position but understands and plays well in the one in question)

However, intriguingly with the example you mentioned, i.e. Casemiro at DM, we definitely need a backup. Not necessarily quality-wise, but someone who can play the role of a 6 and understands it. We have no one else that can. Perhaps Mainoo steps into that, but will have to wait and see.


Wout is a perfect example of someone who is not top tier, but knows the job they're competing for. I suspect the lack of another CF and DM to replace the starters has been one of the main reasons for the worrying sharp drop in control and performances that seem to really come to the fore once the starting DM and CF leave the field.
obvious lack of depth at the 6....we don't have a guy who can play the role that casemiro does which is hwy we brought him in. Fred and Scott have proven they can't play that role unless they are playing next to Casemrio.

The fwd line is the one area where there is a MAJOR issue especially right now with Sancho going thru his mental struggles. We basically have 3 guys who we can work with and the rest have clear concerns.

Pellestri, Garnacho and Elanga while they provide depth are clearly not ready to contribute on a regular basis against top teams. Garnacho is clearly closer than the other two.

Martial is a fuking waste of time simply because he has one or two good games on the trot and then shits the bed for a month.

Antony and Wout are new to the club and/or league but can provide quality

Rashy is the main man.



EtH is getting the best out of these guys in very difficult circumstances but he has made it clear that we need more attacking options and not just adequate replacements as you've stated. Adequate we already have with the 3 young players, we need legit quality.
 

NoPace

Full Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2014
Messages
9,340
So I'm guessing more of a pure 4-3-3 than the 4-2-3-1 for the rest of the year, since Ten Hag prefers Fred further forward and Sabitzer is more comfortable a little higher in midfield. More space centrally for the striker and Bruno a tad wider and deeper maybe, with Antony on the touchline and Dalot/WanB tucked in to help in midfield. So ultimately this hurts Antony a little as we reduce overlapping options for him.

All the more reason to replace McTominay with a proper DM, but I would be shocked if we move him last minute with Eriksen out.