Liveship for me by a wide margin.
I didn't particularly like Tawny Man because The Fool happens to be my favourite character in the series, and I didn't like how Fitz treated HER one little bit.
Her? I thought that their gender was deliberately left ambiguous, and is probably gender fluid, but I thought that biologically the Fool is a male. Isn’t something in the last book where it is revealed that the Fool has a child but didn’t give birth to it, or I am making things up?